Herrington v. C.I.R., 87-4770
Decision Date | 13 September 1988 |
Docket Number | No. 87-4770,87-4770 |
Citation | 854 F.2d 755 |
Parties | -5648, 88-2 USTC P 9507 Clemon J. and Ivy C. HERRINGTON, Petitioners-Appellants, v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, Respondent-Appellee. |
Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Fifth Circuit |
Robert Jackson Herrington, Baton Rouge, La., for petitioners-appellants.
Clemon Herrington and Ivy Herrington, Alexander, La., pro se.
Kenneth L. Greene, Michael L. Paup, Chief Appellate Section Tax Div., Dept. of Justice, William F. Nelson, Chief Counsel, I.R.S., Roger M. Olsen, William S. Rose, Richard Farber, Washington, D.C., for respondent-appellee.
Appeal from the Decision of the United States Tax Court.
Before KING and JOHNSON, Circuit Judges, and LITTLE, * District Judge.
Taxpayers appeal a Tax Court decision upholding gain on the second half of a "straddle" transaction adjudged a sham by the Tax Court in a companion case. Because we hold that the "duty of consistency" doctrine estops the taxpayers from relying on the sham transaction holding, we affirm.
From 1976 through 1978, Clemon and Ivy Herrington carried out a series of "straddle" transactions on the London Metal Exchange. These transactions made use of futures contracts pairing "put options" (rights to sell) and "call options" (rights to buy) in such a way as to produce a loss in one year and a gain in the following year. The straddles offered the taxpayer the advantage that the loss in the first year could be deducted as an ordinary loss, but the gain in the second year could be reported as capital gain and taxed at a lower rate than the corresponding loss.
On their 1976 tax return, the Herringtons reported and deducted a $60,244 loss from the first leg of a London Metal Exchange straddle. In 1977, the Herringtons reported a $54,231 capital gain corresponding to the 1976 loss. Also in 1977, the Herringtons reported and deducted $60,040 as the first leg of a second straddle. The Herringtons' 1978 tax return reported a capital gain of $59,686, closing out the second straddle transaction.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) audited the Herringtons' 1977 and 1978 tax returns, but allowed the statute of limitations period to expire on their 1976 tax return. Finding the 1977 to 1978 straddle to be a sham transaction without economic substance, the Service assessed a deficiency. The IRS Appeals Board affirmed the deficiency. The Herringtons petitioned for a redetermination to the United States Tax Court, and that court consolidated their case with more than a thousand other cases involving London Metal Exchange straddles. Glass v. Commissioner, the consolidated case, found that the type of straddle transaction engaged in by the Herringtons and the other taxpayers on the London Metal Exchange was a sham and had no real economic purpose other than tax avoidance. 87 T.C. 1087 (1986). Specifically, the Tax Court stated:
In conclusion, we hold that the London Option Transaction--petitioners' multiple and complex tax straddle scheme encompassing prearranged results--lacked economic substance and was a sham. Petitioners consequently may not deduct the losses claimed by them in Year One of their straddle transactions. It follows, of course, that since the straddle transactions were a sham, gains reported by petitioners in Year Two and thereafter do not constitute taxable income to them, and we so hold.
87 T.C. at 1177 (emphasis added). The Tax Court then determined that the Herringtons owed a deficiency of $32,417.57 in the 1977 tax year, attributable to the 1977 capital gain leg of the 1976-1977 straddle. It is this first straddle that is the subject of the instant appeal by the Herringtons.
The Herringtons argue that because the Tax Court has held that both the gains and losses in the London Metal Exchange straddles "lacked economic substance," the court cannot, without contradiction, treat their 1977 straddle gain as real and tax it. The Herringtons acknowledge that they received a loss deduction for the first leg of the same straddle in 1976, but they point out that the IRS cannot undo this loss deduction because the statute of limitations has run on the 1976 tax year. While the Herringtons admit that some inequity would result if they were allowed to deduct the 1976 loss without reporting the corresponding 1977 gain, they argue that this inequity is inherent in any statute of limitations.
Of course, the IRS has not technically violated the statute of limitations, since its gain characterization affects the 1977, not the 1976, tax year. More importantly, the Herringtons are precluded from raising the sham transaction argument by a type of estoppel developed in tax cases, known as "quasi estoppel" or the "duty of consistency." The Supreme Court has long held that general principles of estoppel apply in tax cases. R.H. Stearns Co. v. United States, 291 U.S. 54, 54 S.Ct. 325, 78 L.Ed. 647 (1934); Magee v. United States, 282 U.S. 432, 51 S.Ct. 195, 75 L.Ed. 442 (1931). The duty of consistency is a doctrine that prevents a taxpayer from taking one position one year, and a contrary position in a later year, after the limitations period has run in the first year. Union Carbide Corp. v. United States, 612 F.2d 558, 566, 222 Ct.Cl. 75 (1979); Beltzer v. United States, 495 F.2d 211 (8th Cir.1974); Mayfair Minerals, Inc. v. C.I.R., 456 F.2d 622 (5th Cir.1972); Crosley Corp. v. United States, 229 F.2d 376, 380-81 (6th Cir.1956); Johnson v. C.I.R., 162 F.2d 844 (5th Cir.1947); Joplin Bros. Mobile Homes, Inc. v. United States, 524 F.Supp. 800, 803 (W.D.Mo.1981). 1
For example, in Beltzer, the taxpayer inherited stock, had the stock valued, and paid estate taxes on that value. Several years later, after the statute of limitations had run, the taxpayer sold the stock, had its value at the time of acquisition recalculated, and claimed the recalculated, higher value as his basis. The court held the taxpayer to his original, lower basis. Beltzer, 495 F.2d at 212-13. Similarly, in Mayfair Minerals, the taxpayer had accrued and deducted refunds to be paid to its customers. 456 F.2d 622. Later, after the statute of limitations had run, the taxpayer learned that it had not been liable for the refunds. The IRS characterized this event as the extinguishing of a liability, equivalent to realizing taxable income. The taxpayer argued that the liability had not really existed in the earlier year, and,...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Banks v. C.I.R.
... ... Zack v. Comm'r, 291 F.3d 407, 412 (6th Cir.2002) (citing MTS Int'l, Inc. v. Comm'r, 169 F.3d 1018, 1021 (6th Cir.1999)). We will conclude ... to recharacterize the situation in such a way as to harm the Commissioner.'") (quoting Herrington v. Comm'r, 854 F.2d 755, 758 (5th Cir.1988)) ... --------------- ... MOORE, ... ...
-
Lerman v. C.I.R.
... ... Comm'r, 90 T.C. 975 (1988), aff'd, 931 F.2d 59 (9th Cir.1991) (table), holding that since the London option-straddle transactions are economic shams devoid ... Comm'r, 862 F.2d 1486 (11th Cir.1989); Yosha v. Comm'r, 861 F.2d 494 (7th Cir.1988); Herrington v. Comm'r, 854 F.2d 755 (5th Cir.1988), cert. denied, 490 U.S. 1065, 109 S.Ct. 2062, 104 L.Ed.2d ... ...
-
Johnson v. Commissioner, Docket No. 546-83.
...v. Commissioner [88-2 USTC ¶ 9589], 861 F.2d 494 (7th Cir. 1988), affd. sub nom. Herrington v. Commissioner [88-1 USTC ¶ 9507], 854 F.2d 755 (5th Cir. 1988). See Lee v. Commissioner, supra at 917 ("The [London option] transactions * * * lacked economic substance. As such, they are outside t......
-
Marine v. Comm'r of Internal Revenue
... ... Commissioner, 814 F.2d 1363, 1375 (9th Cir. 1987) (Hall, J. dissenting), revg. 81 T.C. 855 (1983); Weimerskirch v. Commissioner, 596 F.2d 358, ... 492 (1984); Glass v. Commissioner, 87 T.C. 1087 (1986), affd. sub nom. Herrington v. Commissioner, 854 F.2d 755 (5th Cir. 1988), affd. sub nom. Yosha v. Commissioner, 861 F.2d 494 ... ...
-
Can the battle be won? Compaq, the sham transaction doctrine, and a critique of proposals to combat the corporate tax shelter dragon.
...a loss in year one and a gain in year two that was approximately equal to the year one loss), aff'd sub nom. Herrington v. Comm'r, 854 F.2d 755 (5th Cir. 1988), Yosha v. Comm'r, 861 F.2d 494 (7th Cir. 1988), Ratliff v. Comm'r, 865 F.2d 97 (6th Cir. 1989), Kirchman v. Comm'r, 862 F.2d 1486 (......
-
Disposable Personal Goodwill, Frosty the Snowman, and Martin Ice Cream All Melt Away in the Bright Sunlight of Analysis
...Co. v. Comm'r, 75 T.C. 497, 559-61 (1980). 88. Eagan v. United States, 80 F.3d 13, 17 (1st Cir. 1996) (quoting Herrington v. Comm'r, 854 F.2d 755, 758 (5th Cir. 89. Estate of Ashman v. Comm'r, 231 F.3d 541, 543 (9th Cir. 2000) (quoting Russell v. Rolfs, 893 F.2d 1033, 1037 (9th Cir. 1990)) ......
-
Comments on consistent treatment of qualified research expenditures in the base period for purposes of calculating the research tax credit.
...to the QRE it reported in the base-period years if those years are barred by the statute of limitations. See Herrington v. Commissioner, 854 F.2d 755 (5th Cir.), cert. denied, 109 S.Ct. 2062 This is not the case in Letter Ruling No. 9040002, where the taxpayer had consistently maintained th......