Hinderlider v. Town of Berthoud
| Court | Colorado Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | CAMPBELL, J. |
| Citation | Hinderlider v. Town of Berthoud, 77 Colo. 504, 238 P. 64 (Colo. 1925) |
| Decision Date | 15 June 1925 |
| Docket Number | 11072. |
| Parties | HINDERLIDER, State Engineer, et al. v. TOWN OF BERTHOUD. |
Department 3.
Error to District Court, Boulder County; Neil F. Graham, Judge.
Suit by the Town of Berthoud against M. C. Hinderlider, as State Engineer, and others. Decree for plaintiff, and defendants bring error.
Reversed with instructions.
Harry N. Haynes, of Greeley (Ralph L. Dougherty of Greeley, of counsel), for plaintiffs in error.
P. D Nelson, of Berthoud, and Stow & Stover and W. K. Lilley, all of Fort Collins, for defendant in error.
This is a controversy between the town of Berthoud, a municipal corporation, plaintiff in the action, and several ditch and reservoir companies. The state and division water officials of water district No. 4 are only nominal parties defendant. In 1883, in an appropriate statutory proceeding in this water district, priorities were awarded to the defendants' ditches or canals, and in 1890, in a supplementary proceeding, for their reservoirs. Additional priorities were thereafter awarded at different times. The plaintiff's waterworks system received its decree in 1912. The controversy here arises out of that part of the general irrigation decree of 1912 which established the rights of the town of Berthoud. The single general decree consisted of different paragraphs or clauses, a separate decree to each of the ditches and reservoirs to which rights were given. The decree to the system of the town was an award of 3 cubic feet of water per second of time as priority No. 1 for domestic purposes. One of its clauses provided that, temporarily, the town's appropriation might be diverted and carried by means of the Handy ditch, belonging to one of the defendants, during the irrigation season only, and until a pipe line should be constructed from the river to its impounding reservoir, which must be finished on or before January 1, 1920, and after the pipe line is finished the diversion and carriage shall be there through at all seasons of the year. Until the pipe line was, within the designated time, constructed, and at such times during the irrigation season as there was not sufficient other water flowing through the Handy ditch, by reason whereof the said 3 second cubic feet failed to supply at its said reservoirs sufficient water for the needs of the town, by reason of loss or seepage or evaporation as it was being carried through the Handy ditch, additional water not exceeding 6 second cubic feet might be temporarily diverted from the natural stream into the Handy ditch when required in amount sufficient to supply the needs of the town, and no more. After January 1, 1920, and prior thereto, if the pipe line of the town was theretofore extended to the river, the right to use the additional 6 cubic feet in order to supply sufficient head shall cease. The state water distributing officers are at all times to be governed by this decree in the distribution of water to the town.
At the outset of the discussion it is well to say that this part of the general 1912 decree was rendered upon a stipulation entered into between the town and the real defendants in this action, the owners of the irrigated lands. To avoid misapprehension, we observe that only the rights of the litigating parties under this clause of the general decree are before us at this time, and our decision in this case does not affect in any respect other parties than those who gave their consent to it. Whether other parties would or would not be bound by it is not a matter before us. The decree as entered in all respects conforms to the stipulation signed by the plaintiff town and the defendants. After its rendition and until the beginning of this action the water officials turned into the diverting canal the water awarded to the town, as fixed by the decree and in the manner thereby designated. The town did not complete its pipe line before January 1, 1920, or at all. One of the terms of the stipulation on which the decree was rendered is that the town on or before that day shall construct such a pipe line or water main from the river to the head of its present pipe line in the Handy ditch, of size and strength sufficient to carry economically from the river sufficient water to supply the needs of the town and its inhabitants for domestic and municipal purposes, on the condition that failure to construct the pipe line shall not work a forfeiture or otherwise affect the 3 second feet of water for which the decree provided. The only penalty to attach to such a failure was the loss of the right to use the additional 6 second feet above referred to, which right in any event shall terminate January 1, 1920. This stipulation was signed by the town of Berthoud by its mayor and recorder, and was executed by the defendants or their grantors. The finding of fact concerning the plaintiff's waterworks system, as made by the referee and adopted by the trial court, together with the decretal order and the stipulation in which appears the reason for requiring the town to build a pipe line, was that the Handy ditch through which its diversion was being made at the time of the decree is constructed through porous substances at different points along its course, so that when other water is being run in the ditch it is necessary to divert at the river head not to exceed 9 second feet to enable a sufficient quantity of water to be delivered at the head of the town's pipe line to supply the town with water for domestic purposes, and that not to exceed 3 second feet delivered at the town's present pipe line is ample supply for its actual present and prospective needs. The findings also recite that the present waterworks system of the town does not constitute facilities for economically supplying it with water for domestic purposes, and there is also a recital that the town had agreed, on or before January 1, to construct a pipe line as above indicated.
In August, 1921, complaint in this action was filed by the town to restrain the water commissioner and the defendants from refusing to divert under the decretal order not to exceed 9 second feet, and to command them to divert for plaintiff at the headgate of the Handy ditch this amount of water; for a decree that the stipulation mentioned is void, and that there be excised from the present decree the provision that after January 1, 1920, or prior thereto, if the pipe line shall theretofore be constructed, the right to use the additional 6 cubic feet per second shall cease and determine. The grounds upon which the relief is asked are thus summarized:
(1) The stipulation on which the decree was rendered was not the act of the town, because its board of trustees did not authorize it.
(2) The inhabitants of the town did not consent thereto or take part therein.
(3) That the pretended stipulation does not relate to any matter properly involved in the adjudication proceedings.
The plaintiff also stated that the cost of construction of the new pipe line would be more than one-fourth of the plaintiff's assessed valuation, and so great as to render it impossible for it to meet the conditions of forfeiture in the stipulation.
In the specification of the ground for the claim that the court did not have jurisdiction, but that it exceeded its powers in rendering this decree, it is said that in an adjudication proceeding the only power of the court is to decree the amount and volume of an appropriation and fix its priority number; that the court had no right to decree any temporary amount of water, and no power to decree any future method of use of water, or to fix any penalty or forfeiture to fail to build a pipe line. There was a general demurrer to the complaint by the defendant, which was overruled. A restraining order was issued, and a motion to dissolve it was denied. An answer was filed containing a number of defenses, in substance, that the attack by the plaintiff was a collateral attack on the decree; that no application for a review or a reargument of the decree has ever been made by the plaintiff, and therefore it is barred from prosecuting this action; that it seeks to escape the provisions of a decree to which it gave its consent at the time, and therefore is estopped to raise the question of the lack of jurisdiction of the court in rendering it. Some testimony was taken by both parties on the issues of fact joined, but we do not pause to discuss the evidence, for we think upon the admitted facts the judgment of the trial court in favor of the plaintiff must be reversed for the following, among other reasons, that the record discloses:
1. Loudon Irrigating Canal & Reservoir Co. v. Town of Berthoud 57 Colo. 374, 381, 140 P. 802, was a case between the town of Berthoud, plaintiff here, and one of the defendants in this action. The same decree was involved there that is now before us. We there held, against the contention of plaintiffs in error, and in favor of the defendant in error, the town of Berthoud, that a party will not be heard to attack the validity of a decree to which he has expressly consented, and that even allegations of departure from a statute in the statutory proceeding will not be considered. We do not see why, if the irrigation company, one of the defendants here, was not permitted to object to this same decree upon jurisdictional...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Salida School Dist. R-32-J v. Morrison
...proceeding establishes "estoppel by judicial act." See Peters v. Peters, 82 Colo. 503, 261 P. 874, 876 (1927); Hinderlider v. Town of Berthoud, 77 Colo. 504, 238 P. 64 (1925). That testimony is not part of the record in this case. See Eveready Freight Service v. Public Utilities Commission,......
-
Elliott v. Clement
...decree adjudicating water rights, and one of the parties, after enjoying the benefits of such decree, seeks to avoid it. Hinderlider v. Berthoud, 77 Colo. 504, 238 P. 64; Boulder etc. County Ditch Company v. Lower Boulder Ditch Company, 22 Colo. 115, 43 P. 540. A similar case is Denver City......
-
Consolidated Home Supply Ditch and Reservoir Co. v. Town of Berthoud
...be given a higher priority than irrigation use. Id. at 380, 140 P. at 804. 3 The decree was again before us in Hinderlider v. Town of Berthoud, 77 Colo. 504, 238 P. 64 (1925), and both Home Supply and Berthoud were parties. This time, Berthoud contested the validity of the decree, arguing t......
-
Peters v. Peters
... ... that the order was a final judgment. Hinderlider v. Berthoud, ... 77 Colo. 504, 512, 238 P. 64; Githens v. Githens, 78 Colo ... 102, 104, 239 P ... ...