Holbrook v. Holbrook
| Decision Date | 16 June 1965 |
| Citation | 240 Or. 567,403 P.2d 12 |
| Parties | Bertha Clyde HOLBROOK, Respondent. v. James W. HOLBROOK, Appellant |
| Court | Oregon Supreme Court |
Robert D. Lytle, Vale, argued the cause and filed briefs for appellant.
Max S. Taggart, Ontario, argued the cause and filed a brief for respondent.
Before McALLISTER, C. J., and PERRY, SLOAN, O'CONNELL, GOODWIN, DENECKE and HOLMAN, JJ.
Plaintiff seeks a declaratory decree declaring her to be the sole owner of a certain parcel of land. Defendant appeals from a decree for plaintiff.
Plaintiff, Bertha Clyde Holbrook, was the wife of William H. Holbrook. In contemplation of divorce they entered into a property settlement agreement which made provision for the disposition of the land in question which, at the time of the agreement, was owned by William and Bertha. The agreement provided in part that 'the parties shall be and become joint tenants with right of survivorship in the property.' The agreement contained the following paragraphs:
'It is further agreed that the said joint tenancy shall be accomplished by the parties executing a deed to their entire present estates in said property to Eleanor L. Anderson with instructions that she convey the same to the parties herein as joint tenants and not as tenants in common or as tenants by the entirety, but with right of survivorship between them, which right of survivorship shall continue without regard to whether or not a divorce shall be granted to one or the other of the parties.
'It is further understood and agreed that during the lifetime of the husband, he shall be entitled to have and receive all rents, issues and profits of the property above described in this paragraph with the duty to maintain the same and to pay all lawful taxes, liens and other charges and assessments on the same which shall accrue during his lifetime.
'At anytime during his lifetime the husband shall have the right to make a bonafide sale of the property at a reasonable price to any third person or party, and in event of such sale the wife shall join with him in such conveyance and shall be entitled to receive as her own property, one-half of the net principal and interest, if any, to be received from such sale.'
On October 22, 1958, William and Bertha executed a quitclaim deed to Eleanor L. Anderson and two months thereafter, William and Bertha were divorced. The following January, Eleanor L. Anderson quitclaimed to William and Bertha, describing them 'as joint tenants with right of survivorship and not as tenants in common.' Subsequently, on January 8, 1963, William conveyed to his nephew James W. Holbrook, an undivided one-half interest in the land in question. William died on November 3, 1963.
It is defendant's position that the deed from Eleanor Anderson to William H. Holbrook and Bertha Clyde Holbrook created a common law joint tenancy which was subject to severance. It is contended that the deed from William Holbrook to defendant, James W. Holbrook, effected a severance as a consequence of which James Holbrook and Bertha Holbrook held as tenants in common.
If, as defendant contends, the estate held by William and Bertha was a common law joint tenancy, then, of course, William's conveyance to James would convert the joint estate into a tenancy in common. But we have held that ORS 93.180 abolishes the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Bryant v. Bryant
...the Oregon Court held that, upon the death of the father, the son owned the property in fee simple. Id. ; accord Holbrook v. Holbrook , 240 Or. 567, 403 P.2d 12, 13–14 (1965).From our review of the authorities cited herein, it appears that Michigan and Oregon 522 S.W.3d 408represent an extr......
-
Hilterbrand v. Carter
... ... In 1976, two of mother's children, Beverly Holbrook and Durene Cantrell, and their spouses (plaintiffs) moved onto the park to help mother operate it. In 1978, mother executed a deed in which she ... ...
-
Spurlock v. Commercial Banking Co.
... ... Halleck, 216 Or. 23, 337 P.2d 330; Holbrook v. Holbrook, 240 Or. 567, 403 P.2d 12 ... C. The Effect of the Security Agreement Upon the Certificate of Deposit. Jurisdictions ... ...
-
Gilbert v. Brown
... ... the account application, they intended to create the type of co-ownership interest in the bonds with right of survivorship described in Holbrook v. Holbrook, 240 Or. 567, 403 P.2d 12 (1965); Halleck v. Halleck, 216 Or. 23, 337 P.2d 330 (1959); Manning v. U.S. Nat. Bank, supra; and Beach v ... ...