Holder v. Western German Bank
Decision Date | 15 February 1905 |
Docket Number | 1,343. |
Citation | 136 F. 90 |
Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Sixth Circuit |
Parties | HOLDER v. WESTERN GERMAN BANK. |
Albert Bettinger, for plaintiff in error.
H. D Peck, Frank H. Shaffer, and J. W. Peck, for defendant in error.
Before LURTON, SEVERENS, and RICHARDS, Circuit Judges.
This was an action prosecuted by the plaintiff in error to recover from the Western German Bank the sum of $4,000, being the amount of a check deposited with it for collection, and interest from March 13, 1903. The case was tried before the court without a jury. The following statement of the material facts as found by the court, and, as we think, fairly exhibited in the brief for plaintiff in error, is sufficient for the purposes of our decision:
'The court further finds that it is, and was at the time of the receipt of this check by defendant for collection, a general and uniform custom among banks and bankers of the United States to remit, in the absence of instructions to the contrary, the proceeds of checks, drafts, notes, and other instruments sent to them for collection by means of drafts or bills of exchange drawn upon banks located in the larger cities of the country, and that a great majority, probably three-fourths, of all remittances, are made by means of drafts upon banks located in the city of New York.'
The court's conclusion of law upon these facts was:
'That the Western German Bank, in requesting said First National Bank to remit in New York exchange, did not exceed its...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
First State Bank of Bristow v. O'bannon
...be permitted by its act alone to change the relation by sending its check and so convert its trust fund into a debt. Holder v. Western Ger. Bank, 6th C. C. A., 136 F. 90. ¶4 The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals spoke in Spokane & E. Trust Co. v. U.S. Products Co., 290 F. 884, and held:"The ru......
-
First State Bank of Bristow v. O'Bannon
... ... convert its trust fund into a debt. Holder v. Western ... Ger. Bank (6th C. C. A.) 136 F. 90 ... The ... Ninth Circuit ... ...
-
Larabee Flour Mills v. First Nat. Bank
...situation would seem novel and anomalous, and opposed to all general principles governing agency and trusteeship. Holder v. Western German Bank, 136 F. 90, 68 C. C. A. 554. A great majority of the cases wherein the federal court doctrine is laid down are cases in which the relation of debto......
-
Macy v. Roedenbeck
... 227 F. 346 MACY v. ROEDENBECK. In re BANK OF SULLY, IOWA. No. 4422. United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit ... the draft at the time it was drawn, the holder thereof would ... have no right of action against the bank in the event ... The ... case of Holder v. Western German Bank, 136 F. 90, 68 ... C.C.A. 554, is a simple determination of ... ...