Holloway v. Burke

CourtMissouri Supreme Court
Writing for the CourtWesthues, C.
CitationHolloway v. Burke, 79 S.W.2d 104, 336 Mo. 380 (Mo. 1935)
Decision Date07 February 1935
PartiesMillard C. Holloway et al. v. Sarah P. Burke et al., Appellants

Appeal from Ray Circuit Court; Hon. Ralph Hughes, Judge.

Reversed (with directions).

Wm A. Craven and Harris L. Moore for appellants.

(1) The ruling of the trial court on defendants' demurrer comes before this court for review upon the record proper. No exceptions nor bill of exceptions are necessary to preserve the ruling of the trial court upon the demurrer. Hannah v. Hannah, 109 Mo. 236, 18 S.W. 87; Hansos v Neal, 215 Mo. 256, 114 S.W. 1072; Warren v. Lead & Zinc Co., 255 Mo. 138, 164 S.W. 206. (2) Where the whole will shows an intention that nothing shall pass as intestate property, then any lapsed residuary legacy falls into the residuum and the rule that a residuary legacy which lapses passes to the next of kin as intestate property does not apply. Plummer v. Brown, 287 S.W. 316, 315 Mo. 627; Corbett v. Skaggs, 207 P. 819, 111 Kan. 380; Aitken v. Sharp, 115 A. 912; Martineau v Simonson, 69 N.Y.S. 185; Stolle v. Stolle, 66 S.W.2d 912; Snow v. Terrill, 8 S.W.2d 1017. (3) The will here in question shows the strongest possible intent not to die intestate as to any part of the estate and that the residuary legatees shall take all of the property. This is shown by the following features each of which have been held to be strongly indicative of such intent: (a) all other heirs or distributees are disinherited except residuary legatees; (b) not only the bulk but the whole estate passes by the residuary clause; (c) residuary legatees are "my full brothers and sisters" and names are only given under a "to-wit" although bequest to persons by name is not conclusive against class; (d) no shares are specified as among the residuary legatees. No case has been found in the reports where one will contained all of these features. Springfield Trust Co. v. Dunn, 136 N.E. 622, 243 Mass. 7. Naming heirs not conclusive against class. Stolle v. Stolle, 66 S.W.2d 912; In re Leverichs' Will, 210 N.Y.S. 605. Taken as a class because will excludes other heirs. Treat v. Savings Bank, 12 F.2d 896. Class because of general intent of will. Clarke v. Rathbone, 109 N.E. 651. Take as class on account of general intent. Roosevelt v. Potter, 73 N.Y.S. 800. Similar case, full discussion. Swallow v. Harmon, 166 Mass. 241, 44 N.E. 132. Beneficiaries named under "namely." Duplicate of case in hand. Held survivors of class take. (4) The devise to the full brothers and sisters was a devise to a class as tenants in common, and no part of the devise lapsed by reason of one of the class without lineal descendants predeceasing the testator but the survivors take the whole. Lounden v. Bollam, 302 Mo. 490, 258 S.W. 440; Philbert v. Campbell, 317 Mo. 556, 296 S.W. 1001; Crecelius v. Horst, 9 Mo.App. 51, affirmed 78 Mo. 566; Stolle v. Stolle, 66 S.W.2d 912; Zombro v. Moffett, 44 S.W.2d 149; Murphy v. Enright, 264 S.W. 811; Snow v. Ferrill, 8 S.W.2d 1017; contra, Lemmons v. Reynolds, 170 Mo. 227, 71 S.W. 135. (5) The words "and their heirs" in the residuary clause of the will are not words of purchase or substitution. Their only effect is to show clearly that the beneficiaries in that clause take a fee simple, an absolute estate. Roberts v. Crume, 173 Mo. 579.

George W. Crowley and Lavelock, Kirkpatrick, Clark & Garner for respondents.

The fifth clause of the will does not constitute a devise to a class; it creates a tenancy in common and not a joint tenancy; therefore, there is no survivorship. Sec. 3114, R. S. 1929; Lemmons v. Reynolds, 170 Mo. 227; Philbert v. Campbell, 317 Mo. 556, 296 S.W. 1001.

OPINION

Westhues, C.

Appellants appealed from a judgment and decree in partition entered in the Circuit Court of Ray County, Missouri. Respondents in their petition alleged that they were the owners of certain interests in the lands sought to be partitioned. Appellants filed a demurrer alleging that the petition, upon its face, disclosed that respondents had no interests in the lands. This demurrer was overruled by the trial court. Appellants declined to plead further and judgment was entered ordering the land to be sold and the proceeds to be divided according to the prayer of the petition.

The controversy arose over the meaning and effect of the last will and testament of Albert B. Wood, deceased, which reads as follows:

"LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT OF ALBERT WOOD.

"I, Albert Wood, of the County of Ray and State of Missouri, aged 59 years, being of sound mind, do make and publish this my last will and testament as follows:

"1st. All my debts, which are inconsiderable, together with nurse, doctor bills and burial expenses and tombstones, I wish first to be paid out of my estate.

"2nd. I give and bequeath to each of the heirs of my half brother, Allen Wood, deceased, the sum of one dollar.

"3rd. I give and bequeath to each of the heirs of my half sister, Fannie Holloway, deceased, the sum of one dollar.

"4th. I give and bequeath to each of the heirs of my half brother, William Wood, deceased, the sum of one dollar.

"5th. I give and bequeath all the residue and remainder of my estate to my full brothers and sisters, to-wit: Ashby Wood, Benjamin Wood, Dyott Wood, Mary E. Runion and Sarah P. Burke, and their heirs, to be proportioned as I may hereafter decide.

"6th. I hereby appoint John Burke as my executor.

"Dated this 4th day of April, 1919.

"Albert B. Wood." (Italics ours.)

For the purpose of this case we take the allegations of the petition as true because appellants, by their demurrer, admitted the truth of all facts well pleaded. The petition alleged that Mary E. Runion died single and unmarried prior to the death of the testator. The petition recited the names of the heirs at law of Mary E. Runion of which there were many in number and they need not be mentioned here except to be referred to as her legal heirs.

The contention of appellants, who were the surviving brothers and sisters mentioned in clause five of the will, was that by this clause the testator devised the residue and remainder of his estate to his full brothers and sisters as a class. It is, therefore, argued that since Mary E. Runion, mentioned in this clause, died prior to the testator's death without lineal descendants the then living brothers and sisters of the testator named in the fifth clause were entitled to all of the residue of the estate to the exclusion of the heirs at law of Mary E. Runion.

Respondents' contention, as stated in their argument, was as follows:

" Under the language of the fifth clause of the will, it is clear that the testator did not intend to create a joint tenancy, but a tenancy in common.

"The devise is not to a class, but to certain persons by name 'and their heirs.'

"This does not mean the joint heirs of all of them, but could only mean the heirs of each. In other words, it is the clear intention of the testator to convey an equal share to each and to the heirs of each and, therefore, upon the death of one the heirs of that one would take the share that the ancestor would have taken. However, under Section 3114, R. S., Mo. 1929, the question of testator's intent becomes a moot question, because, if he did not create a joint tenancy in express terms the statute makes it a tenancy in common. This would be true even though the testator actually intended a joint tenancy."

Lemmons v. Reynolds, 170 Mo. 227, 71 S.W. 135, and Philbert v. Campbell, 317 Mo. 556, 296 S.W. 1001, were cited in support of respondents' theory of the law.

The argument of respondents that under the fifth clause of the will the brothers and sisters of the testator took the residue of the estate as tenants in common and not as joint tenants is beside the point at issue. Neither does Section 3114, cited by respondents, render the intention of the testator a moot question. Section 3114 reads:

"Every interest in real estate granted or devised to two or more persons, other than executors and trustees and husband and wife, shall be a tenancy in common, unless expressly declared, in such grant or devise, to be in joint tenancy."

This section does not prohibit a testator from devising real estate to two or more persons as a class so that the survivors of the class, at the death of the testator, take all of the property devised to the exclusion of the heirs of those of the class who may have predeceased the testator. In such a case those surviving of a class would of course, under this statute, take as tenants in common unless the testator in clear terms created a joint estate.

Respondents place much importance upon Section 3114 and argue that under the provisions of this section the brothers and sisters mentioned in the fifth clause were made tenants in common and that the right of survivorship did not apply as would be the case of a joint tenancy. It is true that under this section the brothers and sisters took the residue of the estate, at the death of the testator, as tenants in common. However, the brothers and sisters had no estate whatever until the testator's death, and having no title, they could not be tenants in common or joint tenants. In Lounden v. Bollam, 258 S.W. 440, 302 Mo. 490, this court en banc said:

"The matter is treated by appellant's counsel as if William F Bollam took the whole title by the right of survivorship just as the law operates upon a joint tenancy fully vested. It is assumed that William, as the survivor of George, took the interest of George. Before one of two joint tenants by right of survivorship can take the estate of the other, there must be a joint tenancy in the two with title fully vested, and the other must die after such vesting of the title. William could not take an interest which George...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex
13 cases
  • McIntosh v. Wiggins
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • July 14, 1947
    ... ... Swan, 58 Mo. 147; Brown v. Rodgers, 125 Mo ... 392, 28 S.W. 630; Lemmons v. Reynolds, 170 Mo. 227, ... 71 S.W. 135 (overruled in Holloway v. Burke, 336 Mo ... 380, 79 S.W.2d 104); State ex rel. Ellis v. Brown, ... 326 Mo. 627, 33 S.W.2d 104; Denny v. Guyton, 327 Mo ... 1030, 40 ... ...
  • St. Louis Union Trust Co. v. Clarke
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • February 7, 1944
    ... ... to the exclusion of the heirs of predeceased members of the ... class. Crecelius v. Horst, 9 Mo.App. 51, 78 Mo. 566; ... Holloway v. Burke, 336 Mo. 380; Walker v. First ... Trust & Savings Bank, 12 F.2d 896. (9) A power of ... appointment not exercised leaves the estates ... ...
  • First Trust Co. v. Myers
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • October 4, 1943
    ... ... the members of the class take per capita. 2 Simes on Future ... Interests, secs. 366, 367; Holloway v. Burke, 336 ... Mo. 380, 79 S.W.2d 104; Corbett v. Skaggs, 111 Kan ... 380, 207 P. 819, 28 A. L. R. 1230; In re Estate of ... Zimmerman, ... ...
  • Adams v. Simpson
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • September 13, 1948
    ... ... testator the same relation. The language of the residuary ... clause and of the entire will forecloses any other ... conclusion. Holloway v. Burke, 336 Mo. 380, 79 ... S.W.2d 104; First Trust Company v. Myers, 351 Mo ... 899, 174 S.W.2d 378; Walker v. First Trust & Savings ... Bank, ... ...
  • Get Started for Free