Hope v. City of New Orleans

CourtSupreme Court of Louisiana
Citation106 La. 345,30 So. 842
Decision Date01 January 1901
Docket Number13,734
PartiesCHARLES W. HOPE, ET AL. v. CITY OF NEW ORLEANS, ET ALS

APPEAL from the Civil District Court, Parish of Orleans -- St Paul, J.

George J. Untereiner, for Plaintiffs, Appellants.

Arthur McGuirk, Assistant City Attorney, for Defendants, Appellees.

OPINION

BLANCHARD J.

Plaintiffs, as citizens and tax-payers of the City of New Orleans, bring this action contesting the legality of appointments in the public service made by the Administrator of Public Improvements, the Administrator of Police and Public Buildings and the Treasurer of the City and enjoining the Comptroller of the City from warranting for, and the Treasurer from paying, the salaries of the officials and employees so appointed.

It is averred that the appointments objected to were made by the officers mentioned in virtue of the pretended authority of Act 89 of 1900 entitled "An Act to provide a civil service for the City of New Orleans, to repeal all acts inconsistent or in conflict therewith and especially Sections 38 to 67 inclusive, and Section 110 of Act 45 of 1896."

The contention is that this act is unconstitutional and void, and, therefore, does not serve as sufficient basis for the tenure of office of the officials and employees the payment of whose salaries is sought to be restrained.

The grounds of the alleged unconstitutionality of the act are: --

1st. That it is repugnant to and contravenes the provisions of Articles 319 and 320 of the State Constitution in this, that it creates a board in a manner prohibited by said articles.

2nd. That it is repugnant to and contravenes the provisions of Article 50 of the Constitution in this, that it is a local and special act and was enacted without previous notice by publication of the intention to apply for its passage.

3rd. That it contravenes the provisions of the fifth section of Article 325 of the Constitution in this, that it pretends to legislate the Board of Civil Service Commissioners appointed under the Act 45 of 1896 out of office.

4th. That it is repugnant to Article 31 of the Constitution, in that the said act contains more than one object.

5th. That it indirectly attempts to remove the Board of Civil Service Commissioners appointed under Act 45 of 1896 in violation of Article 222 of the Constitution, and in a manner otherwise than that provided by Act 45 of 1896.

6th. That its provisions are repugnant to the Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution of the United States in this, that it is unequal in its operation, denying priority of right of appointment to persons receiving the highest percentage in civil service examinations, and vesting arbitrary discretion in the heads of departments to select appointees from the list of those making a certain rating in the examinations, to-wit, seventy per cent. or more out of a possible one hundred per cent. It is claimed that this denies to applicants the equal protection of the law.

The defense is that the act attacked is a constitutional and valid statute and a sufficient warrant for the appointments to office made by the heads of the departments of the city government heretofore mentioned.

There was judgment below rejecting the demands of the plaintiffs and they prosecute this appeal.

The second, third and fifth grounds of attack on the constitutionality of the act underwent consideration in State ev rel. Fortier et al. vs. Capdeveille et als., 104 La. 566, and were there determined adversely to the contention of plaintiffs herein.

The court is not persuaded that there was error in that judgment.

I.

Does the act in question contravene the provisions of Articles 319 and 320 of the Constitution, as is the first contention of plaintiffs?

We think not. The first of these articles provides that the electors of the City of New Orleans shall have the right to choose the public officers who shall be charged with the exercise of the police power and with the administration of the affairs of the corporation in whole or in part.

This declaration, however, is modified by the terms of the succeeding article (320) and is limited and controlled by the exceptions established by the latter article.

Thus, we find that city boards or commissions may be created or established the members of which are made elective by the Council, or who may be appointed by the Mayor with the consent of the Council. Also that authority is reserved to the General Assembly to create boards or commissions whose power shall extend in and beyond the Parish of Orleans, provided that at least two-thirds of the members thereof shall be from the City of New Orleans and selected by the people, or elected by the Council, or appointed by the Mayor.

Here was warrant for the Legislature to create the Board of Civil Service Commissioners provided for by Act 89 of 1900. All of the members of this board are from the City of New Orleans, three of them were selected by the people to the office of Mayor, Treasurer and Comptroller, and by the terms of Act 89 became merely ex officio members of the Civil Service Commission, and the remaining two members provided for by the act were appointed by the Mayor as the act directs, by and with the advice and consent of the Council.

We do not find in this that repugnance to Articles 319 and 320 of the Constitution for which plaintiffs con...

To continue reading

Request your trial
12 cases
  • West v. Town of Lake Placid
    • United States
    • United States State Supreme Court of Florida
    • February 6, 1929
    ...... projects as hereinabove set out. See Antuono v. City of. Tampa, 87 Fla. 82, 99 So. 324. It appears that a. majority of the legally qualified voters ... 304, 18 S.Ct. 617, 42 L.Ed. 1047; People v. Gordon, . 274 Ill. 462, 113 N.E. 864; Hope v. New Orleans, 106. La. 345, 30, So. 842; Chandler v. Neff (D. C.) 298. F. 515; Atty. Gen. ......
  • Klein v. Hutton
    • United States
    • United States State Supreme Court of North Dakota
    • November 25, 1922
    ...... Constitution under the above section of the Territorial. Code. City Fuel & Transfer Co. v. Young, 185 N.W. 934;. State v. Fischer, 184 N.W. 774; Widen v. State, ...Ex parte Mascolo (Cal. 1914) 142 P. 903; Quick. v. White Water Twp. (1856) 7 Ind. 570; Hope v. New. Orleans, 106 La. 345, 30 So. 842; Hoag v. Washington-Oregon Corp. 75 Or. 588, 144 P. ......
  • Ricks v. Department of State Civil Service
    • United States
    • Supreme Court of Louisiana
    • March 30, 1942
    ...... appellant. . . Charles. E. Dunbar, Jr., and Monte M. Lemann, both of New Orleans, for. appellees. . . Eugene. Stanley, Atty. Gen., A. M. Suthon and Cicero C. ... and appoint commissioners as provided in the City Civil. Service Law. Section 5(b) of Act 171 of 1940, the City Civil. Service Law, provides that ... service of the State of Louisiana. . . In the case. of Hope et al. v. City of New Orleans et al., 106 La. 345, 30. So. 842, 843, this court in defining civil ......
  • Charity Hospital of Louisiana v. Axford
    • United States
    • Court of Appeal of Louisiana (US)
    • January 13, 1930
    ...... . . Appeal. from Civil District Court, Parish of Orleans, Division. "C." Hon. E. K. Skinner, Judge. . . Action. by Charity Hospital of ... State v. J. Foto & Bro., 134 La. 154, 63 So. 859;. City of Shreveport v. Kahn, 136 La. 371, 67 So. 35;. Thomas v. Board of School Directors, 136 La. 499, ...456; State v. De Hart, 109 La. 570, 33 So. 605; Suc. of Bienvenu, 106 La. 595, 31 So. 193; Hope et. al. v. City of N. O., 106 La. 345, 30 So. 842; State. v. Logan et al, 104 La. 254, 28 So. ......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT