In re England, No. 03-5329.

CourtUnited States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (District of Columbia)
Writing for the CourtRoberts
Citation375 F.3d 1169
Decision Date27 July 2004
Docket NumberNo. 03-5329.,No. 03-5334.,No. 03-5333.
PartiesIn re: Gordon R. ENGLAND, Secretary of the Navy, et al., Petitioners.
375 F.3d 1169
In re: Gordon R. ENGLAND, Secretary of the Navy, et al., Petitioners.
No. 03-5329.
No. 03-5333.
No. 03-5334.
United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit.
Argued April 22, 2004.
Decided July 27, 2004.
Rehearing En Banc Denied September 21, 2004.

Page 1170

On Petition for Writ of Mandamus and Appeals from the United States District Court for the District of Columbia (No. 00cv00566) (No. 99cv02945).

Robert M. Loeb, Attorney, U.S. Department of Justice, argued the cause for petitioners/appellants. With him on the briefs were Peter D. Keisler, Assistant Attorney General, Roscoe C. Howard, Jr., U.S. Attorney, and Marleigh D. Dover, Attorney.

Arthur A. Schulcz, Sr. argued the cause and filed the brief for respondents/appellees.

Before: GINSBURG, Chief Judge, and GARLAND and ROBERTS, Circuit Judges.

Opinion for the Court filed by Circuit Judge ROBERTS.

ROBERTS, Circuit Judge:


Navy chaplains, like other Navy officers, are recommended for promotion by "selection boards" consisting of superior officers who meet and discuss the relative merits of candidates for promotion. The federal statute establishing the procedures for such selection boards, which applies to all the armed services, provides that board proceedings "may not be disclosed to any person not a member of the board," 10 U.S.C. § 618(f), and board members take an oath of confidentiality to implement this requirement. Certain current and former Navy chaplains and their particular endorsing agency, the Chaplaincy of Full Gospel Churches (CFGC), sued the Navy, alleging that it discriminates against chaplains affiliated with the CFGC in, among other things, promotion decisions. The chaplains and the CFGC sought to compel the Secretary of the Navy to release selection board members from their oath of confidentiality, to allow them to testify about selection board proceedings leading to the challenged decisions.

Page 1171

The district court ruled that Section 618(f) did not preclude disclosure of selection board proceedings through civil discovery, because Congress had not expressly addressed the question of such discovery in providing that board proceedings "may not be disclosed." The court accordingly ordered the Secretary to release selection board members from their oath. We reverse and hold that Section 618(f) bars the disclosure through civil discovery of promotion selection board proceedings.

I. Background

A. The History and Organization of Navy Chaplains

In November 1775, the Continental Congress adopted the first regulations to govern the fledgling Continental Navy. See Rules for the Regulation of the Navy of the United Colonies of North America (Nov. 28, 1775), reprinted in relevant part in 1 Clifford M. Drury, The History of the Chaplain Corps, United States Navy 3 (Bureau of Naval Personnel 1984). Although those regulations did not expressly create a chaplain position, Article 2 provided that "[t]he Commanders of the ships of the thirteen United Colonies, are to take care that divine service be performed twice a day on board, and a sermon preached on Sundays, unless bad weather or other extraordinary accidents prevent." Id. These duties often fell to the captain himself or a designee: only two chaplains were known to have served in the Continental Navy during the Revolutionary War, and the Navy limited the number of chaplains on active duty to nine until 1842 and to 24 from then until 1914. Drury, supra, at 5, 62.

Early chaplains were responsible for educating midshipmen and sailors in addition to their religious duties. The Navy placed great emphasis on the chaplains' role as teacher, selecting them "more for their teaching ability than for their experience or training as ministers." Id. at 18. Indeed, the first "naval academy" was established 200 years ago at the Washington Navy Yard by Chaplain Robert Thompson, who taught midshipmen mathematics and navigation. Id. at 18-20. The success of that academy led to the establishment of the United States Naval Academy at Annapolis, Maryland in 1845.

From those beginnings, the Navy Chaplain Corps has grown with the service to over 800 strong. It is the responsibility of Navy chaplains to "provide for the free exercise of religion for all members of the [Navy and Marine Corps], their dependents, and other authorized persons." Directive No. 1304.19, Appointment of Chaplains for the Military Services ¶ 3 (Dep't of Def. Sept. 18, 1993) (Directive). The Navy chaplain's mission is to accommodate the religious needs of sailors and Marines by providing religious services, counseling, and support. See Marine Corps Warfighting Publication 6-12, Religious Ministry Support in the United States Marine Corps 1-4, 1-5 (Dec. 12, 2001). In addition to this religious ministry, Navy chaplains also provide ethics instruction and critical incident debriefings, and advise commanders on religious, moral, and ethical issues. Id. at 1-5.

A Navy chaplain's role within the service is "unique," involving simultaneous service as clergy or a "professional representative[ ]" of a particular religious denomination and as a commissioned naval officer. OPNAVINST 1730.1, Chaplains Manual 1-2-1-3 (Dep't of the Navy Oct. 3, 1973). A chaplain must satisfy not only the normal physical and educational requirements to become a commissioned officer, but also must have a graduate level theology degree or equivalent and an ecclesiastical endorsement — official notice from a faith group endorsing agency that a candidate

Page 1172

"is professionally qualified to represent that faith group within the military Chaplaincy." Chaplain Candidate Program Officer Handbook Glossary; see Directive ¶¶ 5.1-5.2. Ecclesiastical endorsement must be maintained throughout a chaplain's career; withdrawal of ecclesiastical endorsement at any point in a chaplain's career could result in separation from the Navy. Directive ¶ 5.1.4.

The Navy categorizes chaplains into four general religious categories or "faith groups" according to similarities in religious denominations: Roman Catholic, Liturgical Protestant, Non-Liturgical Protestant, and Special Worship. Liturgical Protestant primarily includes those protestant denominations that trace their origins to the Protestant Reformation and whose religious services are characterized by a set liturgy or order of worship, including the Lutheran, Episcopal, Methodist, and Presbyterian denominations. CFGC Second Am. Compl. ¶ 12(a) (CFGC Compl.). Non-Liturgical Protestant refers to protestant denominations "without a formal liturgy or order in their worship service" whose clergy do not wear religious dress during services, comprising the Baptist, Evangelical, Pentecostal, Bible, and Charismatic churches. Id. ¶ 12(b). The Special Worship category includes the Christian Orthodox, Jewish, Muslim, and Mormon faiths. Appellants' Br. at 5.

B. The Personnel System

The Navy uses the same personnel system for all officers, including chaplains. That system seeks to manage officers' careers to provide the Navy with the best qualified personnel through three critical personnel decisions: (1) promotion; (2) continuation on active duty; and (3) selective early retirement. A naval officer must be recommended by a promotion selection board to advance in rank from lieutenant (junior grade) through rear admiral (lower half). See 10 U.S.C. § 611(a). Continuation on active duty decisions occur when the needs of the Navy require the selection of certain officers — otherwise subject to discharge or retirement for failing to be promoted to the next rank — to continue on active duty for an established period of time. See id. § 637(a)(1), (d). Conversely, selective early retirement decisions generally involve the selection of officers in the grade of captain who were passed over for promotion two or more times for involuntary, early retirement. Id. § 638(a)(1).

Each of these personnel decisions involves a selection board comprised of naval officers who deliberate, make selections, and then submit their recommendations to the Secretary of the Navy. Promotion selection boards are convened under 10 U.S.C. § 611(a); continuation on active duty and selective early retirement boards are convened under 10 U.S.C. § 611(b). Selection boards must consist of five or more active-duty naval officers who "must be serving in a grade higher than the grade of the officers under consideration by the board, except that no member of a board may be serving in a grade below ... lieutenant commander." 10 U.S.C. § 612(a)(1). At least one member of the board must be from the category being considered; thus, if a selection board is considering chaplains, at least one board member must be a chaplain. See id. § 612(a)(2)(A).

Promotion selection boards may only consider an eligible officer's official military personnel file and the selection board "precept" issued to the board by the Secretary of the Navy. See 10 U.S.C. § 615(a), (b). A precept is the Secretary's official guidance to the board, consisting of: (1) the maximum number of officers that the board may recommend for promotion, (2) "information or guidelines relating to the needs of the [Navy]

Page 1173

for officers having particular skills," and (3) applicable guidelines from the Secretary of Defense. Id. § 615(b). A promotion selection board considers these items and recommends those officers "whom the board ... considers best qualified for promotion." Id. § 616(a).

The promotion board reports its recommendations to the Secretary, 10 U.S.C. § 617(a), who takes action on the report in accordance with Section 618. If the Secretary "determines that the board acted contrary to law or regulation or to guidelines furnished the board under Section 615(b)," the Secretary must return the board's recommendations with a written explanation for further proceedings. Id. § 618(a)(2). The Secretary otherwise reviews the board's recommendations and adopts or modifies the list,...

To continue reading

Request your trial
66 practice notes
  • Chaplaincy of Full Gospel Churches v. England, No. 05-5143.
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (District of Columbia)
    • 7 Julio 2006
    ...religious vestments during services; it includes Baptist, Evangelical, Pentecostal, and Charismatic faiths. Id.; see also In re England, 375 F.3d 1169, Page 1172 (D.C.Cir.2004).3 Plaintiffs-Appellants are a group of current and former Navy chaplains of nonliturgical Protestant faiths and th......
  • Cazorla v. Koch Foods of Miss., L.L.C., No. 15-60562
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (5th Circuit)
    • 27 Septiembre 2016
    ...intended the confidentiality provisions to constitute a ‘privilege’ within the meaning of the Federal Rules.”); see also In re England, 375 F.3d 1169, 1179 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (Roberts, J.) (dismissing a proposition essentially identical to Koch's). See generally PGA Tour, Inc. v. Martin , 532......
  • Borikas v. Alameda Unified Sch. Dist., A129295
    • United States
    • California Court of Appeals
    • 12 Junio 2013
    ...intent was not discernable. ( Id. at pp. 1357–1358, 96 Cal.Rptr.3d 864.) 1. Quoted by Justice Roberts in In re England (D.C.Cir.2004) 375 F.3d 1169, 1182. 2. All further statutory references refer to the Government Code unless otherwise indicated. 3. Section 50079 became effective July 2, 1......
  • Harkness v. Sec'y of the Navy, No. 16-5396
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (6th Circuit)
    • 31 Mayo 2017
    ...or ... professional representative[s] of a particular religious denomination and as ... commissioned naval officer[s]." In re England , 375 F.3d 1169, 1171 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (quoting OPNAVINST 1730.1, Chaplains Manual 1-2–1-3 (Dep't of the Navy Oct. 3, 1973)). Navy chaplains are divided into......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
66 cases
  • Chaplaincy of Full Gospel Churches v. England, No. 05-5143.
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (District of Columbia)
    • 7 Julio 2006
    ...religious vestments during services; it includes Baptist, Evangelical, Pentecostal, and Charismatic faiths. Id.; see also In re England, 375 F.3d 1169, Page 1172 (D.C.Cir.2004).3 Plaintiffs-Appellants are a group of current and former Navy chaplains of nonliturgical Protestant faiths and th......
  • Cazorla v. Koch Foods of Miss., L.L.C., No. 15-60562
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (5th Circuit)
    • 27 Septiembre 2016
    ...intended the confidentiality provisions to constitute a ‘privilege’ within the meaning of the Federal Rules.”); see also In re England, 375 F.3d 1169, 1179 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (Roberts, J.) (dismissing a proposition essentially identical to Koch's). See generally PGA Tour, Inc. v. Martin , 532......
  • Borikas v. Alameda Unified Sch. Dist., A129295
    • United States
    • California Court of Appeals
    • 12 Junio 2013
    ...intent was not discernable. ( Id. at pp. 1357–1358, 96 Cal.Rptr.3d 864.) 1. Quoted by Justice Roberts in In re England (D.C.Cir.2004) 375 F.3d 1169, 1182. 2. All further statutory references refer to the Government Code unless otherwise indicated. 3. Section 50079 became effective July 2, 1......
  • Harkness v. Sec'y of the Navy, No. 16-5396
    • United States
    • United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (6th Circuit)
    • 31 Mayo 2017
    ...or ... professional representative[s] of a particular religious denomination and as ... commissioned naval officer[s]." In re England , 375 F.3d 1169, 1171 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (quoting OPNAVINST 1730.1, Chaplains Manual 1-2–1-3 (Dep't of the Navy Oct. 3, 1973)). Navy chaplains are divided into......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT