In re Kellogg
Decision Date | 02 December 1902 |
Docket Number | 15. |
Citation | 118 F. 1017 |
Parties | In re KELLOGG. |
Court | U.S. Court of Appeals — Second Circuit |
The facts are fully set forth in the opinion of the district judge, and there is no dispute about them. He has carefully discussed the propositions of law arising thereon, and we concur in his reasoning and conclusions. It seems unnecessary, therefore, to file any additional opinion here, especially in view of the circumstance that the subject has recently been discussed by this court in Re New York Economical Printing Co., 49 C.C.A. 133, 110 F. 514. It was held in that case that Inasmuch as by the New York 'statute a conditional sale, such as this, of property not delivered to the vendee for consumption or sale (In re Garcewich (C.C.A.) 115 F. 87), is void only as against subsequent purchasers or pledges or mortgagees in good faith, and not against creditors, the decision in Re New York Economical Printing Co., supra, is controlling of the case at bar. Petitioner appreciates this fact, and his argument is addressed to a reargument of the questions settled in that case. We see no reason to change the opinion therein expressed, which was enunciated after a careful consideration of the bankrupt law. No authority conflicting with the views therein expressed is cited; for cases in which by the state law conditional sales are void as against creditors are not in conflict with such opinion. The order of the district court (112 F. 52) is affirmed, with costs. See 113 F. 120.
Frank H. Robinson, for petitioner.
John Griffin, opposed.
To continue reading
Request your trial-
In re Parkway Knitting Mills
...v. Meriden Britannia, 160 N.Y. 178, 54 N.E. 781, 73 Am.St.Rep. 678; In re New York Economical Printing Co., 2 Cir., 110 F. 514; In re Kellogg, 2 Cir., 118 F. 1017; In re Burnham, D.C., 140 F. 926. The weight of authority favors and the law now is as I stated it, supra. We must be careful in......
-
Harper v. Dothan Nat. Bank, 4 Div. 531.
... ... bankrupt, "not as an innocent purchaser, but as the ... debtor had it at the time of the petition." Zartman ... v. First Nat. Bank, 216 U.S. 134, 30 S.Ct. 368, 369, 54 ... L.Ed. 418; Lewin v. Telluride Iron Works Co. (C. C ... A.) 272 F. 590, 595; In re Kellogg (C. C. A.) ... 118 F. 1017; Sparks v. Weatherly, 176 Ala. 324, 58 ... So. 280; American Bottle Co. v. Finney, 203 Ala. 92, ... 82 So. 106; Coffman v. Folds, 216 Ala. 133, 112 So ... The act ... of Congress was not intended as an extension of "the ... operation of the registration ... ...
-
Allen v. Hollander
... ... good faith, it stands differently than when raised by the ... debtor himself, as between him and a creditor, or by a ... trustee in bankruptcy. In re New York Economical Printing ... Company, 110 F. 514, 517, 49 C.C.A. 133; In re ... Garcewich, 115 F. 87, 53 C.C.A. 510; In re ... Kellogg, 118 F. 1017, 56 C.C.A. 383 ... The ... conclusion is that the delivery was sufficient in this case ... to pass the property, as against the trustee, and that the ... defendant should not be held to account. Bill ... ...