In re Soc'y Ins. Co. COVID-19 Bus. Interruption Protection Ins. Litig.

• Decision Date: 22 February 2021
• Docket Number: No. 20 C 05981,MDL No. 2964,Master Docket No. 20 C 5965, No. 20 C 02005,No. 20 C 02813,20 C 02813
• Citation: 521 F.Supp.3d 729
• Court: U.S. District Court — Northern District of Illinois
• Parties: IN RE: SOCIETY INSURANCE CO. COVID-19 BUSINESS INTERRUPTION PROTECTION INSURANCE LITIGATION This Document Relates to the Following Cases: Valley Lodge Corp., Plaintiff, v. Society Insurance, a Mutual Company, Defendant. Rising Dough, Inc. (d/b/a Madison Sourdough), et al. individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs, v. Society Insurance, Defendant. Big Onion Tavern Group, LLC, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Society Insurance, Inc., Defendant.

521 F.Supp.3d 729

IN RE: SOCIETY INSURANCE CO. COVID-19 BUSINESS INTERRUPTION PROTECTION INSURANCE LITIGATION

This Document Relates to the Following Cases:

Valley Lodge Corp., Plaintiff,

v.Society Insurance, a Mutual Company, Defendant.

Rising Dough, Inc. (d/b/a Madison Sourdough), et al. individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiffs,

v.Society Insurance, Defendant.

Big Onion Tavern Group, LLC, et al., Plaintiffs,

v.Society Insurance, Inc., Defendant.

MDL No. 2964

Master Docket No. 20 C 5965

No. 20 C 02813

No. 20 C 05981

No. 20 C 02005

United States District Court, N.D. Illinois, Eastern Division.

Signed February 22, 2021

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Edmond E. Chang, United States District Judge

This multi-district litigation addresses Society Insurance's broad-based denials of business-interruption coverage for a variety of restaurants and other businesses in the hospitality industry whose operations have been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.

This Opinion decides dispositive motions in each of the three bellwether cases selected by the Court. R. 69. Those cases are: Big Onion Tavern Group, LLC, et al. v. Society Insurance , No. 1:20-cv-02005; Valley Lodge Corp. v. Society Insurance , No. 1:20-cv-02813; and Rising Dough, Inc., et al. v. Society Insurance , No. 1:20-cv-05981. Society has filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim in the Rising Dough action, R. 20, No. 20 C 05981, Society's Br. in Support of Mot. to Dismiss; and a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim or, in the alternative, for summary judgment in the Big Onion and Valley Lodge actions. R. 113, No. 20 C 2005, Society Mem. of Law; R. 17, No. 20 C 02813, Society Mem. of Law.

As detailed in this Opinion, Society's motions to dismiss and summary judgment motions are denied to the extent that they target the claims for business-interruption coverage. Those claims do survive. Also, the Section 155 claims survive in Big Onion and Valley Lodge. But the summary judgment motions in the Big Onion and Valley Lodge actions are granted as to the coverage theories under the Civil Authority and the Contamination provisions, and in the Rising Dough case as to the Sue and Labor clause.

I. Background

As readers of this Opinion know all too well, the novel coronavirus has generated a global pandemic lasting almost an entire year. Many government agencies around the world have responded by closing (at least in part) businesses of all kinds and by restricting activities, particularly group gatherings.

At issue here are the impacts of those closures on the plaintiffs in those three cases: specifically, businesses in the hospitality industry in Illinois (the Big Onion and Valley Lodge plaintiffs), and Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Tennessee (the Rising Dough plaintiffs). All have been forced to modify their normal business operations due to the pandemic—for example, suspending in-person dining and relying only on take-out orders—and all allege that they have lost significant revenue as a result. R. 1, 20 C 2813, Valley Lodge Compl. ¶¶ 3-4, 33-42; R. 14, 20 C 5981, Rising Dough Am. Class Action Compl. ¶¶ 50–80; R. 29, No. 20 C 2005, Big Onion First Am. Compl. ¶¶ 6, 97–108. All plaintiffs—indeed, all the plaintiffs in all the cases within this MDL, by definition—are insured by Society Insurance against certain interruptions to their business. The fundamental questions at stake in this litigation are how properly to classify the interruption that has happened here, and whether this particular interruption is covered under the policy. Beyond following state and local government orders and guidance, the Rising Dough plaintiffs also allege that the losses to their businesses occurred as a direct result of the actual presence of the coronavirus itself on the premises. R. 26, 20 C 5981, Rising Dough Pls.’ Resp. at 8; R. 14, 20 C 5981, Am. Class Action Compl. ¶ 80 ("As a result of the presence of COVID-19 and the Closure Orders, Plaintiffs and the other Class members lost Business Income and incurred Extra Expense.") (emphasis added). The Big Onion plaintiffs have similarly alleged that the "continuous presence of the coronavirus on or around Plaintiffs’ premises has created a dangerous condition and rendered their premises unsafe and unfit for their intended use and therefore caused physical property damage or loss under the Policies." R. 29 ¶ 100.

For its part, Society counters that these losses, whether caused by the coronavirus directly or by the government orders, simply do not fall within the plain language of the policy invoked by the Plaintiffs. In particular, the Plaintiffs allege that coverage applies under the following policy provisions, common to all plaintiffs (although each group of plaintiffs has sought recovery under different subsets of these provisions)¹ :

• Business Income coverage, on the Businessowners Special Property Coverage Form, section 5, Additional Coverages:

g. Business Income

(1) Business Income

(a) We will pay for the actual loss of Business Income you sustain due to the necessary suspension of your "operations" during the "period of restoration." The suspension must be caused by direct physical loss of or damage to covered property at the described premises. The loss or damage must be caused by or result from a Covered Cause of Loss....

(b) We will only pay for loss of Business Income that you sustain during the "period of restoration" and that occurs within 12 consecutive months after the date of direct physical loss or damage.

• Civil Authority coverage, on the Businessowners Special Property Coverage Form, section 5, Additional Coverages:

k. Civil Authority

When a Covered Cause of Loss causes damage to property other than property at the described premises, we will pay for the actual loss of Business Income you sustain and necessary Extra Expense caused by action of civil authority that prohibits access to the described premises, provided that both of the following apply:

(1) Access to the area immediately surrounding the damaged property is prohibited by civil authority as a result of the damage, and the described premises are within the area; and

(2) The action of civil authority is taken in response to dangerous physical conditions resulting from the damage or continuation of the Covered Cause of Loss that caused the damage, or the action is taken to enable a civil authority to have unimpeded access to the damaged property.

Civil Authority coverage for Business Income will begin immediately after the time of the first action of civil authority that prohibits access to the described premises and will apply for a period of up to four consecutive weeks from the date on which such coverage begins.

Civil Authority coverage for necessary Extra Expense will begin immediately after the time of first action of civil authority that prohibits access to the described premises and will end:

(1) Four consecutive weeks after the time of that action; or

(2) When your Civil Authority coverage for Business Income ends; whichever is later.

The definitions of Business Income and Extra Expense contained in the Business Income and Extra Expense Additional Coverages also apply to this Civil Authority Additional Coverage. The Civil Authority Additional Coverage is not subject to the Limits of Insurance.

• Contamination coverage, on the Businessowners Special Property Coverage Form, section 5, Additional Coverages:

m. Contamination

If your "operations" are suspended due to "contamination":

(1) We will pay for your costs to clean and sanitize your premises, machinery and equipment, and expenses you incur to withdraw or recall products or merchandise from the market. We will not pay for the cost or value of the product.

The most we will pay for any loss or damage under this Additional Coverage arising out of the sum of all such expenses occurring during each separate policy period is $5,000; and

(2) We will also pay for the actual loss of Business Income and Extra Expense you sustain caused by

(a) "Contamination" that results in an action by a public health or other governmental authority that prohibits access to the described premises or production of your product.

(b) "Contamination threat"

(c) "Publicity" resulting from the discovery or suspicion of "contamination."

Coverage for the actual loss of Business Income under this section will begin immediately upon the suspension of your business operations and will continue for a period not to exceed a total of three consecutive weeks after coverage begins.

Coverage for necessary Extra Expense under this section will likewise begin immediately upon the suspension of your business operations and will continue only for a total of three consecutive weeks after coverage begins, or until the loss of Business Income coverage ends, whichever is longer. The coverages under this section may not be extended nor repeated. The definitions of Business Income and Extra Expense, contained in the Business Income and Extra Expense Additional Coverages section shall also apply to the additional coverages under this section.

(3) Contamination Exclusions

All exclusions and limitations apply except Exclusions B.2.j.(2) and B.2.j.(5)

(4) Additional Definitions:

(a) "Contamination" means a defect, deficiency, inadequacy or dangerous condition in your products, merchandise or premises.

(b) "Contamination threat" means a threat made by a third party against you to commit a "malicious contamination" unless the third party's demand for money or other consideration is met.

(c) "Malicious contamination" means an intentional, malicious and illegal altercation or adulteration of your products.

(d) "Publicity" means a publication or broadcast by the media, of the discovery or suspicion of "contamination" at a described premise.

• Extra Expense coverage, on the Businessowners Special Property Coverage Form, section 5, Additional Coverages:

h. Extra Expense

(1) We will pay necessary Extra Expense you incur during the "period of restoration" that you

...