In re Winegarten
| Decision Date | 14 April 1989 |
| Docket Number | Bankruptcy No. 88-01255. |
| Citation | 101 BR 705 |
| Parties | In re Melvin Archie WINEGARTEN, SSN XXX-XX-XXXX, Katherine Winegarten, SSN XXX-XX-XXXX, Debtors. |
| Court | U.S. Bankruptcy Court — Eastern District of Oklahoma |
Warren McConnico, Tulsa, Okl., for debtors.
A. Craig Abrahamson, Tulsa, Okl., for Wells Fargo Credit Corp.
Kenneth Mather, Tulsa, Okl., Chapter 7 Trustee.
On February 13, 1989, Debtors' Motion for Avoidance of a Judicial Lien pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 522(f)(1), with an accompanying Response by Wells Fargo Credit Corporation, and Trustee's Objection to Exemption, with accompanying Response by Wells Fargo Credit Corporation came before this Court for Trial. A consolidated hearing was conducted for the taking of evidence to resolve both matters. Appearances were entered by Warren McConnico, attorney for the Debtors, A. Craig Abrahamson, representing Wells Fargo Credit Corporation, and Kenneth Mather, the duly appointed Chapter 7 Trustee.
At the conclusion of the taking of evidence, the Court afforded counsel for the three parties represented at the hearing the opportunity to submit proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in support of their respective positions presented at Trial. All such pleadings were timely received by this Court.
After review and consideration of the evidence presented at Trial, the pleadings, and the applicable law in the area, this Court makes the following Findings of Fact in this core proceeding:
STATEMENT OF ISSUE — At issue in this case is whether the Debtors have demonstrated sufficient intent and actions to allow a homestead exemption to be claimed on certain real property owned by the Debtors.
1. On October 24, 1988, the Debtors in this matter filed for Chapter 7 relief under the United States Bankruptcy Code claiming a homestead exemption on certain real property, described as:
The Northeast Quarter of the Southeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter (NE/4 SE/4 SW/4) and the West Half of the Southwest Quarter (W/2 SW/4) and the West four (4) acres of the West Half of the Southeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter (W/2 SE/4 SW/4), Section Thirteen (13), Township Five (5) North, Range Twenty-two (22) East, LeFlore County, OK
This property consists of some 94 acres, 84 acres of which is contiguous and 10 acres of which is separated by 16 noncontiguous acres owned by the Debtor's father, Andrew Winegarten.
2. A house is located on the property which is bisected by the property boundary line between the 84 contiguous acres and the 16 acres owned by the Debtor's father. Testimony revealed that 90 percent of the home is located on the Debtors' property and the remaining 10 percent is located on the property owned by the Debtor's father. Also located on the property are two other structures: a "bunkhouse," generally regarded as uninhabitable, and the framework for a pole barn which is not completed. Both of these structures are located on the 84 contiguous acres owned by the Debtors.
3. The house was built in 1948 by the Debtor, Melvin Winegarten, and his father, Andrew Winegarten, at which time title to both the subject property and the non-owned 16 acres was held by Andrew Winegarten and his wife, Allie Mae. The Debtor testified that when the home was built, it was the intent of the Debtor and his father that it be located entirely on the 16 acre tract, but through an error at the time of construction, the house partially straddles the property line.
Through a series of transactions between the Debtor and his family, the Debtor acquired title to the subject property in 1954.
4. Andrew and Allie Mae Winegarten have occupied the house located on the property since 1952 with the exception of a brief period in the 1970's. The Debtors have not occupied the home for sometime, having resided in the Tulsa area since 1957.
5. The Debtors have performed some work on the property, including beginning construction on the pole barn in the Fall of 1987, but which has not been worked on since the Spring of 1988; installing siding on the house located on the subject property in the Fall of 1987; putting a roof on the home in the Spring of 1988; and insulating the home in the Fall of 1986. All of this work was performed by the Debtor; however, the Debtor has not performed construction on the subject property or visited the premises on a regular basis.
6. The Debtors currently reside in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma,...
To continue reading
Request your trial