Interest on Lawyers' Trust Accounts, Matter of
Decision Date | 25 October 1983 |
Docket Number | No. 19266,19266 |
Citation | 672 P.2d 406 |
Parties | In the Matter of INTEREST ON LAWYERS' TRUST ACCOUNTS. |
Court | Utah Supreme Court |
C. Jeffrey Paoletti, Salt Lake City, for Utah State Bar Ass'n.
This petition invokes the Court's constitutional original jurisdiction to regulate the legal profession. See generally In re Utah State Bar Petition, Etc., Utah, 647 P.2d 991 (1982).
The Utah Bar Foundation and the Board of Commissioners of the Utah State Bar seek approval to implement a program under which interest accrued on certain lawyers' accounts held in trust for clients would be paid to the Foundation, a nonprofit corporation, to support law-related charitable objects such as legal aid for the disadvantaged, law reform, and the administration of justice. Interest on lawyers' trust accounts (I.O.L.T.A.) programs have now been adopted in about fifteen states and in Canada and Australia. The concept has been endorsed by the Conference of Chief Justices, by the Board of Governors of the American Bar Association, and by other interested organizations.
Published opinions describing the history and affirming the legality, tax clearance, and ethical acceptability of I.O.L.T.A. programs include: Matter of Interest on Trust Accounts, Fla., 402 So.2d 389 (1981); Petition of Minnesota State Bar Association, Minn., 332 N.W.2d 151 (1982); Petition of New Hampshire Bar Association, 122 N.H. 971, 453 A.2d 1258 (1982); Rev.Rul. 81-209, 1981-2 C.B. 16 ( ); ABA Comm. on Ethics and Professional Responsibility, Formal Op. 348, 68 A.B.A.J. 1502 (1982) ( ). On the authority of these precedents, we approve the petition, with the following comments for clarification.
1. The program involves only lawyers' deposits of clients' funds that are nominal in amount or expected to be held for only a short period of time. Professional ethics forbid lawyers from receiving the interest on such accounts. ABA Comm.Op. No. 348, 68 A.B.A.J. at 1503-04. Currently, such funds are usually pooled and held in noninterest-bearing accounts since the separate balances do not yield enough interest to cover the expense of computing, remitting, and reporting to the Internal Revenue Service the amounts attributable to each client. This program will allow noninterest-bearing lawyers' trust accounts to be switched to interest-bearing accounts whose pooled earnings will be paid to a charitable organization that will use them for the public benefit.
2. Where client funds are of sufficient amount or are held for a sufficient period that the lawyer can reasonably be expected to foresee that they will yield enough interest to be of significant benefit to the client after transaction costs, the lawyer will continue to be obligated to make the funds produce income for the benefit of the client. Minnesota, 332 N.W.2d at 157-58; New Hampshire, 453 A.2d at 1261; cf. 2 A. Scott, The Law of Trusts §§ 180.3, 181 (3d ed. 1967 and Supp.1981).
3. The program will be voluntary as defined here. 1 By written notice to the Foundation, any lawyer or law firm may affirmatively elect not to participate, but the program will apply to all lawyers and law firms not giving this notice.
4. The I.O.L.T.A. program is not conditioned upon the approval of clients. Indeed, if client approval were required, the Internal Revenue Ruling cited above would probably require that clients be taxed on the earnings on their respective balances in the pooled account, which would require computations, notices, and forms whose costs would render the whole program impractical.
5. It is unnecessary to notify individual clients whose funds are pooled in interest-bearing accounts in the I.O.L.T.A. program, but lawyers and law firms are encouraged to assure that their clients understand the nature and limitations of the I.O.L.T.A. program, especially the fact that it does not deprive clients of any interest income previously available to them from the investment of their funds. Lawyers should also help their clients and the public at large to understand that the I.O.L.T.A. program is expected to result in substantial public benefits. The following statements of the Florida and Minnesota Supreme Courts illustrate the policy considerations:
We urge the Bar to encourage participation in this program, and in furtherance of that end to assist Florida financial institutions and Florida attorneys with as much information and aid as may be necessary...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Phillips v. Washington Legal Foundation
...Fifth Circuit reversed, concluding that such interest belongs to the owner of the principal. Held: 1.Interest earned on client funds held in IOLTA accounts is the "private property'' of the client for Takings Clause purposes. The existence of a property interest is determined by reference t......
-
Washington Legal Foundation v. Massachusetts Bar Foundation
...the character of governmental action, through the IOLTA Rule, is a physical invasion of their beneficial interests in their funds held in IOLTA accounts. The physical invasion occurs, the plaintiffs argue, because the IOLTA program borrows the principal to generate income by collecting the ......
-
Washington Legal Found. v. TEXAS EQUAL ACCESS
...332 N.W.2d 151 (Minn.1982); Petition of New Hampshire Bar Association, 122 N.H. 971, 453 A.2d 1258 (1982); In re Interest on Lawyers Trust Accounts, 672 P.2d 406 (Utah 1983); In re Interest on Lawyers Trust Accounts 283 Ark. 252, 675 S.W.2d 355 (1984); Petition of Massachusetts Bar Ass'n, 3......
-
Washington Legal Found. v. Mass. Bar Found., Civ. A. No. 91-11135-T.
...106 S.Ct. 142, 88 L.Ed.2d 118 (1985); In re Interest on Lawyers' Trust, 283 Ark. 252, 675 S.W.2d 355 (1984); Matter of Interest on Lawyers' Trust Accounts, 672 P.2d 406 (Utah 1983); Petition of N.H. Bar Ass'n, 122 N.H. 971, 453 A.2d 1258 (1982); In re Interest on Trust Accounts, 402 So.2d 3......
-
Utah Bar Foundation
...Utah's IOLTA program exists pursuant to an order from the Utah Supreme Court. See In the Matter of Interest on Lawyers' Trust Accounts, 672 P.2d 406 (Utah 1983). This order, and similar ones in other jurisdictions, permits the pooling of nominal client funds for deposit in interest bearing ......
-
Utah Bar Foundation
...That program was created in Utah in 1983 by the Utah Supreme Court's decision in In the Matter of Interest on Lawyers' Trust Accounts, 672 P.2d 406 (Utah 1983). Through the court's decision, attorneys' trust accounts, which were not interest bearing, were permitted to be changed to interest......
-
New Rules Governing Iolta Program Adopted by the Utah Supreme Court
...education. The IOLTA program was created in 1983 by the Utah Supreme Court Opinion In The Matter of Interest on LawyersÃ. Trust Accounts, 672 P.2d 406 (Utah 1983). It allowed attorneys to pool client funds that were to be held for a minimal amount of time or were of small amount in an inte......