Jacobs v. Goodwater Graphite Co.

• Citation: 205 Ala. 112,87 So. 363
• Decision Date: 16 December 1920
• Docket Number: 5 Div. 754
• Parties: JACOBS v. GOODWATER GRAPHITE CO.
• Court: Supreme Court of Alabama

87 So. 363

205 Ala. 112

JACOBS v. GOODWATER GRAPHITE CO.

5 Div. 754

Supreme Court of Alabama

December 16, 1920

Appeal from Circuit Court, Coosa County; E.J. Garrison, Judge.

Suit by Moses Jacobs, Sr., against the Goodwater Graphite Company to enforce a vendor's lien. Decree for respondent, and complainant appeals. Motion to dismiss overruled, and decree affirmed.

J Sanford Mullins, of Alexander City, for appellant.

John A Darden, of Goodwater, for appellee.

THOMAS J.

The case was submitted on motion and on merits.

The motion was to dismiss the appeal for the reason that appellant did not file the transcript in the cause with the clerk of this court within 60 days after its completion and certification. The final decree was rendered on March 4 1920, from which the appeal was taken on March 19th, security for costs for perfection of the appeal approved March 20th certification of the register to the transcript was on April 16th, and the transcript was filed with the clerk of this court on November 16th thereafter. Gen.Acts 1919, pp. 84-86. Acceptance of service of appeal and waiver of further notice was of date of April 6, 1920; the respective calls of the fifth division were for April 12, 1920, and November 15, 1920.

The several provisions of the act in question have not been construed by this court. Butler Cotton Oil Co. v. Brooks, 85 So. 778; Wells Amusement Co. v. Eros, 85 So. 692. The Act of February 15, 1919, Gen.Acts, p. 84, to amend the Act of September 22, 1915 (Gen.Acts 1915, p. 711), "to further prescribe and regulate the right and manner of taking appeals in civil and criminal cases and their submission in the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals," provides:

That "any appeal taken under the provisions of chapter fifty-three (53) of the Code of Alabama of 1907 must be taken within six months from the rendition of the judgment or decree" in the manner provided (section 1); that "after making [taking] an appeal in the manner herein provided, and filing in the cause a bill of exceptions, or the expiration of the time for filing such bill of exceptions, of if the appellant sooner direct, the clerk, register or judge of probate, as the case may be, shall make out a transcript as required by law, and deliver the same to the appellant" (section 2); that "after the taking of the appeal the clerk or register or judge of probate shall, on demand of the appellee, make out and deliver to him a certificate showing the names of the parties, the court, a copy of the judgment or decree, and the date of the taking of the appeal, and the date the bill of exceptions was signed, if it has been filed, and a copy of the statement of appeal and security for costs, or the supersedeas bond" (section 3); that the "appellant shall file the transcript in the office of the clerk of the Supreme Court, or Court of Appeals within sixty (60) days after the signing or establishing of the bill of exceptions or the expiration of the time for establishing the same" (section 4); that "if the transcript is not filed in the office of the clerk of the court to which the appeal is taken within the time fixed by this act, the appellee may on any

Thursday after the first call of the docket in the court to which the appeal is returnable, after the expiration of the time for filing of the transcript, present the certificate of appeal and certified copy of a security for costs of appeal, or supersedeas bond, and move the court for the dismissal of the appeal or affirmance of the judgment or decree appealed from and a judgment against the sureties for the costs of appeal, or on the supersedeas bond. But the appellate court may for good cause extend the time for filing the transcript" (section 5).

By section 6 it is provided that the clerk of the Supreme Court and the clerk of the Court of Appeals shall enter all cases wherein appeal is taken, on a docket in the order in which the transcripts or certificates of appeal are presented.

The record in the office of the clerk of the Supreme Court discloses that the certificate of appeal was filed on April 6th and there was a continuance of the cause on April 13th, on the call of the Fifth division, from where the appeal came. There was no formal order extending the time for filing the transcript, unless the order of continuance so operated. The appeal was taken when good and sufficient surety for costs was lodged with the register (Kimbrell v. Rogers, 90 Ala. 339, 7 So. 241), and the cause was docketed on certificate in this court within the time prescribed by statute. Section 2868, Code (as amended, Gen.Laws 1915, p. 711); Gen.Laws 1919, p. 84; section 2870, Code.

The delay in filing the transcript was not prejudicial. Collier v. Coggins, 103 Ala. 281, 15 So. 578; Cudd v. Reynolds, 186 Ala. 207, 61 So. 41; National Union v. Sherry, 180 Ala. 627, 61 So. 944; Southern Ry. Co. v. Abraham Bros., 161 Ala. 317, 49 So. 801. Had the case not been docketed in this court until the subsequent term, there may have been merit in movant's motion. National Union v. Sherry, supra. The provision in the act of 1919 (Gen.Acts, p. 85, § 4) requiring appellant to file the transcript within 60 days "after the signing or establishing of the bill of exceptions or the expiration of the time for establishing the same" is not applicable to an appeal in an equity case. The motion to...