Jepson v. The America
| Decision Date | 20 June 1893 |
| Citation | 56 F. 1021 |
| Parties | THE AMERICA. v. THE AMERICA. JEPSON |
| Court | U.S. District Court — District of New Jersey |
Frank G. Stockley, for the motion.
Joseph H. Brinton, opposed.
This claim is a meritorious one, and should be paid. The services for which wages are claimed by the libelant were faithfully performed, and should be compensated for. But, unfortunately for the libelant, he has mistaken his remedy for the wrong done him. The libelant was employed simply as a ship-keeper or watchman of the dredge America, a domestic vessel, while she was lying in port. Such employment, and the consequent services rendered, are not maritime, and cannot be the basis of a maritime lien. The E. A. Barnard, 2 F. 712; The Island City, 1 Low. 375. The libel must therefore be dismissed.
In this case, however, the claimant has been guilty of laches. The libel was duly filed, and the cause proceeded regularly to a decree pro confesso, and an order for sale of the dredge. Then, for the first time, does the claimant intervene, and asks the indulgence of the court, seeking to open the decree pro confesso, and to interpose the defense which has been made. Had the defense been different in character, it is very doubtful whether the court would have interfered. But, having felt constrained to permit the defense to be made, it grants such permission to the claimant, but only upon the terms that the claimant shall pay all taxable costs thus far incurred by the libelant in the cause.
Upon payment of these costs, let the libel be dismissed.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Hoof v. Pacific American Fisheries
... ... --------- ... [1] Thames Towboat Co. v. The Schooner Francis ... McD., 254 U.S. 242, 41 Sup.Ct. 65, 65 L.Ed. 245; The America ... (D.C.) 56 F. 1021; The Hattie Thomas (D.C.) 59 F. 297; The ... Sirius (D.C.) 65 F. 226; The James T. Furber (D.C.) 157 F ... 124; The Fortuna ... ...
-
Hoof v. Pacific American Fisheries
... ... Kemp. Fed. Cas ... No. 5341, 2 Lowell, 477; The Navis (D.C.) 196 F. 843. But the ... weight of authority is otherwise. The America (D.C.) 56 F ... 1021; The Hattie Thomas (D.C., 59 F. 297; The Sirius (D.C.) ... 65 F. 226; The James T. Furber (D.C.) 157 F. 124; The Fortuna ... ...
-
Pond v. The Hattie Thomas
... ... earlier cases, and distinguished them from the case before ... it. See, also, The Wyoming, 36 F. 493. In The America, 56 F ... 1021, Judge Green, citing The E. A. Barnard, 2 F. 712, and ... The Island City, 1 Low. 375, holds that the services of a ... ship ... ...
-
Williams v. The Sirius
... ... services rendered to a vessel in her home port as watchman or ... ship keeper there is no maritime lien is The America, 56 F ... 1021. In that case Judge Green said: ... 'This ... claim is a meritorious one, and should be paid. The ... services for which ... ...