Joslin v. McLean

• Decision Date: 27 March 1894
• Citation: 58 N.W. 467,99 Mich. 480
• Court: Michigan Supreme Court
• Parties: JOSLIN v. McLEAN.

58 N.W. 467

99 Mich. 480

JOSLIN v. McLEAN.

Supreme Court of Michigan

March 27, 1894

Error to circuit court, Saginaw county; John A. Edget, Judge.

Action by Eugene M. Joslin against John McLean for rent. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendant brings error. Affirmed.

Trask & Smith, for appellant.

Wood & Joslin, for appellee.

HOOKER, J.

The only question in this case is whether there was the evidence of a surrender of defendant's leasehold interest sufficient to require the trial court to submit the case to a jury. As stated by the learned circuit judge, the cases of Stewart v. Sprague, 71 Mich. 50, 38 N.W. 673, and Scott v. Beecher, 91 Mich. 594, 52 N.W. 20, are conclusive of this controversy, which it would be profitless to discuss further. Judgment affirmed. The other justices concurred.