Kelly v. Town of Brattleboro, 92-581
| Decision Date | 01 October 1993 |
| Docket Number | No. 92-581,92-581 |
| Parties | Theodore A. KELLY, Jr. v. TOWN OF BRATTLEBORO. |
| Court | Vermont Supreme Court |
Before ALLEN, C.J., and GIBSON, DOOLEY and MORSE, JJ., and GRUSSING, District Judge, specially assigned.
Plaintiff sued the Town of Brattleboro after driving his car into an excavation on a Town street, and appeals from an order of the Windham Superior Court granting the Town's summary judgment motion. We reverse and remand.
The accident occurred at the site where the Town was reinstalling a water service pipe, owned by a private business, at a lower depth to keep the pipe from freezing during the winter. In its ruling on the motion for summary judgment, the trial court characterized the work as road maintenance. The court concluded that even though "the road was excavated by the Town for purposes beneficial to and required by a private citizen ... benefit to private landowners and advantages to privately owned properties are necessary and normal in the performance of road maintenance tasks." As such, the court found that the Town was performing a governmental function, and granted defendant's summary judgment motion on grounds of sovereign immunity.
Plaintiff argues that the Town's work was proprietary, not governmental, and, therefore, the Town was not shielded by sovereign immunity. In Dugan v. City of Burlington, 135 Vt. 303, 304, 375 A.2d 991, 992 (1977), we held that "those functions which are governmental are protected by the doctrine of sovereign immunity, while, in contrast, the governmental unit will be liable for injuries caused or sustained in furtherance of its proprietary functions." The plaintiff in Dugan claimed that he had been injured by falling into a partially covered sewer catch-basin. Id. at 305, 375 A.2d at 992. We reversed the trial court's dismissal of the complaint because it was uncertain whether the catch-basin was part of the sewer system or part of the street. If on remand the basin was found to be part of the sewer system, the city's action would have been proprietary. Id.
In Fuller v. City of Rutland, 122 Vt. 284, 171 A.2d 58 (1961), we confirmed Winn v. Village of Rutland, 52 Vt. 481 (1880), and held that municipal sewer activities were proprietary. In Fuller, the plaintiff had driven into a water-filled hole in a city street, which had been dug to repair a sewer line, and brought a negligence claim against the city. 122 Vt. at 285, 171 A.2d at 58. We ruled that the...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Hillerby v. Town of Colchester
...at 423-24, 160 A.2d at 766-67 (distinction produces anomalous results in factually similar cases). But see Kelly v. Town of Brattleboro, 161 Vt. 566, 567, 641 A.2d 345, 346 (1993) (mem.) (applying distinction in same year that Hudson was In the present case, the Town argues that this Court ......
-
Gretkowski v. City of Burlington
...Co., 125 Vt. 348, 350, 215 A.2d 508 (1965), but the maintenance of sewers is a proprietary function, see Kelly v. Town of Brattleboro, 161 Vt. 566, 567, 641 A.2d 345 (1993); Fuller v. City of Rutland, 122 Vt. 284, 286, 171 A.2d 58 (1961); Winn, 52 Vt. at 491. But see Dugan, 135 Vt. at 305, ......
-
Kucera v. Tkac
...governmental function.") (citing Gain v. City of Burlington, 202 F.2d 532, 533 (2d Cir. 1953)). Plaintiff cites Kelly v. Town of Brattleboro, 641 A.2d 345 (Vt. 1993) and Fuller v. City of Rutland, 171 A.2d 58 (Vt. 1961), and asks the court to find that "the establishment and supervision of ......
-
In re Noemi B., No. H14-CP05-008118-A (CT 10/20/2005)
...M., Superior Court, Juvenile Matters, judicial district of Montville, Docket No. 92051 (February 23, 1993, Silbert, J.), aff'd, 229 Conn. 345, 641 A.2d 345 (1994), in discussing whether predictive neglect could be applied to a neglect petition, the court skillfully reasoned that such an app......