Lawyers Title Ins. Co. v. Carey Hodges & Associates, Inc.
Decision Date | 13 February 1978 |
Docket Number | No. 11758,11758 |
Citation | 358 So.2d 964 |
Parties | LAWYERS TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY v. CAREY HODGES & ASSOCIATES, INC., and Paul J. Morel. |
Court | Court of Appeal of Louisiana — District of US |
Paul M. Hebert, Baton Rouge, of counsel for plaintiff-appellant Lawyers Title Insurance Corp.
Jack Roberts, Jr., Baton Rouge, of counsel for defendant-appellee Carey Hodges Associates, et al.
Before LANDRY, SARTAIN and ELLIS, JJ.
Lawyers Title Insurance Company (Appellant) subrogee of its insured, Lowe's Companies, Inc. (Lowe's), appeals dismissal of its subrogated demand against defendants Carey Hodges & Associates, Inc. (Surveyor) and Surveyor's employee Paul J. Morel, for reimbursement of a claim paid Lowe's pursuant to a policy of title insurance issued by Appellant covering a parcel of land purchased by Lowe's on the strength of a survey by Surveyor. The survey erroneously located drainage facilities on Lowe's land which in reality were on neighboring land. Relying on the survey, Lowe's planned its drainage to utilize the facilities indicated as being on its property. The error was discovered after Lowe's installed its drainage. The work installed by Lowe's had to be removed and new facilities constructed. The trial court found that Surveyor made a mistake but that a mistake does not necessarily constitute actionable negligence and rejected Appellant's demand on the ground that Appellant failed to produce expert testimony to establish Surveyor's negligence by showing that Surveyor failed to exercise the degree of skill and care exercised by other surveyors in the vicinity. We reverse and render judgment for Appellant.
Subject property fronts on a service road running along and parallel to the north side of Florida Boulevard in Baton Rouge, which thoroughfare is subject to the jurisdiction of the State Department of Highways. Surveyor's plat, dated July, 1973, shows a 24" ' pipe lying within the highway right of way parallel to Lowe's front property line.
Lowe's intended to use the land for a large retail outlet. Prior to purchasing the location, Lowe's had the property inspected by its design and construction Engineer, Ken Canter. With Surveyor's plat in hand, Canter went on the property and observed the drainage facilities existing in the highway right of way, including the 24" land. On July 12, 1974, Lowe's received a letter from Charles Hair, Chief Engineer of the City-Parish Government, informing Lowe's that Brinkhaus' complaint was being investigated. Before Lowe's could open its store, it had to have an occupancy permit from the City-Parish Government. It was made plain to Lowe's that the permit would not be forthcoming until the drainage problem was solved. Lowe's then requested bids from several contractors, including its on-the-job contractor, to perform the work necessary to remedy the error. Lowe's on-the-job contractor submitted a low bid of $8,983.00. On July 19, 1974, Lowe's deposited a cash bond of $8,983.00 with City-Parish authorities as a good faith deposit to insure performance of the remedial work. Lowe's also requested and, on July 22, 1974, was granted a permit by the Department of Highways to install a catch basin within the highway right of way to drain into the Department's system.
The curative work involved removal of the encroachment from Brinkhaus' land. This necessitated a complete revamping of the original drainage plan including removal and relocation of curbing, installation of more than 200' of pipe, construction of catch basins, removal of some asphalt paving, reworking a sewerage treatment plant, seeding, landscaping and miscellaneous clean up. The contractor submitted to Lowe's a bill for $8,215.00 which Lowe's paid...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Carter's Ins. Agency, Inc. v. Franklin
...recognized in Unverzagt v. Young Builders, Inc., 252 La. 1091, 215 So.2d 823 (1968) and Lawyers Title Insurance Company v. Carey Hodges & Associates, Inc., 358 So.2d 964 (La.App. 1st Cir.1978). The doctrine of imputation of payments, La.C.C. arts. 2163 et seq., and not that of mitigation of......
-
Hostetler v. W. Gray & Co., Inc.
... ... LSA-C.C. Art. 2545 is in Book III, Title VII entitled "Of Sale." The first article in ... Crawford v. Gray and Associates, 493 So.2d 734 (La.App. 2d Cir.1986), writs ... (La.1986) and 497 So.2d 1013 (La.1986); Lawyers Title Insurance Company v. Carey Hodges and ... ...
-
Bell v. Jones
...85 Conn. 337, 341, 82 A. 577, 579 (1912); Palivoda v. Bruette, 250 A.2d 808, 810 (Del.Super.1969); Lawyers Title Insurance Co. v. Carey Hodges & Associates, 358 So.2d 964, 967 (La.App. 1978); McKinnon v. Batte, 485 So.2d 295, 298 (Miss. 1986); Simonds v. Board of Examiners for Land Surveyor......
-
Crawford v. Gray and Associates
...same degree and care and skill exercised by others in the profession in the same general area. Lawyers Title Insurance Company v. Carey Hodges and Associates, 358 So.2d 964 (La.App. 1st Cir.1978); see also Charles Carter & Company, Inc. v. Edward C. McGee, Jr., 213 So.2d 89 (La.App. 1st Def......