Lee v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co.
Decision Date | 19 January 1949 |
Citation | 81 F. Supp. 1008 |
Parties | LEE v. ÆTNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO. |
Court | U.S. District Court — Southern District of New York |
H. Lee Kanner, of New York City, for plaintiff.
Daniel Miner, of New York City, for defendant.
Plaintiff and defendant move for summary judgment under Rule 56, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, 28 U.S.C.A.
The complaint asserts two claims: In the first, plaintiff seeks to recover $5,000 and $334.76 costs with interest thereon, under a policy of liability insurance issued by defendant to Trefflich Pet Shop, Inc. (hereafter the insured). This claim is based on the provisions of Section 167, subd. 1(b) of the New York Insurance Law, Consol.Laws, c. 28. In the second claim, plaintiff seeks to recover for the expenses alleged to have been incurred by the insured in the defense of an action brought against him by plaintiff, which defendant declined to defend. This claim has been assigned by the insured to plaintiff.
A copy of the insurance policy has been submitted on this motion and its terms are not disputed. Defendant, under this policy, undertook to insure from January 1, 1944, to January 1, 1945, and by its terms obligated itself, "To pay on behalf of the Insured all sums which the Insured shall become obligated to pay by reason of the liability imposed upon him for damages, including damages for care and loss of services, because of the hazards defined in the Special Provisions;" and to "* * defend in his name and behalf any suit against the Insured alleging injury, sickness, disease or destruction covered by this Policy and seeking damages on account thereof, even if such suit is groundless, false or fraudulent. * * *."
The application attached to the policy contains the following Declaration (5) limiting coverage by the insurer:
"Description of Elevators "Number of Elevators "None"
The policy under Definition of Hazards provides coverage for:
The policy also sets forth a number of specified Exclusions one of which reads:
* * * * * *
"(d) to the ownership, maintenance or use of any elevator, unless described herein, at the Premises or owned, rented or controlled by the Insured;" For these motions we accept as undisputed the following facts, most favorable to plaintiff —
Joe Lee, the plaintiff, was asked by a friend to purchase a monkey. On February 9, 1944, Lee went to the shop of the insured at 215-217 Fulton Street, New York City, in quest of a suitable simian. The insured occupied and rented the street floor where it conducted a retail pet shop. Henry Trefflich, the president of the insured, conducted as an individual a wholesale pet shop in premises he rented and occupied on the fifth floor. The monkeys were housed and sold from this floor. There was a freight elevator in the building used in common by all the tenants.
Testifying on the trial of the action brought by him against the insured in the New York Supreme Court, Lee described his misfortunes after entering the shop, as follows:
And he continued:
* * * * * *
(folio 158)
Lee found that he had stepped into an elevator shaft; the elevator not being there he fell down a distance of about 15 feet landing on concrete basement flooring. He sustained serious bodily injuries for which he recovered judgment against the insured in the sum of $33,000. This judgment was later reduced by the Appellate Division, First Department to $25,000, Lee v. Trefflich, 272 App.Div. 255, 70 N.Y.S.2d 611, and as so reduced was affirmed by the Court of Appeals. Lee v. Trefflich, 297 N.Y. 772, 77 N.E.2d 789. Lee has collected $5,000 on account of this judgment; the balance together with interest and costs has remained unpaid for more than 30 days after due notice thereof to defendant.
With the acceptance of these facts, the only question presented on these motions insofar as the first claim is concerned is whether the accident which befell Lee, and the consequent and determined liability of the insured comes within the coverage of the policy. The liability of the insured can no longer be questioned by defendant, the insurer. Jones v. Zurich General Accident & Liability Ins. Co., 2 Cir., 1941, 121 F.2d 761.
Plaintiff's rights under Section 167 subd. 1(b), of the New York Insurance Law are to be measured by the protection and coverage afforded the insured under the terms and provisions of the policy. Coleman v. New Amsterdam Casualty Co., 247 N.Y. 271, 275, 160 N.E. 367, 72 A.L. R. 1443.
Exclusion clause "8(d)" of the policy applies to the accident involved here; the declaration of the insured described the elevators to be insured as "none;" the policy defines elevator to include "shaft, hoistway, or other appliances or parts thereof." The accident in which Lee was injured arose out of the use of the elevator; there was no coverage. Marcus v. United...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Snyder Heating Co., Inc. v. Pennsylvania Mfrs. Ass'n Ins. Co.
...... See Toombs NJ Inc. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 404 Pa.Super. 471, 475-76, 591 A.2d 304, 306 (1991) (insurance company had ......
-
Stidham v. Millvale Sportsmen's Club
...517 A.2d 982 (1986); C. Raymond Davis & Sons, Inc. v. Liberty Mutual Ins. Co., 467 F.Supp. 17 (E.D.Pa.1979); Lee v. Aetna Casualty and Surety Co., 81 F.Supp. 1008 (S.D.N.Y.1949), aff'd, 178 F.2d 750 (2nd Aetna relies on the complaint to join the additional defendant McLaughlin as dispositiv......
-
W. Hills Dev. Co. v. Chartis Claims, Inc.
...fell down the shaft. The plaintiff sued the store and ultimately obtained a judgment against it. See Lee v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co. , 81 F.Supp. 1008, 1009–10 (SD NY 1949). In turn, the store filed an action against its insurer, contending that the insurer was obligated (1) to pay the j......
-
Aragona v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co.
...coverage of the policy because the accident arose out of the use of the elevator a use expressly excluded under the policy. It said, 81 F.Supp. 1008 at 1011: "We do not agree with plaintiff's contention that the proximate cause of the accident was the wrongful and negligent invitation to en......