Luter v. Hammon, 57346

Decision Date20 July 1988
Docket NumberNo. 57346,57346
Citation529 So.2d 625
PartiesEmmett LUTER v. Betty L. HAMMON.
CourtMississippi Supreme Court

Stephen E. Gardner, Stephen W. Rimmer, Young, Scanlon & Sessums, Jackson, for appellant.

Ronald L. Whittington, Guy, Whittington & Ott, McComb, for appellee.

Before ROY NOBLE LEE, C.J., and PRATHER and ROBERTSON, JJ.

ROBERTSON, Justice, for the Court:

I.

This is a rezoning case. City authorities have rezoned from residential to commercial certain undeveloped properties lying between a business enterprise and a residence and generally surrounded by commercial properties in downtown Tylertown, Mississippi.

On appeal, the Circuit Court reversed, holding that the rezoning proponents have not shown enough proof of change of circumstances in the neighborhood. Our review of the record convinces us that there was enough evidence of a change and as well a public need for the rezoning so that the rezoning decision falls within that category we label "fairly debatable". The decision is thus insulated from judicial interference.

The judgment of the Circuit Court is reversed and rendered.

II.

A brief perusal of the maps reflect a familiar scene: the gradual disappearance of downtown residential land use and conversion to commercial uses. This process takes place in small towns like Tylertown, as well as in our larger cities. Hammon's is one of four residences left in an area surrounded by commercially zoned properties.

Our subject is a vacant lot near Tylertown's central business district, owned by Emmett Luter and inherited from his recently deceased father, Hosea Luter. The parcel at issue has heretofore carried an R-2 (single family residential) zoning classification, although it has never been used as such. Adjacent to the property at issue, Luter owns another lot which has long held a C-1 (neighborhood commercial) zoning classification under Tylertown's 1966 Zoning Ordinance. Luter and his father before him have for years operated a wholesale plumbing and electrical supply business known as "Luter's Supply" on this lot.

On the other side of the disputed lot is the residence occupied by Betty L. Hammon, today's Appellee. Hammon's residence has been zoned R-2 under the 1966 Zoning Ordinance.

Tylertown's authorities proposed to change the zoning on Luter's vacant lot from R-2 to C-1, and public notice was given thereof. Hammon protested and filed a written objection. Further written protests were received from the other three residential property owners in the area: Inez Ball, Leon Duncan and Jerry Lawrence.

Luter stated that he plans to use the property in his business, primarily as a place to store pipe and to be used as a truck turnaround. He agreed to maintain unused a twenty foot buffer zone between his property and Hammon's and to work to create a nicer appearance on his lot.

On February 5, 1985, the matter was heard and the Tylertown Mayor and Board of Aldermen responded with a series of findings and conclusions, beginning with a careful description of the area in controversy.

The ... area of contention lies in two city blocks. The boundaries of the western block are Beulah Avenue (or U.S. Highway 98) on the North, Adams Street on the West, North Railroad Avenue on the South, and Simmons Street on the East. Luter's Supply, a wholesale plumbing and electrical supplier, currently operates its offices, warehouses and storage yards in the Western portion of this block, which part of the block is zoned C-1, the Luter's Supply operation taking up approximately the western two-thirds or three-fourths of the block. Four single family residences are located on the Eastern side of this block, the Northernmost residential lot being located at the intersection of Beulah Avenue and Simmons Street, and the other three residences being on lots contiguous to each other along Simmons Street, the southern most of said residential lots being occupied by the residence of Mrs. Betty Hammon. From the Southern line of Mrs. Hammon's property and along Simmons Street to Railroad Avenue, there is a vacant lot owned by Mr. Hosea Luter. It is the zoning of this corner lot that is the contention in this block. This lot and all the other four lots occupied by residences and facing Simmons Street are presently zoned R-2, single-family district, but the corner lot which is in contention is proposed under the new zoning map to be zoned C-1.

In the end the Mayor and Board rezoned Luter's property C-4 (general commercial), instead of C-1. In so doing they announced:

In making our decision on this matter, we have considered all the testimony taken at the hearing, each of the documents introduced into evidence, and our own intimate knowledge of and familiarity with our distinctive community and its citizens.

The Mayor and Board then justified their rezoning decision.

We have considered the recent development, or lack of it, in the neighborhood surrounding the disputed area....

... To the East along North Railroad Avenue, no development has taken place West of Lampton Street except the construction of a lumber warehouse at the Northwest intersection of Lampton Street and North Railroad Avenue. Along Beulah Avenue, a nursery and daycare center has been established at the Southwest intersection of South Collins Street and Beulah Avenue and a law office has been established at the Southeast corner of Simmons Street and Beulah Avenue. On the North side of Beulah Avenue a fast food restaurant and an insurance office have been developed in the block between South Collins Street and Adams Street....

The increased commercial development along Beulah Avenue, the development of the remaining Luter's Supply property as a center of commercial activity, and the lack of recent residential development in the neighborhood persuade us that the portion of the disputed property lying between Conerly Street and Simmons Street should be zoned C-1 neighborhood commercial district and that portion of the disputed property between Simmons Street and Adams Street belonging to Hosea D. Luter and all his property West of Adams Street should be zoned for commercial use, but we are further persuaded that the appropriate zoning classification would be C-4 general commercial district rather than C-1 neighborhood commercial district. [Emphasis supplied]

Betty L. Hammon promptly appealed to the Circuit Court of Walthall County, Mississippi. After reviewing the Bill of Exceptions, the documents, exhibits and photographs and having considered the briefs of counsel and oral argument, the Circuit Court by judgment entered March 14, 1986, reversed and ordered that the subject property be restored to its residential zoning classification under the 1966 Zoning Ordinance. The Circuit Court found that the proponents of rezoning "had failed to meet the necessary burden of proof to rezone the above described parcels." The judgment of the Circuit Court has now been appealed to this Court.

III.

The Town of Tylertown has taken no appeal from the judgment of the Circuit Court. Instead, Emmett Luter, as a taxpayer of Tylertown and as the owner of the subject property, has prosecuted this appeal, seeking reinstatement of the rezoning classifications ordered by the Mayor and Board of Aldermen on April 2, 1985. Hammon complains that Luter has no standing or authority to proceed with this appeal.

An identical legal question has been presented in Luter v. Oakhurst Associates, Ltd., et al., 529 So.2d 889, 892 (Miss. 1988). On the authority of Luter I, we hold that Emmett Luter has standing to prosecute this appeal and that he is a proper party appellant. Miss.Code Ann. Sec. 11-51-105 (Supp.1987).

IV.

Turning to the merits, our law is well settled that, before municipal authorities have the power to rezone, they must find either

(1) that there was a mistake in the original zoning, or

(2)(a) that the character of the neighborhood has changed substantially so that rezoning is clearly justified and

(b) that there is a public need for the rezoning of the property.

Saunders v. City of Jackson, 511 So.2d 902, 906 (Miss.1987); Board of Aldermen, City of Clinton v. Conerly, 509 So.2d 877, 883 (Miss.1987); Thrash v. Mayor and Commissioners of the City of Jackson, 498 So.2d...

To continue reading

Request your trial
22 cases
  • Wheelan v. City of Gautier
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • February 3, 2022
    ...are "legislative in nature." Thomas v. Bd. of Supervisors of Panola Cty. , 45 So. 3d 1173, 1180 (Miss. 2010) (citing Luter v. Hammon , 529 So. 2d 625, 628 (Miss. 1988) ). And "[z]oning ordinances should be given a fair and reasonable construction, in the light of their terminology, the obje......
  • Enlargement of Corporate Limits of City of Hattiesburg, Matter of
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • May 29, 1991
    ...sort of facts legislators ground their legislative judgments, a point we have recognized in other settings. See, e.g., Luter v. Hammon, 529 So.2d 625, 629 (Miss.1988); Thrash v. Mayor and Commissioners of City of Jackson, 498 So.2d 801, 805 (Miss.1986); Board of Aldermen of Town of Bay Spri......
  • Edwards v. Harrison County
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • August 27, 2009
    ...of review for zoning as follows: This Court has held that zoning is not a judicial matter, but a legislative matter. Luter v. Hammon, 529 So.2d 625, 628 (Miss.1988). On appeal, the decision of the Board must be upheld unless it is "arbitrary, capricious, discriminatory, or is illegal, or wi......
  • Hatfield v. Bd. of Supervisors of Madison Cnty.
    • United States
    • Mississippi Supreme Court
    • August 10, 2017
    ...are "legislative in nature." Thomas v. Bd. of Supervisors of Panola Cty. , 45 So.3d 1173, 1180 (Miss. 2010) (citing Luter v. Hammon , 529 So.2d 625, 628 (Miss. 1988) ). And "[z]oning ordinances should be given a fair and reasonable construction, in the light of their terminology, the object......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT