Manhattan Trust Co. v. City of Dayton

Decision Date09 December 1893
Docket Number114.
PartiesMANHATTAN TRUST CO. et al. v. CITY OF DAYTON.
CourtU.S. Court of Appeals — Sixth Circuit

The Dayton Natural Gas Company is an Ohio corporation, organized originally under the name of the Southwestern Ohio Natural Gas & Petroleum Oil Company. On the 18th of March, 1887, the city council of Dayton, Ohio, by ordinance, authorized said corporation to occupy streets, alleys, and public grounds of the city, and lay pipes for the purpose of furnishing gas to the public and to private citizens. By the terms of the ordinance it had 18 months within which to introduce gas into the city, under penalty of forfeiture of all the rights under the ordinance. The company accepted the ordinance, and executed the bond as required by it, and began the work of establishing itself within the city. It failed, however, to introduce gas by January 1, 1889, and in consequence of this failure the city council, by resolution, in pursuance of the reserved power mentioned in the ordinance, declared all the rights granted thereby forfeited. Prior to this forfeiture, and on the 23d of December, 1887, the council had passed an ordinance regulating the price to be charged by the gas company for natural gas to be furnished by it for fuel purposes for and during a period of five years next ensuing from and after the date at which the ordinance should take effect, which was to be at the expiration of 10 days from the date of its first publication. The schedule of prices contained in that ordinance related alone to gas to be furnished for fuel purposes by 'mixer measurement.' Section 2 of the ordinance was in these words: 'The foregoing is fixed as the minimum price at which said city council requires said company to furnish gas to the citizens of said city, and for the public buildings of said city, for said term of five years, and said company is hereby required to assent thereto by written acceptance, filed in the office of the city clerk of said city.' This ordinance was duly accepted by the gas company.

On the 28th of March, 1889, the name of the company having been changed to the Dayton Natural Gas Company, an ordinance was passed by the city of Dayton, granting to the company 'the right and privilege to lay, maintain and operate pipes in the city for the purpose of supplying natural gas for heating, fuel and power purposes only.' This ordinance was in the following words and figures:

'Section 1. Be it ordained by the city council of the city of Dayton, that, subject to the terms, conditions and limitations of this ordinance, there is granted to the Dayton Natural Gas Company, its successors and assigns, the right and privilege, for the term of twenty years, to lay maintain and operate mains, pipes, branches and conduits through the streets, lanes, alleys, avenues and public grounds of said city for the purpose of supplying said city and its inhabitants with natural gas, or produced gas, for heating, fuel and power purposes only.
'Sec 2. Before said company shall do any work or lay any pipes, it shall execute a bond to the city of Dayton in the penal sum of $50,000, to the acceptance of the city council of said city, with not less than five sureties thereon, three of whom shall be residents of said city, conditioned as follows:
'(1) That said company shall proceed within ten days after being notified so to do by the city civil engineer of said city, to repair and place in good condition the streets, avenues, lanes and alleys of said city, where pipes have heretofore been laid or work done by said company, or by the S.W. O. N. G. & P. O. Co., and prosecute said work with diligence.
'(2) That said company will not in any manner molest, damage or interfere with any of the gas or water pipes, or public or private sewers now laid or constructed in or along any of the streets, avenues, lanes, alleys or public grounds of said city.
'(3) That said company will restore any and all streets, avenues, lanes, alleys and public grounds in which it may lay pipes, or which it shall disturb or interfere with in laying pipes, to as good condition as they were before the laying of said pipes.
'(4) That said company will, without delay, remove from the streets, avenues, lanes, alleys and public grounds all dirt or rubbish caused by the laying of said pipes.
'(5) That said company will reimburse said city for all money expended in restoring any street, avenue, lane, alley or public place, or any part thereof, to as good condition as the same was before the same was opened for the purpose of laying pipes therein; and for all money expended for clearing away any dirt or rubbish caused by the laying of pipes, as aforesaid, where said company has failed to so restore the condition of any street, avenue, lane, alley or public place, or to remove such rubbish or dirt within ten days after receiving written notice from the city civil engineer so to do.
'(6) That it shall indemnify and save harmless the said city from and against any and all claims, demands, suits or liabilities of any kind that said city may be subjected to or incurred by reason of or growing out of the opening of said streets, avenues, lanes, alleys and public places, or the laying of pipes therein, or of permitted or of having such gas within the city, or in the said pipes, or the doing of work incident to this grant, or in consequence of injuries or damages to persons or property by such gas, or by reason of any explosion of such gas, or growing out of the failure of said company to restore the streets, avenues, lanes, alleys and public places as aforesaid, it being the intention that said company shall be primarily liable as between it and the city in all such cases.
'Sec. 3. The city council may, at any time, require the renewal of said bond, when in its judgment it has become insufficient.
'Sec. 4. Whenever said city shall determine to construct any sewer in or along any street, avenue, lane, alley or public place where any pipe of said company is laid, said company shall, at its own expense, lower, elevate, change, or remove any such pipe, so that such sewer may be constructed as desired by the city.
'Sec. 5. All pavements, sidewalks, curbstones, gutters, streets, lanes, alleys, avenues or public grounds disturbed or injured by said company, in any manner or by any means, shall at once be placed in as good condition as it was before so injured or disturbed.
'Sec. 6. All work in laying or repairing pipes shall be prosecuted in such a manner as not to interfere with the use or travel upon the streets, avenues, alleys, lanes or public places of said city, where it can be avoided, and when such use is unavoidable obstructed by said company it shall, with reasonable dispatch, repair and replace such street, avenue, lane, alley, or public place.
'Sec. 7. All pipes, mains, and apparatus of every kind used by said company shall be of the most improved design and quality. All pipes shall be of standard weight, and be so laid as not to interfere with the use of the streets, avenues, alleys, lanes and public places after same are in place.
'Sec. 8. In order to provide against gas that may escape from high and low pressure mains and pipes from passing into cellars, sewers and buildings, it shall be, and is hereby, made the duty of said company to furnish and supply perforated stop-box lids on all stop-boxes. Gauges showing the amount of pressure on all natural gas lines shall be erected in the city civil engineer's office, at the expense of the company, and there shall be as many gauges as are necessary to indicate the pressure upon all low pressure lines in said city.
'Sec. 9. Said company shall at all times maintain pressure for domestic use of not less than four ounces nor more than eight ounces to the square inch, at the point of consumption.
'Sec. 10. Any consumer within said city shall have the right to require gas to be furnished by meter measurement, and not by the schedule rates; in cases where a meter is used, said company shall have the right to charge and receive any sum not exceeding ten cents per thousand cubic feet, if paid within ten days, or twelve and one-half cents per thousand cubic feet, if not so paid, for the gas used. Such meter shall be furnished and set in place upon the application of any consumer, without cost to such consumer, by said company; but said company shall be entitled to charge a rent of three dollars per year in advance therefor.
'Sec. 11. For all manufacturing purposes, natural gas shall be supplied and furnished at the option of the consumer. First, at not to exceed seventy-five per cent of the cost of coal; or, second, by special agreement, and in that event, at the same rate to all, whether large or small consumers, and in no case shall preference be given in price to one consumer over another; or, third, by meter measurements, not exceeding ten cents per one thousand cubic feet, if paid within ten days, as heretofore provided, the meter to be furnished and set by the company without cost to the consumer, but at the same rent and terms as heretofore named.
'Sec. 12. Said company may cut off the gas from any consumer in case of ten days' default after bills are due in the payment. But when payment is made, gas shall again be furnished to such consumer, on his request.
'Sec. 13. Said company shall be compelled to furnish gas to all applicants, whenever applied for. Said company shall, within ninety days after being ordered so to do by the council, lay pipes in any streets, lanes, avenues, alleys or public places, contiguous to streets, etc., where their pipes are then laid, provided that, in the opinion of said city council, the amount of gas consumed by such parties will
...

To continue reading

Request your trial
11 cases
  • Saleno v. the City of Neosho
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 19 Marzo 1895
  • The State ex inf. Chaney v. West Missouri Power Company
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 12 Marzo 1926
    ...then in force limiting the term of such a grant to a period not exceeding twenty years and is void for that reason. Manhattan Trust Co. v. City of Dayton, 59 F. 327; Boise Water Co. v. Boise City, 230 U.S. 92. (6) consent to use the city's public ways by an individual or corporation for the......
  • Neosho City Water Company v. City of Neosho
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 23 Diciembre 1896
    ...is null and void. To this position we are not prepared to assent. The case at bar is, we think, clearly distinguishable from Manhattan Trust Co. v. Dayton, 59 F. 327, and of a similar character relied upon by defendant, as supporting this contention. In that case the municipal council was a......
  • The State ex rel. St. Louis Transfer Company v. Clifford
    • United States
    • Missouri Supreme Court
    • 26 Mayo 1910
    ...v. Day, 35 F. 866; Andrew Jackson ex parte, 45 Ark. 158; McConnell v. Mayor, 39 N. J. L. 38; Water Co. v. Neosho, 136 Mo. 498; Manhattan Co. v. Dayton, 59 F. 327; Hannibal Telephone Co., 31 Mo.App. 23; Mt. Olive v. Haslet, 26 Pitts. L. J. (Pa. St.) 400; Austin v. Murray, 16 Pick. 121. (7) I......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT