Mariah B. v. State

Decision Date31 August 2022
Docket NumberS-18026
CourtAlaska Supreme Court
PartiesMARIAH B., Appellant, v. STATE OF ALASKA, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH & SOCIAL SERVICES, OFFICE OF CHILDREN'S SERVICES, Appellee.

UNPUBLISHED See Alaska Appellate Rule 214(d)

Emily L. Jura, Assistant Public Defender, and Samantha Cherot Public Defender, Anchorage, for Appellant.

Laura Fox, Senior Assistant Attorney General, Anchorage, and Treg R. Taylor, Attorney General, Juneau, for Appellee.

Laura Hartz, Assistant Public Advocate, and James Stinson, Public Advocate, Anchorage, for Guardian Ad Litem.

Before: Winfree, Chief Justice, Maassen, Carney, Borghesan and Henderson, Justices.

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND JUDGMENT [*]

1. The superior court terminated a mother's parental rights to her daughter after trial. The mother appealed, arguing that the superior court improperly admitted and relied on hearsay evidence to make its termination findings and erred by finding that the Office of Children's Services (OCS) made reasonable efforts to reunify the family.[1]Without reaching the reasonable efforts issue, we remanded for the court to explain its evidentiary rulings about and its use of hearsay evidence in its termination decision.[2]

2. The superior court issued Supplemental Findings Following Remand providing a detailed explanation of its consideration of hearsay during the termination trial. The court explained that it did not rely on hearsay on the question whether the child was in need of aid.[3] The court further explained why the hearsay evidence it considered was probative of other findings, had circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness, and had arisen in a manner that the mother could meet.

3. After the superior court issued its Supplemental Findings Following Remand, the parties filed supplemental appeal briefs. The mother continued to argue that the court wrongfully relied on inadmissible hearsay. OCS argued that the court's supplement to its original decision demonstrated appropriate use of hearsay and that hearsay evidence did not substantially influence the court's termination findings. The guardian ad litem supported OCS's position.

4. We have considered the parties' original briefing, the superior court's Supplemental Findings Following Remand, and the parties' supplemental briefing. We conclude that the court's clarification of its admission and use of hearsay evidence allows us to understand the termination decision for purposes of appellate review, is consistent with CINA Rule 18(f), and does not reflect legal error or an abuse of discretion warranting reversal of any termination findings.[4] Moreover, with the clarification of the court's use of hearsay evidence, we see no error in the finding that OCS made the required reasonable efforts to reunify the family and that those efforts were unsuccessful.[5] As OCS and the guardian ad litem point out, OCS's efforts easily meet the reasonable efforts standard.[6] 5. The superior court's termination of the mother's parental rights is AFFIRMED.

---------

[*] Entered under Alaska Appellate Rule 214.

[1] Before terminating parental rights a superior court must find by clear and convincing evidence that: (1) a "child has been subjected to conduct or conditions described in AS 47.10.011"; (2) "the parent . . . has not remedied the conduct or conditions that place the child at substantial risk of harm" or "has failed, within a reasonable time, to remedy the conduct or conditions... plac[ing] the child in substantial risk so that returning the child to the parent would place the child at substantial risk of physical or mental injury"; and (3) OCS has made reasonable efforts to provide family support services to the child and to the parent. AS 47.10.088(a); AS 47.10.086. The court must also find "by a preponderance of the evidence that termination ... is in the best interests of the child." CINA Rule 18(c)(3); AS 47.10.088(c).

[3] S...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT