Marston v. Catterlin

CourtMissouri Supreme Court
Writing for the CourtWILLIAMS, J.
CitationMarston v. Catterlin, 270 Mo. 5, 192 S.W. 413 (Mo. 1917)
Decision Date02 February 1917
PartiesEDWIN S. MARSTON, Appellant, v. JOHN M. CATTERLIN et al; JOSEPH HODNETT, Appellant

Appeal from Bates Circuit Court. -- Hon. C. A. Calvird, Judge.

Reversed and remanded (with directions.)

Thomas J. Smith, Bowersock, Hall & Hook and Robert B. Fizzell for appellant Marston.

(1) When the defendant Catterlin acquired the Bates County land by purchase under the foreclosure of the Kerns deed of trust he became a constructive trustee thereof and held the property for the plaintiff. Marston v. Catterlin, 239 Mo. 390; Eoff v. Irvine, 108 Mo. 383; Cameron v. Lewis, 56 Miss. 82; Winn v Dillon, 27 Miss. 496; Olson v. Lamb, 56 Neb 104; Galbraith v. Elder, 8 Watts (Pa.), 81; Henry v. Raiman, 25 Pa. St., 354; Smith v. Brotherline, 62 Pa. St. 461; Ainsworth v. Harding, 22 Idaho 645; Davis v. Smith, 43 Vt. 269; 39 Cyc. 172. (2) When the defendant Catterlin disposed of the Bates County land, he became liable to account to the plaintiff for all of the proceeds of the transaction received by him. 4 Sedgwick on Damages (9 Ed.), sec. 1256h; Perry on Trusts and Trustees (6 Ed.), secs. 429, 430, 844; Pettit v. Carpenter, 86 Mo.App. 452; Whittle v. Vanderbilt M. & M. Co., 83 F. 48; Linnell v. Lyford, 72 Me. 280; Cheshire v. Cheshire, 37 N.C. 569. There is no distinction between express and constructive trustees in this regard. Cheshire v. Cheshire, 37 N.C. 569; Clapp v. Vatcher, 9 Cal.App. 462; Pettit v. Carpenter, 86 Mo.App. 452. (3) The right of the plaintiff to compel the defendant Catterlin to account for the proceeds of his sale of the Bates County land does not depend upon whether or not the defendant Hodnett purchased the land with notice of the present litigation. The plaintiff may elect to hold the defendant Catterlin to account. Oliver v. Pratt, 3 How. (U.S.) 401; Parker v. Straat, 39 Mo.App. 626. (4) No notice of lis pendens having been filed before the defendant Hodnett purchased the Bates County land from the record owner, Hodnett did not have constructive notice of this litigation. Sec. 8211, R. S. 1909; Steele v. Robertson, 75 Ark. 228; Pennington v. Martin, 146 Ind. 635; Trapp v. Bailey, 152 Ky. 369; Perkins v. Ogilvie, 140 Ky. 412; White v. Manning, 26 Ky. L. Rep. 887; St. Ry. Co. v. Detroit, 124 Mich. 449; McKenzie v. Fellows, 97 Miss. 31; Gilman v. Carpenter, 22 S.D. 23; Easley v. Barksdale, 75 Va. 274; DeCamp v. Carnahan, 26 W.Va. 839; Smith v. Gale, 144 U.S. 509; Glass v. Stark, 156 Wis. 21.

C. A. Denton for appellant Hodnett.

(1) The record title that defendant Hodnett purchased under was a complete chain, each link of which was in effect a warranty deed. The deed from Catterlin to Lyons dated September 3, 1904, and recorded the same day, as shown by the record, contained in the granting clause the words "grant, bargain and sell, convey and confirm." There were no words in the habendum clause specifically limiting the said words in the granting clause. Therefore it was a warranty deed and imparted no notice of any equitable defects not of record, that might be against the title to the land involved in this suit. Sec. 2793, R. S. 1909; Tracy v. Greffett, 54 Mo.App. 564; Alexander v. Schreiber, 10 Mo. 460; Collider v. Gambles, 10 Mo. 471; Miller v. Bayless, 101 Mo.App. 487, 194 Mo. 630. (2) Defendant Hodnett had a right to rely upon the covenants of general warranty in the deed from Catterlin to Lyons, as shown by the record in the office of the Recorder of Deeds. Therefore, although the words "grant, bargain and sell, convey and confirm" in the said deed as copied were not in the original deed, having been by mistake so copied on the records, Hodnett had the right to rely upon the records regardless of whether it was a true copy of the original. Terrell v. Andrew County, 44 Mo. 312; White v. Lumber Co., 240 Mo. 13; Ritchie v. Griffith, 12 L. R. A. 384, 22 Am. St. 155; Troyer v. Wood, 96 Mo. 478. (3) The only equitable rights that existed in favor of the plaintiff as found by this court when this case was here before that estopped Catterlin from holding the title to the land in question arose out of Catterlin's acts. In the so called special warranty deed of Catterlin to Lyons, even though it should be held that defendant Hodnett took his title under the conditions of the said deed regardless of the copy as recorded, Catterlin covenanted and warranted against his acts, as will be noted on an examination of the habendum clause. Duffy v. Sharp, 73 Mo.App. 316; 11 Cyc. 1070; Oak Dale v. Fagen, 63 N.W. 456; Jenks v. Ward, 45 Mass. 404; Mitchell v. Warner, 5 Conn. 527.

Silvers & Silvers for respondent.

(1) Plaintiff Marston sued for the land; and cannot recover its value, or the proceeds thereof. 15 Cyc. 262; McMurray v. St. Louis, 138 Mo. 618; Nanson v. Jacob, 93 Mo. 346; Donnelly v. Trust Co., 339 Mo. 370; Hector v. Mann, 225 Mo. 248. (2) Where, as in this case, plaintiff could elect as to remedies, and sue either, (a) for the land, (b) for its value, or (c) for the proceeds arising from its sale, he is bound by his election when he sued for the land itself. Nanson v. Jacobs, 93 Mo. 346. (3) Plaintiff having sued for the land and recovered judgment therefor, has no just cause for appeal. He only asked for the value of the land, in case the court found that it has been placed beyond his reach. (4) Hodnett is in privity with Catterlin as to the land in controversy, claiming through him, and is bound by the judgment of this court which fixed Catterlin's interest in this land. Cooley v. Warren, 53 Mo. 169; Perkins v. Goddin, 11 Mo.App. 443; Henry v. Woods, 77 Mo. 277; Carthage v. Wesner, 116 Mo.App. 121; Mason v. Summers, 124 Mo.App. 174; Litchfield v. Goodnow, 123 U.S. 549; 24 Am. & Eng. Ency. Law, p. 746; Greenleaf, Ev., 523. (5) Catterlin having only a part interest in the land in controversy, he could convey only what he had, and Hodnett could and did get through mesne conveyances from Catterlin only this part interest. Ridgeway v. Holliday, 59 Mo. 455; Bogy v. Shoab, 13 Mo. 380; Craig v. Zimmerman, 87 Mo. 475. (6) The deed from Catterlin to Lyons, was a special warranty, and equivalent to a quit-claim deed only. Mann v. Best, 62 Mo. 497; Oliver v. Pyatt, 3 How. 333; Brown v. Jackson, 3 How. 449; Freeman v. Moffitt, 119 Mo. 306. (7) Hodnett is charged with notice of everything recited in the deeds in his chain of title. Freeman v. Moffitt, 119 Mo. 280. (8) Hodnett who claims under or through quit claim deeds held his interest subject to the equities in favor of Marston, Marston's equities in the land not being subject to registration under our law pertaining to the registration of conveyances. Hendrick v. Calloway, 211 Mo. 563. (9) Hodnett having bought property in litigation at the time of his purchase, takes subject to the result of such litigation. 25 Cyc. 1450; Tice v. Hamilton, 188 Mo. 302; Carr v. Gates, 96 Mo. 274; Parker-Washington Co. v. Clinton, 155 Mo.App. 386. (10) There appeared also in the record of title a recitation that the trust deed given to the New England Loan & Trust Company was a first lien on the property. This was notice to Hodnett, and taken with the circumstance that this $ 1950 trust deed had been foreclosed and the land sold to Marston was sufficient notice to Hodnett to put him on enquiry. Hodnett who traded for the Catterlin interest, had an abstract disclosing to him the seven quit-claim deeds in his chain of title, and the special warranty deed shown on the abstract. This last deed was sufficient to put a reasonable man on guard. And more especially an attorney who knows the significance of such an instrument.

OPINION

WILLIAMS, J.

This is a proceeding by a supplemental bill to have the title to certain land decreed to be in the plaintiff or, if the land should be found to be beyond the reach of the court, then to have the defendant Catterlin account to the plaintiff for the proceeds of the sale of said land. This is the second appeal in the case. The first appeal is reported in the 239th Missouri Report, at page 390. The opinion in that case should be read in connection with this opinion in order to have a correct understanding of the facts. Upon the first appeal, this court reversed the judgment of the trial court and held that the plaintiff should be vested with the title to the real estate in question. Defendant Hodnett was not a party to the original suit. Before final judgment was had upon the first trial, in the trial court, defendant Catterlin conveyed the land in suit, and when the mandate was returned to the trial court this supplemental bill was filed by plaintiff which brought in Joseph Hodnett as an additional defendant. Hodnett was the record owner of the land.

Trial was had in the circuit court of Bates County. The trial court denied plaintiff's right to recover from Catterlin the proceeds of the sale of said land by him, but found that plaintiff was entitled to recover the land from defendant Hodnett, upon the payment to said Hodnett of the sum of $ 348.10. From this judgment both the plaintiff and defendant Hodnett duly perfected an appeal to this court.

The supplemental petition, after stating the facts embraced in the first appeal, alleges that after the filing of the original petition and on the third day of September, 1904 defendant Catterlin conveyed the land to Lyman Lyons and that on the same day said Lyons conveyed the premises to Ray Wolfe; that on November 18, 1904, said Wolfe conveyed said premises to Ralph Earhart; that on January 23, 1905, said Earhart conveyed said premises to defendant Joseph Hodnett; that all of said conveyances were without consideration and did not represent bonafide transactions between the parties, and that the grantees purchased with full notice of the...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex