Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Sers.

Citation115 Fair Empl.Prac.Cas. (BNA) 65,109 A.F.T.R.2d 2012,682 F.3d 1
Decision Date31 May 2012
Docket Number10–2214.,10–2207,Nos. 10–2204,s. 10–2204
PartiesCommonwealth of MASSACHUSETTS, Plaintiff, Appellee, v. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, et al., Defendants, Appellants. Dean Hara, Plaintiff, Appellee/Cross–Appellant, Nancy Gill, et al., Plaintiffs, Appellees, Keith Toney, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Office of Personnel Management, et al., Defendants, Appellants/Cross–Appellees, Hillary Rodham Clinton, in her official capacity as United States Secretary of State, Defendant.
CourtUnited States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (1st Circuit)


Held Unconstitutional

1 U.S.C.A. § 7

Paul D. Clement with whom H. Christopher Bartolomucci, Conor B. Dugan, Nicholas J. Nelson, Bancroft PLLC, Kerry W. Kircher, General Counsel, Office of General Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives, Christine Davenport, Sr., Assistant Counsel, Katherine E. McCarron, Assistant Counsel, William Pittard, Assistant Counsel, and Kirsten W. Konar, Assistant Counsel, were on brief for intervenor-appellant, the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group of the U.S. House of Representatives.

Stuart F. Delery, Acting Assistant Attorney General, Civil Division, Department of Justice, with whom Tony West, Assistant Attorney General, Carmen M. Ortiz, United States Attorney, Robert E. Kopp, Michael Jay Singer, August E. Flentje and Benjamin S. Kingsley, Appellate Staff, Civil Division, Department of Justice, were on brief for the federal defendants.

Anthony R. Picarello, Jr., Jeffrey Hunter Moon, Michael F. Moses, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, Von G. Keetch, Alexander Dushku, R. Shawn Gunnarson, Kirton & McConkie and Carl H. Esbeck, Legal Counsel, Office of Governmental Affairs, National Association of Evangelicals, on brief for U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops; National Association of Evangelicals; The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints; The Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention; The Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod; The Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America; The Massachusetts Catholic Conference; The Brethren in Christ Church; The Christian and Missionary Alliance; The Conservative Congregational Christian Conference; The Evangelical Free Church of America; The Evangelical Presbyterian Church; The International Church of the Foursquare Gospel; The International Pentecostal Holiness Church; The Missionary Church; Open Bible Churches [USA]; The United Brethren in Christ Church; The Wesleyan Church, Amici Curiae.

John Anthony Simmons, Sr. and David Ramos on brief for American College of Pediatricians, Amicus Curiae.

Lawrence J. Joseph on brief for Eagle Forum Education & Legal Defense Fund, Amicus Curiae.

Paul Benjamin Linton, Special Counsel, Thomas More Society, Thomas Brejcha, President & Chief Counsel, Thomas More Society, and Christopher M. Gacek, Family Research Council, on brief for the Family Research Council, Amicus Curiae.

Kristen K. Waggoner and Ellis, Li & McKinstry PLLC on brief for Robert P. George, Sherif Girgis, and Ryan T. Anderson, Amici Curiae.

David Austin R. Nimocks, Brian W. Raum, Dale Schowengerdt and Holly L. Carmichael, Alliance Defense Fund, on brief for Representative Lamar Smith, Amicus Curiae.

Mary E. McAlister, Stephen M. Crampton, Rena M. Lindevaldsen, Mathew D. Staver and Anita L. Staver, Liberty Counsel, on brief for Liberty Counsel, Amicus Curiae.

Thomas M. Fisher, Solicitor General, Office of the Indiana Attorney General, Gregory F. Zoeller, Attorney General, Office of the Indiana Attorney General, Bill Schuette, Attorney General, State of Michigan, Mark L. Shurtleff, Attorney General, State of Utah, John W. Suthers, Attorney General, State of Colorado, and Alan Wilson, Attorney General, State of South Carolina, on brief for the States of Indiana, Colorado, Michigan, South Carolina, and Utah, Amici Curiae.

John A. Eidsmoe, Roy S. Moore and Benjamin D. DuPré, Foundation for Moral Law, on brief for Foundation for Moral Law, Amicus Curiae.

George I. Goverman on brief pro se, Amicus Curiae.

Russell D. Raskin, Raskin & Berman, Abba Cohen and Mordechai Biser, Agudath Israel of America, on brief for Agudath Israel of America, Amicus Curiae.

William C. Duncan, Marriage Law Foundation, and Joshua K. Baker, National Organization for Marriage, on brief for National Organization for Marriage, Amicus Curiae.

Steven W. Fitschen and Douglas E. Myers on brief for the National Legal Foundation, Amicus Curiae.

Stephen C. Whiting and The Whiting Law Firm on brief for Massachusetts Family Institute, Amicus Curiae.

Kevin T. Snider, Pacific Justice Institute, on brief for Pacific Justice Institute, Amicus Curiae.

Eric C. Bohnet on brief for Concerned Women for America, Amicus Curiae.

Gary G. Kreep on brief for National Association for Research & Therapy of Homosexuality (NARTH), Amicus Curiae.

Mary L. Bonauto with whom Gary D. Buseck, Vickie L. Henry, Janson Wu, Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders, Paul M. Smith, Luke C. Platzer, Matthew J. Dunne, Melissa A. Cox, Jenner & Block LLP, Claire Laporte, Ara B. Gershengorn, Matthew E. Miller, Amy Senier, Catherine Deneke, Foley Hoag LLP, David J. Nagle, Richard L. Jones, and Sullivan & Worcester LLP were on brief for plaintiffs, appelleesNancy Gill, et al., and plaintiff, appellee, cross-appellant Dean Hara.

Maura T. Healey, Assistant Attorney General, with whom Martha Coakley, Attorney General, Jonathan B. Miller, Assistant Attorney General, Christopher K. Barry–Smith, Assistant Attorney General, Mark C. Fleming, Felicia H. Ellsworth, Brian J. Boyle Jr., Alan E. Schoenfeld and Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP were on brief for plaintiff, appellee Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

William F. Sheehan, Goodwin Procter LLP and Nathalie F.P. Gilfoyle, American Psychological Association, on brief for the American Psychological Association, the Massachusetts Psychological Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the National Association of Social Workers and its Massachusetts Chapter, the American Medical Association, and the American Academy of Pediatrics, Amici Curiae.

Clifford H. Ruprecht, Catherine R. Connors, Frank H. Bishop and Pierce Atwood LLP on brief for historians Peter W. Bardaglio, Norma Basch, George Chauncey, Stephanie Coontz, Nancy F. Cott, Toby L. Ditz, Ariela Dubler, Laura F. Edwards, Estelle B. Freedman, Sarah Barringer Gordon, Michael Grossberg, Hendrik Hartog, Ellen Herman, Martha Hodes, Linda K. Kerber, Alice Kessler–Harris, Elaine Tyler May, Steven Mintz, Elizabeth H. Pleck, Carole Shammas, Mary L. Shanley, Amy Dru Stanley and Barbara Young Welke, Amici Curiae.

Patricia A. Peard, Ronald W. Schneider, Jr., Bernstein Shur and Katharine K. Baker, Professor of Law, Chicago–Kent College of Law, on brief for Family Law Professors, Amici Curiae.

William L. Chapman, Emily Gray Rice, Orr & Reno, P.A., Joan Heifetz Hollinger, Lecturer–in–Residence, Child Advocacy Program, University of CA, Berkeley School of Law, Courtney Joslin, Acting Professor, UC Davis School of Law, and Katharine Silbaugh, Professor of Law and Law Alumni Scholar, on brief for Family and Child Welfare Law Professors, Amici Curiae.

Robert G. Young, Daryl J. Lapp, Edwards Wildman Palmer LLP, James D. Esseks, Joshua A. Block, American Civil Liberties Union Foundation, Shannon Minter, Christopher F. Stoll, National Center for Lesbian Rights, Jon W. Davidson, and Peter Renn, Lambda Legal, on brief for 31 Bar Associations, Public–Interest Organizations and Legal Service Organizations, Amici Curiae.

Mirian R. Nemetz, Kathleen Connery Dawe, Michael B. Kimberly, Mayer Brown LLP, and Heather C. Sawyer, Minority Counsel, Committee on the Judiciary, Ranking Members John Conyers, Jr. and Jerrold Nadler, on brief for Members of the U.S. House of Representatives–Including Objecting Members of the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group, Representatives Nancy Pelosi and Steny H. Hoyer, Amici Curiae.

Alan B. Morrison, George Washington Law School, Anne L. Weismann, Melanie Sloan, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, on brief for Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, Amicus Curiae.

Sabin Willett, Beth I.Z. Boland and Bingham McCutchen LLP on brief for 70 Business, Professional and Municipal Employers, and Professional, Trade, and Civic Organizations Representing Employers, Amici Curiae.

Jacob C. Cohn, Jeffrey I. Pasek and Cozen O'Connor on brief for the Jewish Social Policy Action Network, Amicus Curiae.

James L. Linsey, Cohen, Weiss and Simon LLP, National Association of Letter

Carriers, Judith A. Scott, General Counsel, Nicole G. Berner, Associate General Counsel, Laurel R. Webb, Assistant General Counsel, Service Employees International Union, David Borer, General Counsel, Leisha A. Self, Staff Counsel, American Federation of Government Employees, John C. Dempsey, General Counsel, American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, David Strom, General Counsel, American Federation of Teachers, Thomas R. Carpenter, General Counsel, American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, Edward J. Gilmartin, General Counsel, Association of Flight Attendants, Alan S. Gordon, General Counsel, Deborah Allton–Maher, Eastern Counsel, American Guild of Musical Artists, Patrick J. Szymanski, General Counsel, Change to Win, Mary K. O'Melveny, General Counsel, Communications Workers of America, National Education Association, Duncan Crabtree–Ireland, General Counsel, Danielle S. Van Lier, Assistant General Counsel, Screen Actors Guild, David Rosen, General Counsel, Transport Workers Union of America, Michael Nicholson, General Counsel, International Union, UAW, Nick Clark, General Counsel, United Food and Commercial Workers International Union, American Federation of Musicians, Clinton J. Miller III, General Counsel, Erika A. Diehl, Assistant General Counsel, United Transportation Union, Richard J. Brean, General Counsel, United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber,...

To continue reading

Request your trial
79 cases
  • Sixta Gladys Peña Martínez v. Azar
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — District of Puerto Rico
    • April 15, 2019
    ...Gill v. Office of Pers. Mgmt., 699 F. Supp. 2d 374, 395 (D. Mass. 2010) (Tauro, J.), aff'd sub nom. Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2012). The Government thus attempts to bootstrap its program costs argument to its economic disruption argument, whi......
  • Pedersen v. Office of Pers. Mgmt.
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — District of Connecticut
    • July 31, 2012
    ...its ramifying application throughout the U.S. Code, only one day of hearings was held on DOMA." Massachusetts v. United States Dep't of Health and Human Services, 682 F.3d 1, 13 (1st Cir. 2012). During this brief hearing, "Congress did not hear testimony from agency heads regarding how DOMA......
  • Bassett v. Snyder
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Eastern District of Michigan
    • June 28, 2013
    ...held that cost savings alone are insufficient to justify an otherwise discriminatory statute. Massachusetts v. United States Dep't of Health and Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1, 11, 14 (1st Cir.2012); Diaz, 656 F.3d at 1013–14. The plaintiffs have shown that the defendant's justifications for the ......
  • Kitchen v. Herbert
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — District of Utah
    • December 20, 2013
    ...controlling precedent and therefore precludes consideration of the issues in this lawsuit. See, e.g., Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1, 8 (1st Cir.2012) (holding that Baker “limit[s] the arguments to ones that do not presume to rest on a constitutional right ......
  • Request a trial to view additional results
1 firm's commentaries
  • November 2012 Employee Benefits Update - Select Compliance Deadlines And Reminders
    • United States
    • Mondaq United States
    • November 20, 2012
    ...COMMENT: The First Circuit Court of Appeals previously held DOMA unconstitutional in Gill et al. v. Office of Personnel Management, 682 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2012). Following these circuit court decisions, the Supreme Court may grant certiorari on these cases in order to consider the validity of......
4 books & journal articles
  • Marriage, Biology, and Federal Benefits
    • United States
    • Iowa Law Review No. 98-4, May 2013
    • May 1, 2013
    ...couple through ovum sharing). 16. Hernandez , 855 N.E.2d at 7. 17. See, e.g. , Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep’t of Health & Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1, 12 (1st Cir. 2012) (“Congress has never purported to lay down a general code defining marriage or purporting to bind the states to such a regime.”......
  • Equal Protection
    • United States
    • Georgetown Journal of Gender and the Law No. XXIII-2, January 2022
    • January 1, 2022
    ...Off‌ice of Pers. Mgmt., 699 F. Supp. 2d 374, 397 (D. Mass 2010), aff’d sub nom. , Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep’t of Health & Human Services, 682 F.3d 1, 15–16 (1st Cir. 2012), cert. denied ; Golinski v. U.S. Off‌ice of Pers. Mgmt., 824 F. Supp. 2d 968, 995 (N.D. Cal. 2012), appeal dismissed (h......
    • United States
    • Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy Vol. 45 No. 1, January 2022
    • January 1, 2022
    ...threshold inquiry into whether consulting the commentary was warranted). (105.) Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health & Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1, 15-16 (1st Cir. 2012); United States v. Johnson, 921 F.3d 991, 1001 (11th Cir. 2019) (en banc). But see Richard Re, Narrowing Supreme Court P......
  • The evolution toward judicial independence in the continuing quest for LGBT equality.
    • United States
    • Case Western Reserve Law Review Vol. 64 No. 3, March - March 2014
    • March 22, 2014
    ...federal constitutional privacy rights of gay men and lesbians). (253.) See, e.g., Massachusetts v. U.S. Dep't of Health and Human Servs., 682 F.3d 1, 8 (1st Cir. 2012) (concluding that "Baker does not resolve our own case but it does limit the arguments to ones that do not presume or rest o......

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT