Matthews v. Automated Bus. Sys. & Serv.
| Court | D.C. Court of Appeals |
| Writing for the Court | Terry |
| Citation | Matthews v. Automated Bus. Sys. & Serv., 558 A.2d 1175 (D.C. 1989) |
| Decision Date | 24 May 1989 |
| Docket Number | No. 87-529.,87-529. |
| Parties | Cheryl MATTHEWS, Appellant, v. AUTOMATED BUSINESS SYSTEMS & SERVICES, INC., et al., Appellees. |
Ralph J. Temple, Washington, D.C., for appellant.
Kevin P. Chavous, Fairfax, Va., for appellees.
Before BELSON and TERRY, Associate Judges, and REILLY, Senior Judge.
Appellant Matthews filed a four-count complaint in the Superior Court against appellees Automated Business Systems & Services, Inc. (ABSS), and its president and chief executive officer, Theodore Howard, alleging unlawful employment discrimination in violation of the District of Columbia Human Rights Act,1 breach of contract, wrongful discharge, and interference with contractual relations. The trial court, on appellees' motion, dismissed one count of the complaint for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction2 and the other three counts on the ground of forum non conveniens.3 Appellant contends on this appeal that the factual findings on which the court based its dismissal were erroneous. Because the record fails to support the trial court's dismissal of the first count, we reverse that missal and remand this case for further proceedings. We also vacate the dismissals of the three remaining counts and direct the court on remand to reconsider the forum non conveniens issue in light of our ruling on subject-matter jurisdiction.
Cheryl Matthews was employed as an account manager by ABSS from February 22, 1983, until she was fired by Mr. Howard on October 4, 1985. ABSS, a District of Columbia corporation with its principal place of business in Riverdale, Maryland, provides automated data processing services to various governmental and private entities, including agencies of the federal government within the District of Columbia. Matthews' duties were to sell computer hardware, software, and services to ABSS customers. She was dismissed when she refused to sign a new proposed contract for fiscal 1986.
The first count of Matthews' complaint alleged that appellees had engaged in unlawful discrimination based on her age and sex in violation of the Human Rights Act. She claimed that her male counterparts received higher salaries and expense allowances than she did, even though she had a longer tenure at the firm. When she complained to Mr. Howard, she was allegedly told that she received a lower salary because she was younger than her colleagues and that, "as a female, she should `work smart', and not just `hard', referring to factors unrelated to her work for ABSS." Matthews based her breach of contract claim on ABSS' refusal to pay certain commissions and bonuses which she said were owed to her for her past sales performance. She also asserted that her discharge was wrongful because the new contract she was asked to sign violated the terms of her current contract and retroactively changed her sales quota and sales record. Finally, she maintained that Mr. Howard's discriminatory and unfair actions constituted an interference with her contractual relations with ABSS.
Appellees responded with a motion to dismiss based on, inter alia, lack of subject-matter jurisdiction and forum non conveniens. In support of the motion, appellees filed three affidavits, two by Mr. Howard and one by Elizabeth Simpson, Vice President of Administration at ABSS. These affidavits stated that the substantial part of ABSS' business was in Maryland and that its activities in the District of Columbia were limited. The affidavits also said that all of Matthews' employment contracts were negotiated, executed, and substantially performed in Maryland and that Matthews was assigned to work in Maryland, where her supervisors, her personnel records, and her business phone were ail located. Finally, the Simpson affidavit stated that Matthews never performed any actual service work on the contracts for which she was responsible.
Matthews opposed the motion to dismiss and filed an affidavit of her own. In it she acknowledged that ABSS had its main office in Maryland but asserted that it was, and publicly held itself out to be, a District of Columbia corporation. Matthews stated that ABSS did indeed perform a substantial amount of business in the District, particularly installing on-site computer services for agencies of the federal government.4 She estimated that between forty and sixty percent of her work was performed in the District of Columbia. Finally, Matthews said that the terms of her employment were substantially negotiated within the District and that some of the acts of alleged discrimination occurred in the District.
The trial court granted appellees' motion to dismiss the complaint. As to the first count, the court held that because Matthews' "actual place of employment was at all times in Maryland," there was not a sufficient nexus between Matthews and the District of Columbia to permit the court to entertain an action under the Human Rights Act. The court then dismissed the remaining three counts on the ground of forum non conveniens after balancing the private and public interests involved. In ruling that Matthews' minimal private interests were "heavily outweighed" by the District's public interest in not clogging its court calendars without good reason, the court reiterated that Matthews' "actual place of employment was at all times in Maryland."
Matthews contends that the trial court erred in finding that she was employed "at all times" in Maryland solely on the basis of the Howard and Simpson affidavits. She claims that the facts set forth in her affidavit — that she performed a substantial amount of her employment in the District of Columbia, that she negotiated terms of her employment in the District, and that certain acts of employment discrimination took place in the District — should have been accepted as true by the trial court. We reject this argument because it fails to recognize the difference between Rule 12(b)(1) and Rule 12(b)(6): the trial court, in considering a motion under Rule 12(b)(1), was not required to assume the truthfulness of Matthews' affidavit. For a different reason, however, we hold that the trial court erred in dismissing the first count of the complaint for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, and thus we reverse that dismissal and remand the case for further proceedings.
Though appellees sought to dismiss Matthews' complaint both for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, Super.Ct.Civ.R. 12(b)(1), and for failure to state a claim upon which relief could be granted, Super.Ct.Civ.R 120(b)(6), the court dismissed the first count on only the former ground. These two subsections of Rule 12 differ in several respects, the most significant being that a court may review and weigh evidence only upon a Rule 12(b)(1) motion. See Haase v. Sessions, 266 U.S.App.D.C. 325, 328-329, 835 F.2d 902, 905-906 (1987); Wilderness Society v. Griles, 262 U.S.App.D.C. 277, 289-290 n. 10, 824 F.2d 4, 16-17 n. 10 (1987);5 2A J. MOORE & J. LUCAS, MOORE'S FEDERAL PRACTICE ¶ 12.07 [2.-1], at 12-45 to 12-46 (2d ed. 1987) ("MOORE'S FEDERAL PRACTICE"); 10 C. WRIGHT, A. MILLER, & M. KANE, FEDERAL PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE § 2713, at 612-613 (2d ed. 1983) ("WRIGHT & MILLER").6
When a court is presented with affidavits submitted by the parties on a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, the motion is converted to one for summary judgment, and the court looks to the affidavits to see whether there are any issues of material fact that require a trial. Super.Ct.Civ.R. 12(b), last sentence; see International Underwriters, Inc. v. Boyle, 365 A.2d 779, 782 (D.C.1976); Doolin v. Environmental Power, Ltd., 360 A.2d 493, 496 n. 5 (D.C.1976). In so doing, the court views the evidence in the light most favorable to the party opposing the motion. E.g., Williams v. Gerstenfeld, 514 A.2d 1172, 1176 (D.C.1986).
The submission of affidavits, however, does not convert a Rule 12(b)(1) motion to one for summary judgment. Haase v. Sessions, supra, 266 U.S.App.D. C. at 328-329, 835 F.2d at 905-906; 2A MOORE'S FEDERAL PRACTICE, supra, ¶ 12.07 [2.-1], at 12-48; 10 WRIGHT & MILLER, supra, § 2713, at 608-611 (citing cases). Rather, the court may conduct an independent review of the evidence submitted by the parties, including affidavits, to resolve factual disputes concerning whether subject-matter jurisdiction exists. See Land v. Dollar, 330 U.S. 731, 735 n. 4, 67 S.Ct. 1009, 1011 n. 4, 91 L.Ed. 1209 (1947); Wilderness Society v. Griles, supra, 262 U.S. App.D.C. at 289 n. 10, 824 F.2d at 16 n. 10; Williamson v. Tucker, 645 F.2d 404, 413 (5th Cir.), cert. denied, 454 U.S. 897, 102 S.Ct. 396, 70 L.Ed.2d 212 (1981). Therefore, because the court dismissed Matthews' action on a Rule 12(b)(1) motion, it was not obliged to accept any of her allegations as true but was free to decide for itself whether it had jurisdiction based on the evidence presented by the parties. See Timberlane Lumber Co. v. Bank of America, 574 F.Supp. 1453, 1461 (N.D.Cal.1983), aff'd, 749 F.2d 1378 (9th Cir.1984), cert. denied, 472 U.S. 1032, 105 S.Ct. 3514, 87 L.Ed.2d 643 (1985).7
Matthews' contention that the court could not simply credit the affidavits submitted by appellees when her own affidavit established essential jurisdictional facts raises a different issue. Generally, the determination of jurisdictional facts is a matter for the court, not a jury, see Williamson, supra, 645 F.2d at 413, and the court has broad discretion in determining how to proceed in finding such facts, including basing its decision on affidavits. See Prakash v. American University, 234 U.S. App.D.C. 75, 80-81, 727 F.2d 1174, 1179-1180 (1984). In some cases, however, a court may be required to provide a plaintiff with a hearing on the issue of jurisdiction, especially if the evidence presented in the affidavits is not sufficient, or if "the facts are complicated and testimony would be helpful."...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Aguehounde v. District of Columbia
...instead, the court may consider all evidence coming to its attention bearing on that issue. See, e.g., Matthews v. Automated Bus. Sys. & Serv., 558 A.2d 1175, 1179-80 (D.C.1989) ("the court has broad discretion in determining how to proceed in finding such jurisdictional facts, including ba......
-
Brin v. S.E.W. Investors, No. 02-CV-649.
...one of "jurisdiction," the trial court would have quite properly resolved disputed questions of fact. See Matthews v. Automated Bus. Sys. & Servs., Inc., 558 A.2d 1175, 1179 (D.C.1989). With its mind set of ruling on a question of "jurisdiction," it is not entirely clear to us that the tria......
-
Bpa Intern., Inc. v. Kingdom of Sweden
...jurisdiction exists. See Land v. Dollar, 330 U.S. 731, 735 n. 4, 67 S.Ct. 1009, 91 L.Ed. 1209 (1947); Matthews v. Automated Bus. Sys. & Services, 558 A.2d 1175, 1179 (D.C.1989). In addition, a party may assert lack of personal jurisdiction under FED. R. CIV. P. 12(b)(2) and insufficiency of......
-
BIBLE WAY CHURCH v. BEARDS
...fails to survive the "facial" attack from Bible Way's motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(1). See supra note 4 (discussing Matthews, 558 A.2d at 1179 n. 7). We recognize that liberal rules of pleading normally protect a plaintiff against dismissal of an ambiguous complaint when it can be sai......