McClay v. Philadelphia
| Decision Date | 22 March 1909 |
| Docket Number | 183 |
| Citation | 224 Pa. 174,73 A. 188 |
| Parties | McClay v. Philadelphia, Appellant |
| Court | Pennsylvania Supreme Court |
Argued: January 18, 1909
Appeal, No. 183, Jan. T., 1908, by defendant, from judgment of C.P. No. 1, Phila. Co., March T., 1906, No. 1,176, on verdict for plaintiff in case of Annie McClay v. Philadelphia. Affirmed.
Trespass to recover damages for death of plaintiff's husband.
The facts are stated in the opinion of the Supreme Court.
Verdict and judgment for plaintiff for $4,000. Defendant appealed.
Error assigned was in refusing binding instructions for defendant.
The judgment is affirmed.
Thomas D. Finletter, assistant city solicitor, with him Harry T. Kingston, assistant city solicitor, and J. Howard Gendell, city solicitor, for appellant.
Thomas F. Gain, with him Alfred Law Cameron, for appellee.
Before MITCHELL, C.J., FELL, BROWN, MESTREZAT, POTTER, ELKIN and STEWART, JJ.
The only question argued was that of contributory negligence. The plaintiff's husband was riding on an elevated seat on an open wagon on a wide thoroughfare crowded with heavy teams, on which there were three tracks of a steam railroad. While crossing the tracks he turned his horses to one side to avoid a team crossing in front of him. One of the wheels of his wagon slid on a rail and went into a narrow depression or hole at its side, causing a jolt that threw him from his seat. Whether under the circumstances he should have seen and avoided the danger caused by the defect in the surface of the street was a question for the jury.
While the duty of vigilance is obligatory on everyone in the use of city streets, a driver who is unable to give undivided attention to the roadbed, because of the care required in managing his horses and in avoiding other vehicles, cannot be held to have seen, or to have been reckless in not seeing, defects in a roadbed that would have been obvious to a pedestrian.
The judgment is affirmed.
To continue reading
Request your trial