Meagher v. Minnesota Thresher Manuf Co

• Court: U.S. Supreme Court
• Writing for the Court: FULLER
• Citation: Meagher v. Minnesota Thresher Manuf Co, 145 U.S. 608, 12 S.Ct. 876, 36 L.Ed. 834 (1892)
• Decision Date: 16 May 1892
• Parties: MEAGHER et al. v. MINNESOTA THRESHER MANUF'G CO

145 U.S. 608

12 S.Ct. 876

36 L.Ed. 834

MEAGHER et al. v. MINNESOTA THRESHER MANUF'G CO.

May 16, 1892.

C. K. Davis and Frank W. M. Cutcheon, for the motion.

Horace G. Stone, opposed.

Mr. Chief Justice FULLER delivered the opinion of the court.

One McKusick recovered judgment in the district court of Washington county, Minn., against the corporation of Seymour, Sabin & Co., and in aid of execution brought an action praying for a sequestration of the stock, property, things in action, and effects of the corporation, and the appointment of a receiver to take charge thereof and carry on its business until sale or other disposition. A receiver was accordingly appointed, qualified, and entered upon the administration of the company's affairs and effects. An order was entered by the court requiring the creditors of the corporation to exhibit their claims in the action, which was done, among others, by the Minnesota Thresher Manufacturing Company, to a very large amount. Subsequently the latter company filed an intervening petition or complaint in the general winding-up action, setting forth the names of some 60 shareholders of the Seymour-Sabin corporation, and the amounts of their holdings of stock, and praying that the court make those named, and all other persons who might subsequently be found to be shareholders, parties to the action, require them to answer the petition, and enforce the liability in respect of stock held by them which the petition claimed the constitution of the state imposed. It was also prayed that the court determine the amount of the assets of the Seymour-Sabin Company available for the satisfaction of the claims of creditors; the amount of its indebtedness; the number of shares of its capital outstanding between July 5, 1881, and May 10, 1884, during which time the indebtedness represented by the claims filed was incurred; the names of the various holders of stock between those dates; what shareholders were insolvent; what nonresident; what persons were entitled to share in the assets, and to what extent; and the amount of any other indebtedness on the part of any of the defendants to the Seymour-Sabin Company.

The district court made an order impleading the parties named as defendants in the action, and requiring them to enter their appearance and answer within a time limited. Among the numerous persons thus made defendants the plaintiffs in error in this case were included, and they demurred to the intervening petition or supplemental complaint upon the ground, among others, that the facts stated were not sufficient to constitute a cause of action. The petition charged that defendants were liable upon their stock to the extent of a sum equal to the par value thereof for the debts of the Seymour-Sabin corporation under section 3, art. 10, of the constitution of Minnesota, which provided: 'Each stockholder in any corporation (excepting those organized for the purpose of carrying on any kind of manufacturing or mechanical business) shall be liable to the amount of stock held or owned by him.'

The demurring defendants contended that this was a mere direction to the legislature of the state to impose such a liability, and was not self-executing.

The demurrers of plaintiffs in error and of...