Monier v. Gallen
| Decision Date | 21 May 1982 |
| Docket Number | No. 82-208,82-208 |
| Citation | 122 N.H. 474,446 A.2d 454 |
| Parties | Robert B. MONIER, President New Hampshire Senate v. Hugh J. GALLEN, Governor et al. |
| Court | New Hampshire Supreme Court |
Richard A. Hampe, Concord, on the brief and orally, for plaintiff.
Gregory H. Smith, Atty. Gen. (Deborah J. Cooper, Deputy Atty. Gen., and Ronald F. Rodgers, Concord, Attorney, on the brief, and Deborah J. Cooper, orally), for the defendants.
Winograd Professional Association, Concord (I. Michael Winograd, Concord, on the brief and orally), for Richard E. Boyer, intervenor.
This action is a petition requesting that this court exercise its original jurisdiction to resolve an apparent impasse that has developed with respect to the redistricting of the New Hampshire Senate and to ensure a timely and orderly electoral process with respect to the 1982 senatorial elections. The petition requests the court to declare that the present senatorial districts violate the Constitution of New Hampshire and the Constitution of the United States and that the 1982 senatorial elections should be conducted pursuant to the redistricting plan which was adopted by both houses of the General Court but vetoed by the Governor (Senate Bill 1). In the alternative, we are requested to authorize the 1982 senatorial elections to be conducted pursuant to the existing districts notwithstanding their disparity in population.
Pursuant to New Hampshire Constitution, part II, article 26, Senate Bill 1, an act reapportioning the State senatorial districts, was introduced in the senate on April 10, 1981. It passed the senate on May 7, 1981, and was introduced in the house of representatives on May 18, 1981, where it died in committee on June 30, 1981, pursuant to Joint Rule 24. Senate Bill 1, an act reapportioning the State senatorial districts, was introduced November 17, 1981 and passed the senate, after amendment, on February 10, 1982. It was introduced in the house of representatives on February 15, 1982, passed the house of representatives on April 13, 1982, and was then vetoed by the Governor on April 20, 1982. An attempt to override the Governor's veto failed on May 13, 1982.
The filing period for State offices opens on June 2, 1982, with a State primary scheduled for September 14, 1982. A general election is scheduled for November 1982.
The 1980 federal census establishes the population of the State of New Hampshire at 920,610 which would establish the ideal population for each of the twenty-four senatorial districts at 38,359. The present State senatorial districts vary in population from a high of 50,701 in District 9 to a low of 29,360 in District 1, which is a total deviation of 55.7 percent.
The senatorial districts proposed in Senate Bill 1 vary in population from a high of 39,860 in District 14 to a low of 36,930 in District 20, which is a total deviation of 7.6 percent.
The defendants argue that this matter should not be before the court because it is beyond the scope of our jurisdiction. See RSA 490:4 (Supp.1979). On the other hand, our fundamental charter states that the "judicial power of the state shall be vested in the supreme court...." N.H.Const. pt. II, art. 72-a; see also id. pt. II, art. 74. This controversy arises under our Constitution. As we observed in an earlier dispute between a speaker of the house and a Governor:
...
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Terrazas v. Ramirez
...jurisdiction retained in 258 Iowa 1121, 142 N.W.2d 355, cert. denied, 385 U.S. 851, 87 S.Ct. 79, 17 L.Ed.2d 80 (1966); Monier v. Gallen, 122 N.H. 474, 446 A.2d 454 (1982); Butcher v. Bloom, 420 Pa. 305, 216 A.2d 457 (1966), pursuant to jurisdiction retained in 415 Pa. 438, 203 A.2d 556 (196......
-
In re Below
...in doing so it fulfilled its constitutional obligation to enact a redistricting plan based upon the 2000 census. See Monier v. Gallen, 122 N.H. 474, 476, 446 A.2d 454 (1982).The petitioners assert that the new districts created by HB 1292 and HB 264 violate the Federal and State Constitutio......
-
Burling v. Chandler
...plan consistent with constitutional requisites before the 2002 elections, the court accepted jurisdiction. See Monier v. Gallen, 122 N.H. 474, 476, 446 A.2d 454 (1982). Because the senate and house recessed on May 22, 2002, without enacting a house reapportionment plan, the court determined......
-
Below v. Gardner
...plan consistent with constitutional requisites before the 2002 senate election, we accepted jurisdiction. See Monier v. Gallen, 122 N.H. 474, 476, 446 A.2d 454 (1982). On May 22, 2002, the senate and the house recessed without enacting a valid senate redistricting plan. On May 23, 2002, the......