Moore v. First National Bank of Abilene, 21313.

• Decision Date: 21 May 1965
• Docket Number: No. 21313.,21313.
• Citation: 345 F.2d 638
• Parties: Harry MOORE, Trustee of the Estate of Billie Sol Estes, Bankrupt, Appellant, v. FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF ABILENE, Appellee.
• Court: U.S. Court of Appeals — Fifth Circuit

345 F.2d 638 (1965)

Harry MOORE, Trustee of the Estate of Billie Sol Estes, Bankrupt, Appellant, v. FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF ABILENE, Appellee.

No. 21313.

United States Court of Appeals Fifth Circuit.

May 21, 1965.

Allan L. Poage, El Paso, Tex., for appellant.

Stanley P. Wilson, McMahon, Smart, Sprain, Wilson & Camp, Abilene, Tex., for appellee.

Before GEWIN and BELL, Circuit Judges, and McRAE, District Judge.

McRAE, District Judge.

On May 14, 1957, Billie Sol Estes (Estes) executed and delivered his promissory note for $16,000.00 to the First National Bank of Pecos which transferred the note to the First National Bank of Abilene (Abilene). The note was due October 27, 1957, and the security for this note was the execution and delivery of a separate Collateral Agreement.¹ Thereafter, Estes renewed this indebtedness from time to time by the execution of renewal notes, the last of which was given on November 21, 1961, in the amount of $3,000.00.

On March 30, 1961, Abilene obtained from First National Bank of Pecos two promissory notes signed by one Marcus Dingler and dated March 21, 1961. These notes were secured by chattel mortgages on certain irrigation equipment and by the endorsement of Estes, individually.

On April 7, 1962, Estes filed his petition for an arrangement proceeding in bankruptcy in the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas, and on May 3, 1962, that Court entered its Amended General Stay Order, ordering that "all acts and proceedings to enforce any lien upon any property of Billie Sol Estes, or entity in which he has an interest, are enjoined and stayed until further order of this Court." The creditors refused the arrangement proposed by Estes, and he was adjudicated a bankrupt by the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas on July 13, 1962. Appellant Harry Moore (Moore) was appointed Trustee of the Estes Estate.

In August 1962, Abilene foreclosed on the chattel mortgage securing the Dingler notes. After applying the proceeds of this foreclosure sale, there remained a deficit of $15,298.62 owing to Abilene on the Dingler notes. During August and October of 1962, Abilene sold certain of the stocks which had been delivered to it by Estes under the Collateral Agreement for a net amount of $18,750.42. Abilene applied $3,145.50 of this as full payment of principal and interest on the Estes note. Of the $15,604.92 remaining, Abilene applied $1,183.87 as interest due and $14,421.05 as payment of principal on the Dingler notes.

Abilene has not taken part in any of the bankruptcy proceedings, and although the amount realized from the sale of the property held under the Collateral Agreement was not sufficient to satisfy the debt owing to it, Abilene expressly waived any claim against the Estes Estate for the deficiency.

In April 1963, Moore brought this action in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, praying for the return of the funds derived from the sale of the stocks which Abilene had applied to the Dingler notes. After hearing, the District Judge entered an order denying Moore's Motion for Summary Judgment, and granting Abilene's Motion for Summary Judgment. Moore brings this appeal from the Summary Judgment entered for Abilene.

Two questions are presented on this appeal. First, the substantive question of whether the broad language of the Collateral Agreement was properly interpreted to include...