Morris v. Stuyvesant Fire Ins. Co
| Decision Date | 30 June 1919 |
| Docket Number | 22235 |
| Citation | 145 La. 471,82 So. 586 |
| Court | Louisiana Supreme Court |
| Parties | MORRIS v. STUYVESANT FIRE INS. CO |
John D. Nix, Jr., of New Orleans, for appellant.
Howe Fenner, Spencer & Cocke, of New Orleans, for appellee.
O'NIELL, J.
Plaintiff appeals from a judgment rejecting his demand for $ 3,400 on two policies of insurance on a stock of merchandise and his store fixtures that were destroyed by fire.
The defenses are: First, that plaintiff violated the iron-safe clause in his policies; and, second, that he intentionally misrepresented and grossly exaggerated the value of the stock of merchandise that he had had on hand at the time of the fire.
The iron-safe clause required that the assured should make a complete itemized inventory of his stock on hand at least once in each calendar year, and that such an inventory should be made in detail within 30 days after issuance of the policy unless one was made within 12 months prior to the date of the policy. It required also that the assured should keep a set of books containing a complete record of the business transacted, including all purchases, sales, and shipments. The promises made in the iron-safe clause were declared a warranty; and it was stipulated that a failure to produce the inventories and set of books for the inspection of the insurance company would render the policy null and void and be a perpetual bar to a recovery thereon.
When the insurance adjuster asked plaintiff for his books and inventories after the fire, he produced only an inventory dated several months after the policies were issued and a book showing the amount of his daily sales from the date of the inventory to the date of the fire. When the suit had been put at issue, plaintiff's brother testified, under commission, that an inventory had been made within the 12 months prior to the date of the policies, and that he, the brother, had kept books for plaintiff from the time he began business to a date about six months before the fire. The inventory said to have been made within the 12 months prior to the date of the policies was not produced, nor was its absence accounted for. A journal and a ledger, said to have been kept by plaintiff's brother, showing the transactions to a date 6 months before the fire, were produced on the trial and filed in evidence. Plaintiff testified that he found them at his home in New Orleans, had his wife had brought them some time...
To continue reading
Request your trial