Mount v. Baptist Hospital of Gadsden, Inc.

Decision Date17 February 1966
Docket Number7 Div. 826
Citation43 Ala.App. 423,191 So.2d 262
PartiesIrene MOUNT v. BAPTIST HOSPITAL OF GADSDEN, INC. . Oct, 18, 1966. Robt. E. Lewis, Gadsden, for appellant. Buford L. Copeland, Gadsden, for appellee. CATES, Judge. This appeal was
CourtAlabama Court of Appeals

Buford L. Copeland, Gadsden, for appellee.

CATES, Judge.

This appeal was submitted February 17, 1966, on written argument.

Mrs. Mount appeals from a judgment for defendant-appellee. She had sued the hospital for $44.25 on account or alternatively for money received by it to her use.

Being for less than $50.00, the originating complaint was filed in the County Court of Etowah County. The hospital appealed from a judgment there for the suit amount. Thus came trial de novo in the circuit court.

I.

The case was submitted without the intervention of a jury Hon. A. B. Cunningham on the following agreed statement of facts:

'Mrs. Irene Mount, wife of Guy Mount, entered the Baptist Memorial Hospital for minor surgery on December 8, 1962. Upon arrival at the hospital she went to a patient room while Mr. Mount went to the office to complete the necessary arrangements for her admittance as a patient.

'Mrs. Mount gave to her husband $100.00 to use in arranging her admission to the hospital. At the time of her admission Mr. Mount delivered to the hospital office attendent the said $100.00 as a deposit 'At the time Mr. Mount delivered the aforesaid $100.00 to the hospital, which was accredited to Mrs. Irene Mount, Mr. Guy Mount was indebted to the hospital on a previous obligation.

for the admission of Mrs. Mount to the hospital. Said amount was accredited properly as an advance admission charge for the hospitalization of Mrs. Irene Mount.

'The hospital charges for the confinement of Mrs. Irene Mount were $55.75. The hospital applied this amount to the confinement of Mrs. Irene Mount, and applied the remaining amount of the aforesaid $100.00 deposit in the amount of $44.25 in reduction of the aforesaid obligation of Guy Mount, which was in existence at the time he made the $100.00 deposit on behalf of Mrs. Irene Mount. 'The money claimed in this lawsuit for Mrs. Irene Mount is the $44.25, which was credited to the obligation of Guy Mount, husband of Mrs. Irene Mount. 'A letter from Baptist Memorial Hospital to Mr. Guy Mount, Re: Mrs. Irene Mount's hospital account, with statement of account attached, is hereby attached and made a part hereof.

'Oct. 2, 1964

Buford Copeland

Atty for Deft Bap. Hosp.

Robert E. Lewis

Attorney for Irene Mount

'BAPTIST MEMORIAL HOSPITAL

1136 Sixth Avenue Gadsden, Alabama

December 14, 1961

'J. Cecil Hamiter

Administrator

Phone

Liberty 6--5211

'Mr. Guy Mount

5 North 28th Street

ACS/Gadsden, Alabama

RE: Mrs. Irene Mount Code #5, 6745

'Dear Mr. Mount:

'We are writing this letter in regard to the refund balance on your account for Mrs. Irene Mount dates 12/8/61 to 12/9/61. In checking our records we find that you still have an outstanding balance on an account for your mother who was a patient in the hospital 4/19/58 to 5/4/58. When she was discharged from the hospital you signed a note assuming responsibility for the account. To this date payment has not been received on this account.

'We are enclosing a copy of your wife's hospital account showing the amount that was applied to the past-due account.

'Thanking you in advance for your cooperation.

Sincerely yours,

BAPTIST MEMORIAL HOSPITAL

L. C. Jolley

L. C. Jolley

Office Manager

'LCJ/bjb'

(There follows a ledger sheet type of statement showing Mrs. Mount as the patient, employed as a housewife then Mr. Mount as 'employee or subscriber' noted as 'Husband Unemployed' followed by Dec. 8, 1961, as Mrs. Mount's date of admission with her hospital discharge given as the next day. Thereafter appear the items which amount to $55.75 with a final credit on the ledger to this account of $44.25.)

II.

Appellant relies on the Married Woman's Property Act. Code 1940, T. 34, § 65. 1

One seldom sets up another as his agent sub silentio. Indeed, Code 1940, T. 9, § 74, allows a third party to treat an undisclosed agent as a principal. This section 2 reads:

' § 74. One who deals with an agent without knowing or having reason to believe that the agent acts as such in the transaction, may set off against any claim of the principal arising out of the same, all claims which he might have set off against the agent before notice of the agency.'

3 Am.Jur.2d, Agency, § 325, states in part:

'* * * where a third person contracts with an undisclosed agent who has not given notice to such third person of his agency, he may set off a debt or claim due to him from such agent personally in an action on the contract by the principal.'--citing Gardner v. Allen's Ex'r, 6 Ala. 187.

Relationship creates no...

To continue reading

Request your trial
8 cases
  • Emanuel v. McGriff
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • January 17, 1992
    ...medical and hospital treatment for her cure and comfort comporting with his station in life." Mount v. Baptist Hospital of Gadsden, Inc., 43 Ala.App. 423, 191 So.2d 262, 264 (1966). The executrix contends that, because Huntsville Hospital and Dr. McGriff failed to file their claims against ......
  • Memorial Hospital v. Hahaj
    • United States
    • Indiana Appellate Court
    • January 28, 1982
    ...a husband is liable for his wife's "necessaries," including her medical expenses, has continued. See, e. g., Mount v. Baptist of Gadsen, Inc. (1966), 43 Ala.App. 423, 191 So.2d 262 (husband "prima facie" has duty to furnish wife necessaries including medical and hospital treatment); Memoria......
  • Ex parte Bunting Plastic Surgery Clinic, P.C.
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • August 20, 1993
    ..."medical and hospital treatment for her cure and comfort comporting with his station in life." Mount v. Baptist Hospital of Gadsden, Inc., 43 Ala.App. 423, 426, 191 So.2d 262, 264 (1966); see, also, Green v. First Nat'l Bank of Tuskaloosa, 49 Ala.App. 426, 272 So.2d 895 (1971), reversed on ......
  • Shipp v. First Alabama Bank of Gadsden, N.A.
    • United States
    • Alabama Supreme Court
    • May 31, 1985
    ...he signs. Cf. Phenix Girard Bank v. Cannon, 414 So.2d 926 (Ala.1982); Code of 1975, § 7-3-403; and Mount v. Baptist Hospital of Gadsden, Inc., 43 Ala.App. 423, 191 So.2d 262 (1966). Let the judgment be AFFIRMED. TORBERT, C.J., and MADDOX, JONES and SHORES, JJ., concur. ...
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT