Mumford v. Hall

CourtMinnesota Supreme Court
Writing for the CourtBerry, J.
CitationMumford v. Hall, 25 Minn. 347 (Minn. 1879)
Decision Date10 January 1879
PartiesJohn P. Mumford, Petitioner, v. Mary L. Hall, Executrix, and another

[Syllabus Material] [Syllabus Material] [Syllabus Material] [Syllabus Material]

On April 17, 1877, John P. Mumford filed a petition in the probate court of Ramsey county, stating that he was a creditor of the estate of John M. Hall, of New York, deceased, whose will was proved in that court, on June 11, 1861, in which will the testator named Mary L. Hall executrix, and John J. Cole executor thereof, and constituted the former his residuary legatee; that the executrix and executor have never given the bond required by statute, nor so complied with the law as to entitle them to act as such, or to receive letters testamentary, and that Mary L. Hall has never executed any bond to authorize her to take possession of the assets of the testator as residuary legatee; that notwithstanding such omission to give bond, the probate court, on June 19, 1861, improvidently issued to them letters testamentary, and since that time they have wrongfully and unlawfully intermeddled with the estate, and Mary L. Hall has assumed the ownership of all the assets of the deceased, and has been selling and disposing of them as if she were legally authorized so to do; that neither of them, as executor and executrix, nor Mary L. Hall, as residuary legatee, has ever offered to pay the petitioner's claim, which amounts to $ 1,500, and has long been due; that they have never filed any inventory, nor caused notice to be given to creditors to present their claims, nor have commissioners to pass upon claims against the estate ever been appointed; nor have any steps whatever been taken toward settling the estate; and that neither the executrix nor the executor has ever resided in this state.

The prayer of the petition is that if the court shall be satisfied that the letters testamentary were improvidently and illegally issued, and that the persons named therein were never legally entitled, an order be made revoking and annulling such letters, and declaring them to be of no validity whatever; but if the court shall be satisfied that such letters were legally issued, and are valid, then that an order be made, removing such executrix and executor from their offices and trusts as such; and that some suitable person be appointed administrator with the will annexed.

A hearing having been had, the probate court made an order denying the prayer of the petition, but directing that the executrix and executor file an additional bond. From this order, the petitioner appealed to the district court, where the case was tried before Brill, J., without a jury, and the order of the probate court was reversed, the court holding that the bond given by the executrix and the executor to the probate court was void, and that the letters testamentary issued to them were on that account void. A new trial was refused, and the executrix and executor appealed.

The condition of the bond in question is as follows: "Whereas the said Mary L. Hall was nominated executrix, and John J. Cole executor, of the last will and testament of John Mortimer Hall, now deceased, and said will has been admitted to probate in the probate court of said county and state, and letters testamentary are about to be issued thereon to the persons so named, and whereas the said executrix is the residuary legatee and devisee, in said will: Now the condition of this obligation is such that if the said executrix and executor shall pay all the debts and legacies of the said testator, or such dividends thereon as shall be ordered and decreed by the probate court, out of the goods, chattels, rights, credits and estate of the testator, and render a true and just account of their administration when required, and perform all orders and decrees of the probate court by them to be performed, then this obligation to be void; otherwise, in full force." The district court found that this was the only bond filed. The letters testamentary contain a recital among other things of the granting of probate of the will to the executrix and executor therein named, "and Mary L. Hall and John J. Cole having complied with the provisions of the statute in such case made and provided." The statutory provisions on this subject, in force at the time of the issuing of the letters, will be found in the margin. [*]

Order of the district court refusing a new trial is accordingly reversed, and such court directed to enter an order affirming the order of the probate court.

John J. Cole, for appellants, argued that the granting of the letters and admitting the will to probate was a judgment or adjudication; (Penniman's Will, 20 Minn. 245; Porter v. Purdy, 29 N.Y. 110;) and not reviewable by the same court, after a lapse of 15 years; Freeman on Judgments, §§ 96, 101; AEtna Ins. Co. v. McCormick, 20 Wis. 265; U. S. Bank v. Moss, 6 How. 31; Cameron v. McRoberts, 3 Wheat. 591; Brush v. Robbins, 3 McLean 486; Grant v. Schmidt, 22 Minn. 1; State v. Probate Court of Ramsey Co., 18 Minn. 117; Wood v. Myrick, 16 Minn. 495; Parcher v. Bussell, 11 Cush. 107; Parker v. Parker, 11 Cush. 519; that when the letters recite the giving of a bond, it is an adjudication, and cannot afterwards be questioned; Grignon v. Astor, 2 How. 340; that letters testamentary, granted by a court having jurisdiction, are not revocable for error in granting them; Griffith v. Frazier, 8 Cranch 9; that, the jurisdiction to grant the letters appearing, the same presumption obtains that it was rightly exercised which prevails with reference to superior courts; Florentine v. Barton, 2 Wall. 216; Comstock v. Crawford, 3 Wall. 396: that the recital in the letters, "and said Mary L. Hall and John J. Cole having complied with the provisions of the statutes in such case made and provided," is conclusive as to the validity of the bond; 3 Redf. on Wills, 56; Baldwin v. Standish, 7 Cush. 207; that executors derive their authority from the will, and not solely from the letters; Hartnett v. Wandell, 60 N.Y. 346; 1 Wms. on Exrs. 239; that the granting of letters was an immediate and necessary consequence of admitting the will to probate, and was therefore part of the same adjudication, with the condition of giving security; and the security being accepted, the adjudication was complete; the defect, if any, in the bond is cured by the granting of letters, unless the granting is appealed from. Bloom v. Burdick, 1 Hill 134.

A. R. Capehart, for respondent.

From an order appointing an executor, an appeal might be taken. On such appeal, if letters have been issued, the decision of the appeal determines whether they should be revoked. But if the appeal is taken before letters issue, the decision affects only the correctness of the order, and the power of the court to issue or withhold them. In the former case, the order may be erroneous, and the executor, having given the proper bond may have already received his letters. In the latter, the order may be correct, but the proper bond may not have been executed. An order appointing an executor, as the word "appoint" is used in the statute, involves a determination that the person so appointed is the same person named as executor, that he is legally competent and that he accepts the trust. Such an order is appealable. Yet such order may be in all respects correct, and yet, after it is made, the executor may fail to give a proper bond, and it would be illegal to issue letters to him. But if in such case the court should issue the letters, there would be no remedy by appealing from the order appointing the executor, for in that order there is no error; nor by appealing from the act of issuing and delivering the letters, for that is not an order, and is not appealable. The only remedy would be by petition to the court to undo its illegal act. If such act were a judgment or adjudication, it could not be reviewed after the statutory lapse of time; but if it be an erroneous ministerial act, it may be corrected at any time; and if contrary to the express provisions of a statute, it is null and void. Probate of the will was granted to this executrix and executor. The probate court judicially ascertained and determined the validity of the will, that they were the same persons named as such executor and executrix therein, that they were legally competent and willing to accept the trust. The adjudication on these points is conclusive, and cannot now be reviewed. But here the jurisdiction stops, until some action on the part of those interested in the estate shall again call it into exercise. The next step taken by the court involves a question not so much of jurisdiction as of power. Jurisdiction of a matter is one thing, and power to do certain acts therein is another. The probate court can allow the will, and grant an order appointing the executor, but it cannot issue and deliver to him letters testamentary, unless he complies with the condition precedent of the statute, by executing the bond prescribed by law. After general jurisdiction of a matter is acquired, further jurisdiction, in all courts, frequently depends on certain acts. Babcock v. Cobb, 11 Minn. 247 (347;) Montour v. Purdy, 11 Minn. 278 (384;) Blake v. Sherman, 12 Minn. 420; Wood v. Myrick, 16 Minn. 495; Dickinson's Appeal, 2 Mich. 337; Tappan v. Tappan, 4 Foster 400; 10 Foster 69; Heydock v. Duncan, 43 N.H. 45; Williamson v. Williamson, 3 Sm. & Marsh. 715; Re Fisher, 15 Wis. 567; Frederick v. Pacquette, 19 Wis. 569.

The language of the statute is peremptory. Unless complied with the court has no power to issue letters testamentary. It cannot issue them unless the bond in fact existed at the time; and while the recital in the letters might be sufficient in a collateral...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex

Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant

  • Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database

  • Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength

  • Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities

  • Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting

vLex
3 cases
  • Larson v. How
    • United States
    • Minnesota Supreme Court
    • January 21, 1898
    ... ... ground of insufficiency of evidence. State v. Probate ... Court, 19 Minn. 85 (117), and cases cited; Mumford ... v. Hall, 25 Minn. 347; Greenwood v. Murray, 26 ... Minn. 259; In re Mousseau, 30 Minn. 202; Graham ... v. Burch, 44 Minn. 33; Logenfiel v ... ...
  • Jacobson v. Anderson
    • United States
    • Minnesota Supreme Court
    • June 2, 1898
    ...This order was never appealed from nor reversed, and we are of the opinion that it stands conclusive between the parties. See Mumford v. Hall, 25 Minn. 347. It did, appear upon the trial of this action, by uncontradicted evidence, that Saugstad had, on February 20, 1896, paid to C. M. Benso......
  • Lehman v. Norton
    • United States
    • Minnesota Supreme Court
    • March 16, 1934
    ...original jurisdiction to issue letters, and, if the appointment is improper, remedy is by appeal from the order of appointment. Mumford v. Hall, 25 Minn. 347; Betcher v. Betcher, 83 Minn. 215, 86 N.W. 1; First T. & S. Bank v. U.S.F. & G. Co. 163 Minn. 168, 203 N.W. 612. Plaintiffs did not o......