Nat'l Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Scarlato
Decision Date | 24 July 2017 |
Docket Number | No. 1-16-1943.,1-16-1943. |
Citation | 83 N.E.3d 44,2017 IL App (1st) 161943 |
Parties | NATIONAL LIFE REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS, LLC, Plaintiff and Citation Petitioner–Appellant v. Ronald SCARLATO, Defendant, (International Bank of Chicago, Citation Respondent–Appellee). |
Court | United States Appellate Court of Illinois |
Donald A. Murday, David J. Novotny, and Stuart F. Primack, of Chittenden, Murday & Novotny LLC, of Chicago, for appellant.
Michael Lee Tinalgia, of Law Offices of Michael Lee Tinalgia, Ltd., of Park Ridge, for appellee.
¶ 1 Plaintiff, National Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC (National Life), appeals the trial court's ruling that denied its motion for entry of judgment against third-party citation respondent, International Bank of Chicago (IBC), arguing that the court's decision was improper where after being served with a citation, IBC violated the restraining provision of the citation by extending a loan to judgment debtor, Ronald S. Scarlato. National Life specifically asserts that the citation was violated when IBC advanced and disbursed proceeds of the loan to third-parties on behalf of Scarlato. IBC responds that the trial court was correct in denying the motion for entry of judgment because National Life has not and cannot establish that IBC ever held property "belonging to the judgment debtor or to which he or she may be entitled or which may thereafter be acquired by or become due to him or her." See 735 ILCS 5/2–1402(f)(1) (West 2012). We reverse the trial court's decision to deny National Life's motion for entry of judgment.
¶ 3 This case stems from an approximately $3.5 million judgment entered against Scarlato and the resulting supplementary proceeding in which National Life attempted to collect the judgment amount by serving IBC, a bank that conducted business with Scarlato, with a third-party citation to discover assets. Ultimately, National Life became aware that IBC had entered into a loan agreement with Scarlato after being served with the citation and moved to enter judgment against IBC as a result of its alleged violation of the citation, which prohibited the transfer of any property belonging to Scarlato.
¶ 4 Prior to entering into the $3.5 million "Construction Loan Agreement" (agreement) and promissory note (note) that form the basis of the dispute here, IBC held a $4 million note from Scarlato and two limited liability corporations for which he was the managing member, Bellwood Place, LLC (BP), and Scarlato Holdings Bellwood Place, LLC (SHBP), dated September 19, 2008 (September 2008 note), and a $2.6 million note from Scarlato, BP, and SHBP, dated October 19, 2012 (October 2012 note). Both of the notes contained a "right of setoff" provision that stated:
The September 2008 note and the October 2012 note were both secured by second and third position mortgages on the subject property, located at 110 North 25th Avenue in Melrose Park (property). These mortgages were granted as collateral to IBC by BP and SHBP, the two owners in fee simple of the property, with each having an undivided 50% ownership interest. The property is a parcel of land that measures over 19.4 acres and is improved with a mixed-use 543,044 square-foot building. The first floor of the building is commercial retail and the second floor is residential condominiums. As of August 1, 2013, IBC held a total debt of approximately $14 million relating to the property. Also as of that date, the construction on the property was only about halfway complete. An appraisal report dated February 13, 2013, valued the property, as is, at $12,015,000, with the completed property valued at $16.2 million.
¶ 5 In November 2012, National Life obtained a judgment in the amount of $3,424,228.97 against Scarlato, Division Street Place, LLC, and Scarlato Holdings Division St. LLC, jointly and severally. Thereafter, National Life began supplementary proceedings in an attempt to collect the judgment amount. On April 12, 2013, National Life issued a third-party citation to discover assets directed to IBC. The citation was served on IBC on April 13, 2013, and contained the following prohibitive provision:
IBC filed its initial response to the citation on May 7, 2013, and supplemented its response on two subsequent occasions.
¶ 6 On August 1, 2013, nearly four months after IBC was served with National Life's third-party citation to discover assets, Scarlato, BP, and SHBP applied for a $3.5 million loan from IBC and entered into the agreement. The agreement listed IBC as the lender, and Scarlato, BP, and SHBP as the borrowers. Scarlato executed and signed the Agreement three times and in three ways: individually, on behalf of himself, and in his capacity as the managing member of BP and SHBP. Scarlato also executed and signed the Note in conjunction with the agreement on August 1, 2013, by signing three times and in the same three ways.
¶ 7 On August 1, 2013, in addition to the agreement and note, Scarlato, BP, and SHBP entered into an assignment of construction contracts (assignment) that granted, transferred, and assigned to IBC all of the borrowers' present and future rights, title, and interest in and to the construction contract with CMG Construction Management Group, Inc., the general contractor. The assignment provided that IBC was not allowed to exercise any rights of Scarlato, BP, or SHBP unless and until a default occurred. Scarlato executed and signed the assignment three times and in three ways: individually, on behalf of himself, and in his capacity as the managing member of BP and SHBP.
¶ 9 On August 1, 2013, the borrowers requested a $3.5 million "advance" under the agreement and instructed IBC to disburse and pay all the loan proceeds to Greater Illinois Title, the construction escrow agent. Scarlato executed the disbursement request and authorization three times and in three ways: individually, on behalf of himself, and in his capacity as the managing member of BP and SHBP. From August 2013 to March 2014, IBC disbursed $3.5 million pursuant to the agreement but not all proceeds went to Greater Illinois Title. On August 23, 2013, IBC credited $1,510,000 of the $3.5 million loan to an IBC account designated with account No. 80063. Also on August 23, 2013, IBC issued the following loan cashier's checks from account No. 80063, payable from the proceeds of the $1,510,000 that was credited to the loan: $565,000, payable to BP, $675,000, payable to ID Investment Capital, LLC, and $270,000, payable to BP. Then, on November 18, 2013, IBC credited an additional $528,000 to the loan by placing the proceeds into account No. 80063 and issued a loan cashier's check in the amount of $528,000 payable to Greater Illinois Title, which was drawn from account No. 80063 and payable from the proceeds credited to the loan on that same date. Similarly, on March 26, 2014, IBC credited an additional $1,462,000 to the loan by placing the proceeds into account No. 80063 and issued a loan cashier's check in the amount of $1,462,000, payable to BP, drawn from account No. 80063 and payable from the proceeds credited to the loan on that same date....
To continue reading
Request your trial-
McGinley Partners, LLC v. Royalty Props., LLC
...The court further found that Squires Cannon also had entitlement to the funds under National Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Scarlato , 2017 IL App (1st) 161943, 415 Ill.Dec. 788, 83 N.E.3d 44. Consequently, the court found that, "[b]ecause [Squires] Cannon had entitlement to the funds, p......
-
Triumph Cmty. Bank v. Ired Elmhurst, LLC
...the appellants violated the citations is a matter of statutory interpretation, and our review is de novo. National Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Scarlato , 2017 IL App (1st) 161943, ¶ 20, 415 Ill.Dec. 788, 83 N.E.3d 44. Moreover, "[w]e review de novo a trial court's ruling in supplement......
-
Karim v. Bayview Loan Servicing, LLC (In re Karim)
...2013).17 Podvinec v. Popov , 168 Ill. 2d 130, 212 Ill.Dec. 951, 658 N.E.2d 433 (1995) ; Nat'l Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Scarlato , 2017 IL App (1st) 161943, 415 Ill.Dec. 788, 83 N.E.3d 44 (cited by Bayview but notably not dealing with the lien provision of the statute).18 All of sec......
-
Nolan v. Hearthside Homebuilders, Inc.
...against a third party, where the third party may possess assets belonging to the judgment debtor. See National Life Real Estate Holdings, LLC v. Scarlato , 2017 IL App (1st) 161943, ¶ 31, 415 Ill.Dec. 788, 83 N.E.3d 44. Thus, the Nolans were permitted under section 2-1402 to issue a citatio......