National City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 245-56.
Decision Date | 16 July 1958 |
Docket Number | No. 245-56.,245-56. |
Citation | 163 F. Supp. 846,143 Ct. Cl. 154 |
Parties | The NATIONAL CITY BANK OF EVANSVILLE, a Corporation, v. UNITED STATES. |
Court | U.S. Claims Court |
Kathryn H. Baldwin, Washington, D. C., with whom was Asst. Atty. Gen. George Cochran Doub, for defendant.
This case comes before the court on cross-motions for summary judgment.
Plaintiff, as assignee on three defaulted contracts, sues for the alleged unpaid balance due at the time of termination for default, plaintiff's claim being that the defendant could not use any of such balances for completion of the work, since it would in effect be a benefit to the sureties, who had given plaintiff a subrogation agreement.
The facts are summarized as follows: On November 26, 1952, Regent Contracting Company, a co-partnership consisting of Raymond W. Ewell, Henry Tuller, Julie Tuller and Ralph I. Tuller, entered into Contract NOy-74886 with the United States Department of the Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks, for the construction of an enlisted men's barracks and subsistence building at the United States Naval Air Station, Oceana, Virginia, at a contract price of $2,700,000, which was subsequently increased to $2,762,089.15. The contractor gave performance and payment bonds in the respective amounts of $2,700,000 and $1,080,000, on which Seaboard Surety Company, Employers Reinsurance Corporation, Manufacturers Casualty Insurance Company and Pacific National Fire Insurance Company were co-sureties.
Under the terms of the contract the contractor was to commence work on December 1, 1952, and complete the work on December 1, 1953, which latter date was modified to July 14, 1954; and provision was made for the assessment, in accordance with article 11 of the contract, of liquidated damages in the amount of $995 for each calendar day of delay.
Defendant received notice of assignment to plaintiff of all moneys due to become due under said contract, and receipt of said notice, together with an accompanying instrument as assignment, was acknowledged by defendant on December 15, 1952. Thereafter certain progress payments on said contract were made to plaintiff pursuant to said assignment.
On August 26, 1953, said Regent Contracting Company, a co-partnership, entered into Contract NOy-75695 with the United States Department of the Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks, for the construction of a 10-bed infirmary at the United States Naval Air Station, Oceana, Virginia, at a contract price of $270,000, which was subsequently decreased to $269,853. The contractor gave performance and payment bonds in the respective amounts of $270,000 and $135,000, on which said Pacific National Fire Insurance Company was the surety.
Under the terms of the contracts the contractor was to commence work on September 1, 1953, and complete the work on May 9, 1954, and provision was made for the assessment, in accordance with article 11 of the contract, of liquidated damages in the amount of $100 per each calendar day of delay.
Defendant received notice of assignment to plaintiff of all moneys due or to become due under said contract, and receipt of said notice, together with an accompanying instrument of assignment, was acknowledged by the defendant on October 5, 1953. Thereafter certain progress payments on said contract were made to plaintiff pursuant to said assignment.
On January 15, 1954, Regent Contracting Company, Inc. entered into Contract NOy-74835 with the United States Department of the Navy, Bureau of Yards and Docks, for the construction of a steam generating plant at the United States Naval Air Station, Oceana, Virginia, at a contract price of $338,000, which was subsequently increased to $350,423. The contractor gave performance and payment bonds in the respective amounts of $338,000 and $169,000, on which American Fidelity Company and The New Hampshire Fire Insurance Company were co-sureties.
Defendant received notice of assignment to plaintiff of all moneys due or to become due under said contract, and receipt of said notice, together with an accompanying instrument of assignment, was acknowledged by defendant on February 17, 1954. Thereafter certain progress payments on said contract were made to plaintiff pursuant to said assignment.
All of the Contracts NOy-74886, NOy-75695, and NOy-74835 contained the following provisions:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Investment Co. of the Southwest v. Reese
...the assignor, and that by assignment the assignee could acquire no greater rights than its assignor." (quoting National City Bank v. United States, 163 F.Supp. 846, 852 (1958)); see also Restatement of Contracts Sec. 167(1) However, the aphorism that the assignee stands in the shoes of the ......
-
Fanelli v. United States
...See 28 U.S.C. § 1491(a)(1) (providing jurisdiction for claims against the United States); see also Nat'l City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 163 F. Supp. 846, 852 (Ct. Cl. 1958) ("It is well established that . . . a controversy between private parties could not be entertained [in this......
-
Proxtronics Dosimetry, LLC v. United States, 15-1589
...(requiring that the United States be designated as the defendant in the Court of Federal Claims); Nat'l City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 163 F. Supp. 846, 852 (Ct. Cl. 1958) ("It is well established that the jurisdiction of this court extends only to claims against the United State......
-
Capelouto v. U.S.
...588 (1941) (noting that this court "is without jurisdiction of any suit brought against private parties"); Nat'l City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 143 Ct. Cl. 154, 164 (1958) ("It is well established that the jurisdiction of this court extends only to claims against the United State......
-
29 C.F.R. § 4.187 Recovery of Underpayments
...B-178198, August 30, 1973; 56 Comp. Gen. 499 (1977); 55 Comp. Gen. 744 (1976); The National City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 143 Ct. Cl. 154, 163 Supp. 846 (1958); National Surety Corporation v. United States, 132 Ct. Cl. 724, 135 F. Supp. 381 (1955), cert. denied, 350 U.S. 902.) (......
-
29 C.F.R. § 4.187 Recovery of Underpayments
...B-178198, August 30, 1973; 56 Comp. Gen. 499 (1977); 55 Comp. Gen. 744 (1976); The National City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 143 Ct. Cl. 154, 163 Supp. 846 (1958); National Surety Corporation v. United States, 132 Ct. Cl. 724, 135 F. Supp. 381 (1955), cert. denied, 350 U.S. 902.) (......
-
29 C.F.R. § 4.187 Recovery of Underpayments
...B-178198, August 30, 1973; 56 Comp. Gen. 499 (1977); 55 Comp. Gen. 744 (1976); The National City Bank of Evansville v. United States, 143 Ct. Cl. 154, 163 Supp. 846 (1958); National Surety Corporation v. United States, 132 Ct. Cl. 724, 135 F. Supp. 381 (1955), cert. denied, 350 U.S. 902.) (......