Nulter v. State Rd. Comm'n Of West Va., C. C. No. 579.

Citation194 S.E. 270
Decision Date15 December 1937
Docket NumberC. C. No. 579.
CourtSupreme Court of West Virginia
PartiesNULTER. v. STATE ROAD COMMISSION OF WEST VIRGINIA et al.
Dissenting opinion.

For majority opinion, see 193 S.E. 549.

RILEY, Judge (dissenting).

It is with regret that I dissent from the majority opinion in so far as that opinion undertakes to extend the operation of the "Financial Responsibility Law" contained in chapter 61 of the Acts of the West Virginia Legislature of 1935, to a judgment rendered by a court outside the territorial limits of the state of West Virginia. This act provides that upon the rendition of a judgment against an automobile operator, a resident of the State of West Virginia, by a court in West Virginia or any of her sister states or the Dominion of Canada, which judgment is not satisfied, and a certified copy thereof having been filed with the State Road Commissioner of the state of West Virginia, his operator's license shall be withdrawn. The statute contains no provision for notice or hearing.

I am fully aware of the necessity of having competent automobile drivers on the roads of West Virginia, and the other states of the country. I am equally alert to the fact that legislation such as this, no matter from what source it came, no matter what motive prompted it into existence, is dangerous in its character and is contrary to the fundamental political philosophy of the United States, as I view that philosophy. The majority opinion has cited no case in which the operation of a financial responsibility act, enacted by any state, has been made to extend beyond the territorial limits of the state in which the judgment is rendered. And I note also that the Attorney General, both in oral argument as well as in the written brief, has stated no case in which such an act has been construed by any court in the United States to that extent. May not the reason lay in the fact there is no authority in the United States which has gone so far as the majority opinion of this court is undertaking to go? At least, I have found no decision of a court of last resort.

This financial responsibility act includes not only the states belonging to the American Union, but it extends to the Dominion of Canada. In discussing this act, we must look beyond the viewpoint of the instant case. If such an act applies to a judgment of the Dominion of Canada, why cannot it be enlarged to extend to a judgment of a South American Republic? Why not to a judgment of the Republic of France, or Great...

To continue reading

Request your trial
36 cases
  • Quesenberry v. Estep
    • United States
    • West Virginia Supreme Court
    • December 22, 1956
    ...City of Huntington v. State Water Commission, 137 W.Va. 786, 73 S.E.2d 833; Nulter v. State Road Commission, 119 W.Va. 312, 193 S.E. 549, 194 S.E. 270; Prager v. W. H. Chapman and Sons Company, 122 W.Va. 428, 9 S.E.2d 880, 129 A.L.R. 1114; Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railway Company v. S......
  • Reitz v. Mealey, 28886.
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Northern District of New York
    • August 14, 1940
    ...200, 35 P.2d 359; State v. Price, 49 Ariz. 19, 63 P.2d 653, 108 A.L.R. 1156; Nulter v. State Road Comm., 119 W.Va. 312, 193 S.E. 549, 194 S.E. 270. The argument that the section conflicts with § 17 of the Bankruptcy Act is more plausible. It seems to us at least very doubtful whether, as wa......
  • State ex rel. Appalachian Power Co. v. Gainer
    • United States
    • West Virginia Supreme Court
    • July 13, 1965
    ...Farley v. Graney, 146 W.Va. 22, pt. 5 syl., 119 S.E.2d 833; Nulter v. State Road Commission, pt. 2 syl., 119 W.Va. 312, 193 S.E. 549 (194 S.E. 270); City of Huntington v. State Water Commission, 137 W.Va. 786, pt. 3 syl., 73 S.E.2d 833. The police power is difficult to define because it is ......
  • City of Huntington v. State Water Commission
    • United States
    • West Virginia Supreme Court
    • January 14, 1953
    ...of the Federal Constitution does not impair the police power of a state.' Point 2, Syllabus, Nulter v. State Road Commission of West Virginia, 119 W.Va. 312 [193 S.E. 54, 194 S.E. 270]. 4. The police power of the state embraces regulations designed to promote public health, public morals an......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT