Nusbaum v. Berlin
| Court | Virginia Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | Cynthia D. Kinser |
| Citation | Nusbaum v. Berlin, 641 S.E.2d 494, 273 Va. 385 (2007) |
| Decision Date | 02 March 2007 |
| Docket Number | Record No. 061277.,Record No. 061784. |
| Parties | Robert C. NUSBAUM v. Candace L. BERLIN, et al. (Two Cases). |
No brief filed by appellees Dennis Berlin, Gloria Bookbinder and Bonnie Pinsker.
Present: All the Justices.
OPINION BY Justice CYNTHIA D. KINSER.
The circuit court entered judgment imposing, as a monetary sanction against Robert C. Nusbaum, an attorney, for his misconduct during a jury trial, an award of attorneys' fees and costs to the opposing parties. In the same judgment order, the circuit court found Nusbaum guilty of criminal contempt of court in violation of Code § 18.2-456(1) and imposed a fine of $250 pursuant to Code § 18.2-457. Nusbaum petitioned for an appeal to this Court pursuant to Code § 8.01-670(A)(3) from the circuit court's judgment imposing the monetary sanction. Nusbaum also appealed the conviction for contempt of court to the Court of Appeals of Virginia pursuant to Code § 19.2-318. We awarded Nusbaum an appeal, certified the appeal of his contempt of court conviction from the Court of Appeals to this Court pursuant to Code §§ 17.1-409(A) and -409(B)(2), and paired the two cases. We will reverse the circuit court's judgment imposing the monetary sanction because a trial court's inherent authority to discipline an attorney does not include the power to punish the attorney by assessing a monetary sanction consisting of an award of attorneys' fees and costs. We will affirm the circuit court's judgment convicting Nusbaum of contempt of court and imposing a $250 fine.
The incident giving rise to both the assessment of the monetary sanction and the conviction for contempt of court occurred on December 12, 2005 during a multi-week civil jury trial in the Circuit Court of the City of Virginia Beach. Nusbaum and Linda S. Laibstain represented the two plaintiffs. Everette G. Allen, Jr., along with another attorney, represented three of the four defendants.1
During Allen's cross-examination of one of the plaintiffs, Laibstain objected several times to alleged discrepancies in certain documentary evidence. Allen countered at one point by stating that Laibstain's complaints were not true. Laibstain then requested a brief bench conference. Nusbaum claims that, during this bench conference, which was not recorded, Allen again accused Laibstain of being untruthful. When the bench conference concluded, the circuit court took a recess. After the jury left the courtroom, the circuit court admonished the attorneys by stating:
Ladies and gentlemen, the [c]ourt is not going to tolerate the lack of civility between and among the lawyers. It's uncalled for. And with any objection that is required by any or all lawyers, the [c]ourt will hear the motion and make the decision.
. . . .
And any movement towards touching or shoving will be dealt with properly.
Following additional cross-examination of that plaintiff and a subsequent luncheon recess, the circuit court informed counsel and the parties, outside the presence of the jury, that the bailiff had advised the court about an incident that had occurred immediately after the bench conference earlier that morning. The court then asked the bailiff to state on the record what she had observed. The court offered to place the bailiff under oath, but no one responded. The bailiff then gave this statement in open court:
[W]hile all parties were at the side bar . . ., I saw Mr. Nusbaum get in Mr. Allen's face. Mr. Allen backed up, but he couldn't go any further because his back was to my podium, and I saw Mr. Nusbaum get in his face and shove him with the elbow. And I grabbed Mr. Nusbaum by his forearm, and I said, that was inappropriate. You will not do that again. And [Mr. Nusbaum] stated to me, "I thought it was appropriate."
The circuit court inquired whether anyone wanted to ask the bailiff questions. Allen responded:
Your Honor, I will just say I didn't take any offense at that. This is—we have some heated discussions sometimes and sometimes lawyers get a little frazzled. And a lawyer bumps up against me, that doesn't bother me.
Mr. Nusbaum has always been a gentleman with me and certainly I overlooked it, didn't think any more about it. But she has—the deputy has recited it the way it happened.
But I wouldn't—I hope the [c]ourt is not troubled by it.
The following colloquy then occurred:
Mr. Nusbaum.
MR. NUSBAUM: When Mr. Allen told the [c]ourt that Ms. Laibstain was not being truthful, I objected to that. You speak about a lack of civility; I can't recall ever telling a judge that another lawyer wasn't being truthful. I could disagree with what he said, I could have a different version testify [sic], but I never accused a fellow lawyer before the [c]ourt of being untruthful, and I resented it very much. And whatever—take a step forward, I would probably do it again under the same circumstances.
I did not mean to threaten Mr. Allen physically and I'm sure he didn't feel threatened, but when somebody says about my co[-]counsel that they are not telling the truth, I feel that it's my duty to step forward and make it clear that I object to that.
THE COURT: Thank you, Mr. Nusbaum.
The jury is sitting in the box and had an opportunity to observe all of this. Now, whether they did or not, the [c]ourt does not propose to make that inquiry of the jury. That doesn't have anything to do with them.
As the bailiff said, the conduct was inappropriate, and the [c]ourt is going to declare a mistrial and charge the plaintiffs with the trial expense for the days that the [c]ourt has been in session.2
. . . .
MS. LAIBSTAIN: Your Honor, the one thing that we would like to do is object to the assessing the cost.
. . . .
THE COURT: . . . It's the most troubling experience I have ever had. . . . I didn't see the occurrence.
I think [the bailiff]—what she said, I have no reason but to accept [her] version of what happened. And the [c]ourt cannot let this thing go without declaring a mistrial and assessing the plaintiffs with the costs of the proceedings for the four or five days we've been in trial.
Is there anything further?
. . . .
MS. LAIBSTAIN: Your Honor, I think that we would like to be heard on that because—
. . . .
Laibstain also advised the circuit court that she wanted to retain counsel to represent her and Nusbaum.
Nusbaum again objected to the basis of the circuit court's decision to declare a mistrial:
MR. NUSBAUM: If Your Honor please, I want to just say a sentence or two for the record about the incident that the [c]ourt saw fit to address his basis for a mistrial.
I'd like the record to show that the incident occurred at—under the bench in a side bar conference where the judge was present, along with all four or five attorneys, and as I understand, Your Honor, you did not observe anything personally?
I do acknowledge that the [bailiff] did take me by the arm as we were leaving to return to our tables and saying what she thought had happened was inappropriate, and I disagreed with her. But beyond that, I don't know that there is any conduct that would possibly be the basis for a mistrial. It was in the presence of the jury. There's no indication that the jury saw it or was disturbed by it.
So my objection is not to the granting of the mistrial, but the basis for it that the [c]ourt is saying.
Allen then asked for "`enhanced sanctions' meaning enough reimbursement to truly cover [the defendants] for the money that they will lose because of this continuance." In subsequently filed motions and memoranda, all the defendants urged the circuit court to use its inherent authority to impose sufficient sanctions so as to make them whole and prevent the plaintiffs from benefiting from their counsel's misconduct. Nusbaum, now represented by counsel, filed a written objection to the circuit court's decision to grant the mistrial and assess costs. Nusbaum argued not only that the circuit court had no basis for declaring the mistrial but also that it did not have the authority to impose costs against an attorney for conduct that did not violate either Code § 8.01-271.1 or Rule 4:12(b). He noted that the proposed monetary sanction, if assessed,...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Johnson v. Com.
...S.Ct. at 2789). These principles recognize that an appellate court is "not permitted to reweigh the evidence," Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 408, 641 S.E.2d 494, 507 (2007), because appellate courts have no authority "to preside de novo over a second trial," Haskins v. Commonwealth, 44 Va......
-
Ervin v. Commonwealth of Va..
...Commonwealth v. Presley, 256 Va. 465, 466, 507 S.E.2d 72, 72 (1998)), nor may we “reweigh the evidence,” Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 408, 641 S.E.2d 494, 507 (2007), because we have no authority “to preside de novo over a second trial,” Haskins v. Commonwealth, 44 Va.App. 1, 11, 602 S.E......
-
Holloway v. Commonwealth of Va..
...63 (2010) (citing Jackson, 443 U.S. at 319, 99 S.Ct. at 2789). We are “not permitted to reweigh the evidence,” Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 408, 641 S.E.2d 494, 507 (2007), because appellate courts have no authority “to preside de novo over a second trial,” Haskins v. Commonwealth, 44 Va......
-
ERVIN v. Commonwealth Of Va.
...Commonwealth v. Presley, 256 Va. 465, 466, 507 S.E.2d 72, 72 (1998)), nor may we "reweigh the evidence," Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 408, 641 S.E.2d 494, 507 (2007), because we have no authority "to preside de novo over a second trial," Haskins v. Commonwealth, 44 Va. App. 1, 11, 602 S.......
-
Scialdone v. Commonwealth–Best Preservation of Error Opinion Ever?
...Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 641 S.E.2d 494 (2007), thereby dispelling one of the great urban legends of the lawNusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 641 S.E.2d 494 (2007), thereby dispelling one of the great urban legends of the law. The facts the case are, shall we say, unseemly. It arose ou......
-
Urban Legends of the Law: The Nusbaum Motion
...default in the wake of Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 641 S.E.2d 494 (2007). I have no idea whether this is true. (I’ve been burned beforeNusbaum motion. As I understand it, there is a perception brewing in some corners of the bar that you need to file a dedicated pleading in order to prot......
-
11.4 Imposing Sanctions
...their opponents from resisting discovery without justification").[138] Va. R. 4:12(a)(4); see, e.g., Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 409, 641 S.E.2d 494, 507 (2007) (affirming $250 fine associated with attorney's conviction for criminal contempt of court); Ford Motor Co. v. Benitez, 273 Va.......
-
Table Of Authorities
...North River Ins. Co. v. Stefanou, 831 F.2d 484, 487 (4th Cir. 1987)....................46 Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 641 S.E.2d 494 (2007).....................................245 O'Boyle v. Commonwealth, 100 Va. 785, 40 S.E. 121 (1901)...............................151 Oakey v. Warren,......
-
2.9 Appellate Review of Sanction Awards
...( it was reasonable for the defendant to believe its defense was warranted by existing law).[204] Nusbaum v. Berlin,273 Va. 385, 408, 641 S.E.2d 494, 506 (2007) (citing Mercer v. Commonwealth, 259 Va. 235, 243, 523 S.E.2d 213, 217 (2000)).[205] Carter v. Commonwealth, 2 Va. App. 392, 396, 3......
-
Table of Authorities
...Nusbaum v. Berlin, 273 Va. 385, 641 S.E.2d 494 (2007)........................................................................331, 343 O'Brian v. Langley Sch., 256 Va. 547, 507 S.E.2d 363 (1998)........................................................................349 O'Brien v. Amtrak, 163......