Oetting v. Heffler, Radetich & Saitta, LLP

Decision Date11 August 2017
Docket NumberCIVIL ACTION NO. 11-4757
CourtU.S. District Court — Eastern District of Pennsylvania
PartiesJAMES OETTING, Individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. HEFFLER, RADETICH & SAITTA, LLP, EDWARD J. SINCAVAGE, EDWARD J. RADETICH, JR., and MICHAEL T. BANCROFT, Defendants.

DuBois, J.

MEMORANDUM
I. INTRODUCTION

This case involves claims asserted by plaintiff James Oetting on behalf of himself and a certified class of similarly situated individuals who received payments from a settlement fund in a long-running multidistrict litigation in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. This case was originally filed as a separate action in that district but was transferred to this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) by Order dated July 25, 2011. Plaintiff seeks damages from defendants for harm suffered by the class due to fraudulent claims made on the settlement fund by a former employee of defendant Heffler, Radetich & Saitta, LLP ("Heffler"), that were authorized by defendants. Plaintiff asserts claims for negligence, accountant malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud.

Presently before the Court are the parties' memoranda and supplemental memoranda on all choice of law issues. For the reasons that follow, the Court concludes that Pennsylvania's statute of limitations, the Missouri savings statute, and Missouri substantive law are applicable to this case.

II. BACKGROUND

The relevant facts as outlined in plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint, attached exhibits, and the underlying MDL docket are as follows. This case arises out of securities litigation following a merger between BankAmerica Corporation ("BankAmerica") and NationsBank. On October 16, 1998, the first of numerous class actions was initiated against BankAmerica. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 1. The Judicial Panel for Multi-District Litigation issued a Transfer Order on February 12, 1999, consolidating all cases relating to the merger for all pretrial purposes in the Eastern Division of the Eastern District of Missouri. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 2. Judge John F. Nangle was the appointed judge. Judge Carol E. Jackson succeeded Judge Nangle upon his death. Id. The multi-district litigation is identified as In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litigation, 99-md-1264 (E.D. Mo.) ("the MDL").

By Order dated July 6, 1999, Judge Nangle certified four classes in the MDL: (1) the NationsBank Holder Class, (2) the NationsBank Purchaser Class, (3) the BankAmerica Holder Class, and (4) the BankAmerica Purchaser Class. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 3. Plaintiff James Oetting was a member of the original NationsBank Holder Class. Judge Nangle approved a settlement between the MDL defendants and all four of the MDL classes by Order dated September 20, 2002. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 24. Under the terms of the settlement agreement, the MDL defendants agreed to pay $490 million to the class members, with $333.2 million allocated to a combined NationsBank class and $156.8 million allocated to a combined BankAmerica class. Id.

Following submission of a proposal to class counsel, Heffler was appointed by the MDL Court as the Claims Administrator for the settlement. Second Am. Compl. ¶¶ 4-9, 25-26. As Claims Administrator, Heffler was responsible for publicizing the settlement, receiving andreviewing submitted claims, identifying valid and invalid claims, and distributing the settlement proceeds to valid claimants. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 25-26. The individual defendants in this case, Edward J. Sincavage, Edward J. Radetich, Jr., and Michael T. Bancroft, were partners in Heffler during the time that the firm oversaw distribution of the MDL settlement fund. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 12.

On May 13, 2004, lead counsel for the NationsBank class filed a motion for partial distribution of the NationsBank settlement fund. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 29; Pls' Joint Mot. for Approval of Distribution of Class Settlement Fund, In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. May 13, 2004), Doc. No. 616. In support of that Motion, counsel submitted an affidavit from defendant Sincavage stating, inter alia, that Heffler had examined and calculated all claims forms to determine that they were properly completed, signed, and documented. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 29. By Order dated June 14, 2004, Judge Nangle granted the Motion and approved a partial distribution of the settlement funds in accordance with the motion and the attached affidavit from Sincavage. Id.; Order, In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. June 14, 2004), Doc. No. 630.

During Heffler's administration of the settlement, but prior to the first distribution of settlement funds authorized by the MDL Court by Order dated June 14, 2004, a then-employee of Heffler, Christian Penta, submitted false claims for payment from the NationsBank class settlement fund. Second Am. Compl. ¶ 28. Thus, the first distribution included "payment(s) of over $5.87 million based on false claims submitted by Penta and his co-conspirators." Second Am. Compl. ¶ 30. The fraud was not immediately discovered.

A grand jury in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania ultimately returned an indictment against Penta and four co-conspirators on charges including mail fraud, wire fraud, and tax evasionrelating to three separate class action settlement funds managed by Heffler, including the In re BankAmerica fund. Indictment, United States v. Penta et al., Criminal Action No. 08-550 (E.D. Pa. Sept. 11, 2008) (Savage, J.).1 The Penta indictment was publicly announced on November 20, 2008, in a press release issued by the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania. Defs' Mem. on Choice of Law Issues ("Defs' Mem."), Ex. G, Press Release, "Six Charged in $40 Million Class Action Fraud," Issued by the United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Nov. 20, 2008 ("Press Release").2

On October 29, 2009, the law firm of Green Jacobsen, former class counsel, filed a Supplemental Complaint with the MDL Court on behalf of the NationsBank class. Supp. Compl., In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. Oct. 29, 2009), Doc. No. 723. The Supplemental Complaint asserted against Heffler claims of breach of fiduciary duty, negligent misrepresentation, accountant malpractice, conversion, and money had and received. Id. On May 3, 2010, more than six months after the filing of the Supplemental Complaint, Heffler moved to dismiss or strike the Supplemental Complaint because, inter alia, the NationsBank class did not first obtain leave of court as required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 15(d). [Heffler's] Mot. to Strike the Supp. Compl., or in the Alternative, to Dismiss the Supp. Compl., In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. May 3, 2010), Doc. No. 745. In response, on May 13, 2010, Green Jacobsen moved for leave to file the Supplemental Complaint. Mot. for Leave to File Supp. Compl., In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. May 13, 2010), Doc. No. 749 & 750. The MDL Court ultimately granted Heffler's Motion to Dismiss and denied Green Jacobsen's Motion forleave to file the Supplemental Complaint by Order dated November 5, 2010, and dismissed the Supplemental Complaint, concluding that although the allegations in the Supplemental Complaint were "connected to" the underlying MDL, the asserted claims were "not similar enough in substance to the claims in the underlying action to justify supplemental pleading." Mem. and Order, In re BankAmerica Corp. Securities Litig., MDL No. 1264 (E.D. Mo. Nov. 5, 2010), Doc. No. 763.

On February 8, 2011, former plaintiff David Oetting filed this lawsuit in the Eastern District of Missouri on behalf of a putative class of NationsBank settlement claimants. Complaint, Oetting v. Heffler, Radetich, & Saitta, LLP, Civil Action No. 11-253 (E.D. Mo. Feb. 8, 2011). The Complaint named Heffler as the sole defendant, and included claims for breach of fiduciary duty, accountant malpractice, and respondeat superior liability based on the conduct of its former employee, Penta. Id. By Order dated July 25, 2011, Judge Jackson dismissed the respondeat superior claim on the ground that it failed as a matter of Missouri tort law because Penta acted outside of the scope of his employment. Memorandum and Order, Oetting v. Heffler, Radetich, & Saitta, LLP, Civil Action No. 11-253 (E.D. Mo. July 25, 2011), Doc. Nos. 19, 20. By separate Order dated July 25, 2011, Judge Jackson transferred the case to this Court on Heffler's motion pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a) for the convenience of the parties and witnesses. Order, Oetting v. Heffler, Radetich, & Saitta, LLP, Civil Action No. 11-253 (E.D. Mo. July 25, 2011), Doc. Nos. 18, 21.

Following the transfer to this Court, on August 16, 2011, plaintiff David Oetting filed the First Amended Complaint. Heffler filed an Answer to the First Amended Complaint on September 13, 2011. By Order dated August 21, 2015, the Court granted plaintiff leave to file and serve a Second Amended Complaint. On September 3, 2015, David Oetting filed a SecondAmended and Restated Complaint, adding James Oetting as plaintiff. The Second Amended Complaint includes five separate claims for relief: a claim of breach of fiduciary duty against Heffler (Count I), a claim of "accountant malpractice" against Heffler (Count II), claims of fraud against Bancroft and Sincavage (Count III), a claim of negligence against Radetich ("Count VI" [sic]), and claims of negligence against "all defendants" ("Count VII" [sic]). The Second Amended Complaint asserts these claims on behalf of individual plaintiffs David Oetting and James Oetting, and on behalf of "a class of all persons similarly situated, who are defined as all members of the NationsBank classes (a) who were entitled to receive a distribution from the [MDL] Action in 2004; (b) who have received a distribution at any time from the [MDL] Action...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT