Otis Engineering Corp. v. Grace

• Decision Date: 20 September 1974
• Docket Number: No. 9938,9938
• Citation: 527 P.2d 322,86 N.M. 727,1974 NMSC 76
• Parties: OTIS ENGINEERING CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation, Plaintiff- Appellee, v. Michael P. GRACE and Corinne Grace, Defendants-Appellants.
• Court: New Mexico Supreme Court

Page 322

527 P.2d 322

86 N.M. 727

OTIS ENGINEERING CORPORATION, a Delaware corporationPlaintiff- Appellee, v.Michael P. GRACE and Corinne Grace, Defendants-Appellants.

No. 9938.

Supreme Court of New Mexico.

Sept. 20, 1974.

Rehearing Denied Oct. 17, 1974.

[86 NM 727] Lon P. Watkins, Carlsbad, F. B. Howden, Los Lunas, for appellants.

A. D. Solsbery, Roswell, for appellee.

OPINION

STEPHENSON, Justice.

Plaintiff-appellee(Otis), alleging it furnished materials and services to certain oil and gas leaseholds for appellants(the Graces), sued the Graces for a money judgment, attorney fees and other relief.

Mr. Grace was personally served with process and Mrs. Grace was served by leaving a copy of the summons and complaint at her purported place of abode in Eddy County after Mr. Grace declined to receive the documents for her.

No pleadings having been filed by the Graces, a certificate of default was entered by the district court clerk on March 22, 1973.This evoked a flurry of motions from the Graces the following day, including a motion from Mr. Grace praying that the default be set aside because he was not indebted to Otis and also a motion to dismiss for failure to state a cause of action upon which relief could be granted.Mrs. Grace moved to dismiss the complaint 'for the reason that she has not been served with process' and also moved, with a supporting affidavit, to set the default aside on the ground that the service of process was invalid.She said she was not a resident of and had no place of abode in New Mexico.

On August 21, 1973, default judgment was entered for the amount of damages prayed, plus interest, attorney fees and costs.

Whether or not the hearing which culminated in the default judgment was to take place at the appointed time was the subject of a misunderstanding between the court and counsel, the details of which are not pertinent to our decision.

The trial court does not appear to have considered the Graces' motions enumerated above when the default judgment was entered.

The default judgment brought forth more motions from the Graces.They moved to set it aside stating the Grace version of the misunderstanding; alleging that 'defendants have a meritorious defense to the claims of the plaintiff;' and that the Graces' failure to appear and defend on August 21, 1973, was due to 'inadvertence or excusable neglect.'Mrs. Grace continued to insist that she had not been properly served with process.

There matters stood when Judge Reese entered the picture.A hearing was held of which all parties had proper notice and at which all parties were represented by counsel.All pending motions were considered.Evidence was taken and legal arguments heard.At the conclusion of those proceedings, Judge Reese decided that he had complete jurisdiction and that the Graces had no meritorious defense.He denied all pending motions and adjudged and decreed the judgment of August 21, 1973 to be and remain in full force and effect.

This appeal followed.We affirm.

This appeal could be decided adversely to the Graces on a number of grounds and a great deal could be written about the procedures utilized and the issues formulated by the pleadings we have recounted.Rules of Civil Procedure 6(b), 55(c) and 60(b)(§ 21--1--1(6)(b), (55)(c), (60)(b),N.M.S.A.1953) are applicable.We have fully expressed ourselves on the operation of these rules, at least insofar as they apply to this case, in Springer Corporation v. Herrera, 85 N.M. 201, 510 P.2d 1072(1973)andRogers v. Lyle Adjustment Company, 70 N.M. 209, 372 P.2d 797(1962).

In Springer we spoke at length on how a trial court should approach a decision as to the setting aside of a default judgment and the manner in which its discretion ought to be exercised.We have nothing to add on...