People's Realty Co. v. Southern Colonization Co.

• Decision Date: 17 December 1919
• Citation: 78 Fla. 628,83 So. 527
• Court: Florida Supreme Court
• Parties: PEOPLE'S REALTY CO. v. SOUTHERN COLONIZATION CO. et al.

83 So. 527

78 Fla. 628

PEOPLE'S REALTY CO. v. SOUTHERN COLONIZATION CO. et al.

Florida Supreme Court

December 17, 1919

Appeal from Circuit Court, Okeechobee County; E. B. Donnell, Judge.

Action between the People's Realty Company, a corporation, and the Southern Colonization Company, a corporation, and another. From an order setting aside a decree pro confesso and a final decree consequent thereon, the Realty Company appeals. Affirmed.

Ellis J., dissenting.

Syllabus by the Court

SYLLABUS

To open up a final decree, after 20 days, in order to let in a defense, it must be shown there was deceit, surprise, or irregularity in obtaining the decree, that the defendant acted bona fide, and with reasonable diligence, that he has a meritorious defense, and that strong and unavoidable circumstances exist excusing the failure to answer at the proper time, and the proposed answer should be exhibited at the time of making the application.

Presumably the order of the circuit court setting aside a decree pro confesso and final decree entered thereon, is in accordance with the requirements of law and equity procedure, and the burden is on the appellant who appeals from such order to clearly show it is erroneous.

Where the showing made and the contents of the order of the court appealed from do not make error to clearly appear, the order will be affirmed.

COUNSEL Dickinson & Dickinson, of Sanford, for appellant.

W. B Crawford and Johnston & Garrett, all of Kissimmee, and P. A Vans Agnew, of Jacksonville, for appellees.

OPINION

WHITFIELD J.

This appeal was taken from an order setting aside a decree pro confesso and a final decree consequent thereon, the order appealed from having been made upon an application presented more than 20 days, to wit, about 60 days after the date of the final decree. An erroneous denial of a motion to set aside a decree pro confesso, and final decree consequent thereon, will be reversed. Jett v. Eldridge, 63 Fla 442, 59 So. 16.

An order setting aside a decree pro confesso and a final decree consequent thereon will be reversed where the showing made in support of the motion is not sufficient to equitably support the order under the principles controlling in such cases. Horner v. White, 46 Fla. 479, 35 So. 662; City of Gainesville v. Johnson, 59 Fla. 459, 51 So. 852; Friedman v. Rehm, 43 Fla. 330, 31 So. 234; Stribling v. Hart, 20 Fla. 235.

An interlocutory order setting aside a final decree, which has become absolute under the statute, for the purpose of permitting a defense to be interposed, will be reversed on appeal, where it is not shown that such circumstances existed as to authorize the action of the court in setting aside the decree, and the action of the court thereon is assigned as error, unless it clearly appears that the bill of complaint is without equity, in which event such order will not be reversed, but the bill will be dismissed without prejudice. Macfarlane v. Dorsey, 49 Fla. 341, 38 So. 512.

The power to open such decree is not to be exercised in cases where the decree has been made absolute in the regular course, and the defendant has been guilty of neglect and failure to give attention to the process of the court. Without the existence of strong and unavoidable circumstances excusing such neglect and laches, the decree should not be opened. Such power should not be exercised upon a mere desire to let in a defense upon the merits. The facts established must show deceit, surprise, or irregularity in obtaining the decree, that the defendant has acted bona fide, and with reasonable diligence, and has a meritorious defense, and the facts constituting such defense must distinctly and satisfactorily appear, and the proposed answer should be exhibited. Stribling v. Hart, 20 Fla. 235.

When a decree pro confesso, regularly entered, has become absolute the complainant...