People v. Portenga
Decision Date | 14 July 1903 |
Citation | 96 N.W. 17,134 Mich. 247 |
Court | Michigan Supreme Court |
Parties | PEOPLE v. PORTENGA. |
Exceptions from Circuit Court, Muskegon County; Fred J. Russell, Judge.
John Portenga was convicted of an assault with intent to commit rape, and appeals. Affirmed.
F. W. Cook, for appellant.
George S. Lovelace, Pros. Atty., and Chas. B. Cross, Asst. Pros. Atty., for the People.
Defendant was convicted of committing an assault with intent to commit the crime of rape. His defense was an alibi. He asks to have the conviction set aside on the ground that the court erred in charging the jury as follows:
It is insisted that the court erred in telling the jury to This language did not instruct the jury to discredit the defendant's testimony, nor did it indicate to them that they should be controlled by any supposed view entertained by the court. It simply cautioned the jury to carefully examine that testimony. Cases might arise in which it would be unnecessary, and perhaps improper to extend such a caution; but, as the record in this case does not contain the testimony referred to, we are bound to assume, under the authority of People v. Tice, 115...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
People v. McCoy
...of charge is not without some background. 2 Gillespie Michigan Criminal Law and Procedure (2d ed) § 9036, p. 1211; People v. Portenga, 134 Mich. 247, 96 N.W. 17 (1903); People v. Tice, 115 Mich. 219, 73 N.W. 108 (1897). There was also no objection below. Nonetheless, it is an unlawful instr......
-
Burtnett v. United States
...v. State, 134 Ala. 145, 32 So. 273; State v. Blunt, 59 Iowa, 468, 13 N. W. 427; Walker v. State, 6 Tex. App. 576; People v. Portenga, 134 Mich. 247, 96 N. W. 17; Rayburn v. State, 69 Ark. 177, 63 S. W. 356. I am unable to discover that the instruction was argumentative in any I think the se......
-
Bennett v. Carr
... ... Certiorari ... to Circuit Court, Muskegon County; Fred. J. Russell, Judge ... Certiorari ... by the people, on relation of John R. Bennett, to review a ... judgment of the circuit court sustaining the refusal of John ... M. Carr, a justice of the peace, ... ...
-
People v. Marcus, 152.
...guilt in your minds, you will acquit him.’ There is no error in this. People v. Resh, 107 Mich. 251, 65 N. W. 99;People v. Portenga, 134 Mich. 247, 96 N. W. 17;People v. Trzil, 235 Mich. 469, 209 N. W. 564. Complaint is made of the testimony of a police officer relating to a conversation be......