People v. Wheeler

Decision Date28 September 1998
Docket NumberNo. 4-97-0037,4-97-0037
Citation299 Ill.App.3d 245,233 Ill.Dec. 535,701 N.E.2d 178
Parties, 233 Ill.Dec. 535 The PEOPLE of the State of Illinois, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Chad E. WHEELER, Defendant-Appellant.
CourtUnited States Appellate Court of Illinois

Daniel D. Yuhas, Deputy Defender, Duane E. Schuster, Asst. Defender (argued), Office of State Appellate Defender, Springfield, for Chad E. Wheeler.

Charles G. Reynard, State's Atty., Bloomington, Norbert J. Goetten, Director, Robert J. Biderman, Deputy Director, David E. Mannchen, Staff Atty. (argued), State's Attys.. Appellate Prosecutor, Springfield, for the People.

Justice GREEN delivered the opinion of the court:.

After a trial by jury in the circuit court of McLean County, defendant Chad E. Wheeler was convicted in November 1996 of one count of first degree murder (720 ILCS 5/9-1(a) (West Supp.1995)) and two counts of aggravated battery to a child (720 ILCS 5/12-4.3(a) (West 1996)). The victim of these offenses was defendant's impaired three-month-old son, Levi Michael Wheeler. The court vacated the aggravated battery conviction and sentenced defendant to natural life in prison for the murder pursuant to section 5-8-1(a)(1)(c)(ii) of the Unified Code of Corrections (Code) (730 ILCS 5/5-8-1(a)(1)(c)(ii) (West 1996)).

Defendant has appealed, contending (1) the proof did not support the verdict; (2) resentencing is required because the statute under which the sentence was imposed was invalid; (3) the court erred in refusing the jury's request for a transcript of defendant's testimony; (4) the prosecution's opening statement and closing argument were improper; (5) the court abused its discretion in allowing, over defense objection, a police detective who was a witness to remain at the counsel table; and (6) the court denied defendant his right to due process when it refused to explain to the jury the meaning of the term "reasonable doubt." We affirm.

The evidence indicated (1) Levi was born to defendant and Shannon R. Gibson in October 1995; (2) Levi weighed only 1 pound 15 ounces at birth; (3) when Levi left the hospital in January 1996, he weighed approximately five pounds and suffered from sleep apnea, which could cause the baby to stop breathing while asleep; (4) as a result of the apnea, the baby's parents were instructed to and did attach an apnea monitor to the child's body when they went to sleep; and (5) the monitor sounded an alarm whenever the heartbeat or breathing reached the levels of danger.

The evidence also indicated the following: (1) shortly after Levi went home, Levi's parents returned him to the hospital when the apnea's monitor alarm went off; (2) hospital testing indicated Levi was developing normally so he was sent home; (3) at 2 a.m. on February 2, 1996, Jeffrey Emmert, an emergency medical technician of the Bloomington fire department, was sent to Levi's house because Levi had reportedly stopped breathing; (4) when Emmert arrived at defendant's house, defendant was in the living room holding Levi, whereupon Emmert checked the child's pulse and breathing and found neither to be functioning; and (5) Emmert then applied cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) to the child and got the child breathing and his pulse returned.

Paramedics Lorinda Ausili and Walter Rudy apparently arrived on the scene as the child's pulse and breathing returned. Ausili testified she noticed an old scar on Levi's abdomen and bruises on his face. Rudy also testified to seeing those bruises. Rudy testified defendant then stated "we're not child abuser's [sic ]" and that his (defendant's) pit bull dog had caused the injuries. Apparently the paramedics inserted a breathing tube into Levi's trachea and attached a heart monitor, and Levi was transported to BroMenn hospital locally and then taken by helicopter to St. Francis Medical Center in Peoria. Levi remained at St. Francis in a chronic vegetative state for three months. On May 3, 1996, he was transferred to a facility in Sycamore and died there on May 26, 1996.

Dr. Jacqueline Nehama admitted Levi into St. Francis Medical Center. Dr. Nehama testified that she noted a bruise above Levi's right eye, an older bruise under his left eye, and bruises around his temple and behind his ear. Levi also had bruises on his chest and a large scar on his abdomen. Based on Levi's condition, Dr. Nehama formed two possible diagnoses: non-accidental trauma or a serious infection. Tests did not locate an infection; rather, they revealed that Levi was bleeding in his brain. Dr. Nehama concluded that Levi's injuries resulted from being severely shaken.

Dr. Nehama consulted with defendant and Gibson to develop a medical history. Defendant and Gibson told Dr. Nehama that Levi was bruised by the family pit bull a few days earlier when the dog ran over Levi and jumped on him. Also, Levi had surgery for a bowel problem, which left a large scar on his abdomen. Levi had been running a low-grade fever for a few days prior to being admitted to St. Francis Hospital, but appeared to be improving.

Dr. Terry Furguile, the director of the pediatric intensive care unit at St. Francis Medical Center, also treated Levi. Dr. Furguile noted the bruises on Levi's body and found a soft spot on top of Levi's head that was full and dense, a condition that is never normal. Testing and X rays revealed blood in Levi's brain, fractured ribs, and fractures in his legs and arm. One of the fractures in his leg was a spiral fracture associated with forceful twisting. Also, an ophthalmologist found bleeding behind Levi's right eye. Based on this evidence, Dr. Furguile concluded that Levi had suffered multiple traumatic injuries most likely caused by violent shaking.

Dr. Furguile stated that Levi's broken ribs were not consistent with an improper attempt to perform CPR; rather, they were more consistent with abuse. He acknowledged that Levi's bruises could have been caused by thrombocytopenia, a blood condition that makes infants susceptible to bruising. Levi was born with this condition, but no longer suffered from this disorder. Dr. Furguile also acknowledged that Levi's broken bones could have been caused by osteogenesis imperfecta, a genetic disease that makes bones brittle.

Dr. Furguile stated that fractures in a three-month-old infant are extremely rare and require great force to inflict. Thus, he concluded that Levi's injuries were not inflicted by the family dog; rather, he was a battered child. Dr. Furguile testified that battered child syndrome was a more severe form of shaken baby syndrome that results in internal bleeding due to violent shaking in conjunction with fractures and external bruising.

Dr. Paul Cruse, a neurologist at St. Francis Medical Center, testified he spoke with defendant concerning Levi's injuries and defendant told him his pit bull dog jumped on Levi a few days before Levi was admitted to the hospital and this caused Levi's injuries. Cruse reviewed the medical evidence and diagnosed Levi with brain injuries consistent with shaken baby syndrome. Based on Levi's other injuries, Dr. Cruse concluded Levi's injuries were not consistent with a dog attack; rather, Levi was a battered child.

Dr. John Patrick Rhode, an ophthalmologist who treated Levi in February 1996, testified that Levi had large pockets of bleeding in his eyes. Dr. Rhode concluded that Levi's injuries were most likely caused by vigorous shaking.

Paul Park, a chaplain in the pediatric unit at St. Francis Medical Center, testified he met with defendant and Gibson the day Levi was admitted. According to the chaplain, defendant reiterated the story regarding the pit bull jumping on Levi and causing his external injuries. The chaplain then explained that he met with those parents the following Sunday and they told him their previous explanation was untrue. The chaplain said defendant then contended (1) a few nights before the night in question, Levi's apnea alarm sounded; (2) defendant brought Levi into the family room and then went to the kitchen to warm a bottle and have a cigarette; (3) when defendant returned, Levi was on the floor and the pit bull was on top of him; and (4) Levi did not appear injured, so defendant fed him.

Dr. Violette Hnilica, a forensic pathologist, performed the autopsy on Levi. Dr. Hnilica noted that Levi had acute pneumonia and several other diseases resulting from premature birth. Levi's brain was totally scarred with several areas of hemorrhaging. His brain was also shrunken, weighing less than 40% its normal weight, and he had scars in his eyes from retinal hemorrhages. Dr. Hnilica testified that shaking or hitting the head could have caused the injuries to Levi's brain and eyes. Further, she stated that Levi did not have thrombocytopenia or osteogenesis imperfecta. She concluded that Levi's death was consistent with battered child syndrome.

Dr. Larry Bush, the director of the infant apnea center for St. Francis Medical Center, testified that based on the data from Levi's apnea monitor, many real episodes of apnea and low heart rate occurred while Levi was living with his parents. Dr. Bush also stated that defendant and Gibson were informed that they did not have to attach the monitor when Levi was awake. The only exception was when Levi was left unattended. Further, he stated that apnea monitors were commonly used for premature babies.

Dr. Bush testified that on February 2, 1996, the monitor was shut off at 12:37 a.m. and turned back on at 1:34 a.m. At 2 and 2:02 a.m., the monitor's alarm sounded because Levi's heart rate was very slow. Thereafter, the monitor was turned off and on several times. At 2:12 a.m., the monitor sounded an alarm because Levi stopped breathing regularly. This was followed by multiple alarms for a very low heart rate until the monitor was shut off at 2:25 a.m. During this time frame, Dr. Bush noted a seven-second interval when someone administered CPR compressions on Levi.


To continue reading

Request your trial
8 cases
  • People v. Wooters
    • United States
    • Illinois Supreme Court
    • November 18, 1999
    ...this state has traditionally exhibited an acute interest in the well-being of minors. See, e.g., People v. Wheeler, 299 Ill.App.3d 245, 254, 233 Ill.Dec. 535, 701 N.E.2d 178 (1998); see also American Federation of State, County & Municipal Employees v. Department of Central Management Servi......
  • People v. Caban
    • United States
    • United States Appellate Court of Illinois
    • January 12, 2001
    ...court to] grant * * * the State's motion to vacate the sentence." We reject this argument. In People v. Wheeler, 299 Ill.App.3d 245, 252-54, 233 Ill.Dec. 535, 701 N.E.2d 178 (1998), the Fourth District held that section 5-8-1(a)(1)(c)(ii) of the Code of Corrections did not violate the singl......
  • People v. Boatman
    • United States
    • United States Appellate Court of Illinois
    • March 8, 1999
    ...other necessities. Wiggins, 298 Ill.App.3d at 770, 233 Ill.Dec. 18, 700 N.E.2d at 122; see also People v. Wheeler, 299 Ill.App.3d 245, 253-54, 233 Ill.Dec. 535, 701 N.E.2d 178, 184 (1998) (amendment to the Illinois Mortgage Foreclosure Law (735 ILCS 5/15-1101 et seq. (West 1996)) affecting ......
  • Greenlaw v. Department of Employment Sec.
    • United States
    • United States Appellate Court of Illinois
    • September 28, 1998
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT