Peraita v. State

• Decision Date: 06 August 2021
• Docket Number: CR-17-1025
• Court: Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals
• Parties: Cuhuatemoc Hinricky Peraita v. State of Alabama

Cuhuatemoc Hinricky Peraita v. State of Alabama

No. CR-17-1025

Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals

August 6, 2021

Appeal from Escambia Circuit Court (CC-00-293.60)

COLE JUDGE

Cuhuatemoc Hinricky Peraita, an inmate on Alabama's death row appeals the Escambia Circuit Court's summary dismissal in part and denial in part of his Rule 32, Ala. R. Crim. P. petition for postconviction relief.

Facts and Procedural History

In September 2001, Peraita was convicted of two counts of capital murder for killing Quincy Lewis -- one count because Peraita killed Lewis while Peraita was under a sentence of life imprisonment, see § 13A-5-40(a)(6), Ala Code 1975, and one count because Peraita had been convicted of murder within the 20 years preceding the capital offense see § 13A-5-40(a)(13), Ala. Code 1975.^[1]

On direct appeal, this Court summarized the facts underlying Peraita's convictions as follows:

"[Peraita], Michael Castillo, and Quincy Lewis were incarcerated at Holman Prison on December 10 and 11, 1999. Around midnight, an incident occurred in which Lewis was stabbed several times. Shortly thereafter, he died as a result of his injuries.

"Kevin James Bishop was employed as a correctional officer at Holman Prison and worked from 10 p.m. on December 10, 1999, until 6 a.m. on December 11, 1999. At approximately 11:43 p.m., as officers were doing a body count to make sure all of the inmates who were assigned to Dorm 4 were accounted for, he saw [Peraita] in the dorm. [Peraita] said,' "What's up Bishop, "' and did not indicate that he was scared for himself or Castillo. (R. 966.) Bishop testified that, if [Peraita] had asked to be removed from the dorm, he would have been placed in segregation in a cell by himself for his protection until the situation could be investigated. After the body count was completed, the lights were turned down for the night so that only about one-half of the lights were on.

"Charles Smith was incarcerated at Holman Prison on the night of the offense and knew [Peraita], Castillo, and Lewis. Five or six days before the offense occurred, he had seen the knife that was used to stab Lewis in a paper bag at the foot of Lewis'[s] bed. He testified that he had heard Lewis tell [Peraita] to get the knife out of the bag and that [Peraita] had taken the knife and hidden it under his clothes.

"Shortly before midnight and after the body count on the night the offense occurred, Smith saw Castillo and Lewis together. Lewis was walking toward the television room, but he stopped and sat on a bed across from Castillo's bed where Castillo was sitting. When he did, [Peraita], who was sitting on a box that was between the beds, got up to walk away. As [Peraita] walked between Castillo and Lewis, Lewis slapped him. [Peraita] continued to walk to his own bed. Smith testified that, after Lewis slapped [Peraita], the other inmates were expecting something else to happen. He explained that some sort of response is common in a prison when one inmate slaps another inmate.

"Smith testified that [Peraita] stayed at his bunk for two or three minutes and then returned to the box on which he had previously been sitting. After about three to five minutes, [Peraita] stood up and started out like he was going to leave again. However, he spun around, grabbed Lewis around the neck, and 'snatched his neck back.' (R. 1044.) Castillo then started stabbing Lewis in the neck and in several other places. In the process, he also stabbed [Peraita] in the arm. Eventually, Lewis put a towel to his neck and staggered out of the dorm. As he was doing so Castillo gave the knife to [Peraita]. [Peraita] then 'hit [Lewis] in the side' and said,' "Die, n[___ ]."' (R. 1045-46.)

"Smith testified that [Peraita] and Castillo had paid Lewis two cartons of cigarettes to leave them alone and that he had asked Lewis several times to leave them alone. He also testified that Lewis could not stand the idea of [Peraita] being with Castillo. Finally, he stated that [Peraita] had been sleeping in the bed above Lewis'[s] bed, but that he had changed to a different bed.

"Alvin Hamner was also incarcerated at Holman Prison on the night of the incident and knew [Peraita], Castillo, and Lewis. During the night, he heard some movement and turned to look at what was happening. At that time, he saw [Peraita] 'holding Quincy Lewis around the neck and Castillo standing over him.' (R. 1029.) He first thought Castillo was punching Lewis in the neck, chest, and stomach. However, after more lights were turned on, he saw blood and realized that Castillo had been stabbing Lewis. He testified that Castillo had the knife, but handed it to [Peraita] when the lights came on and officers entered the dorm. He further testified that, as Lewis was falling to the floor, he saw [Peraita] stab Lewis in the side. Lewis subsequently walked out of the dorm and into the hallway, where he again fell to the floor. As [Peraita] walked by Lewis, Hamner heard him say,' "M ___ f ___, die."' (R. 1031.)

"Alphonso Burroughs was also employed as a correctional officer at Holman Prison and worked from 10 p.m. on December 10, 1999, until 6 a.m. on December 11, 1999. When he walked into Dorm 4, he saw Lewis, who was covered with blood, walking from the area around Castillo's bed. [Peraita] and Castillo, who were also covered with blood, were in the same area only a few feet from Lewis, and [Peraita] had a knife in his hand.

"Lewis walked out of the dorm and collapsed during the time Burroughs was escorting [Peraita] and Castillo out of the dorm. Burroughs went to help Lewis, and he told [Peraita] and Castillo to 'go on up the hall.' (R. 952.) [Peraita] and Castillo complied, and Burroughs, another officer, and two inmates picked up Lewis to carry him to the infirmary to get medical attention. Part of the way there, [Peraita], who was still holding the knife, and Castillo turned around. [Peraita] waved the knife and said,' "Drop the bastard and let the bastard die."' (R. 953.) [Peraita], who appeared to be mad, continued to swing the knife and said,' "Y'all get back too or we'll cut you too."' (R. 954.)

"Bishop also saw [Peraita] and Castillo standing side by side in the dorm. Both were covered with blood, and [Peraita] had a knife in his hand. Shortly thereafter, Lewis walked out of the dorm and collapsed. As others helped Lewis, Bishop stayed between [Peraita] and Castillo and Lewis. He testified that he told [Peraita] several times to put the knife down. However, [Peraita] said he would not do so until he and Castillo were in segregation. [Peraita] and Castillo walked part of the way down the hall, but then they turned around, [Peraita] swung his knife toward Bishop, and said,' "Put the bastard down and let the son-of-a-bitch die."' (R. 972.)

"Kevin Dale Boughner was also employed as a correctional officer at Holman Prison on December 10 and 11, 1999. He saw [Peraita], who had a knife in his hand, walking toward the segregation area. [Peraita] and Castillo were '[c]overed with blood, arm [in] arm, walking down the hall at a very brisk pace' toward him. (R. 980.) [Peraita] looked at him and said,' "If you get us to a safe place I'll give you the knife."' (R. 980.) Boughner put them in a holding cell and locked the door, and [Peraita] threw the knife out. Boughner described [Peraita] as 'really pumped up, hyper, adrenaline flowing, just really pumped up, hyped up.' (R. 981.) He also stated that, on two occasions, [Peraita] asked,' "Is he dead?"' (R. 982.)

"Bishop remained with [Peraita] and Castillo while Burroughs, the other officer, and the two inmates carried Lewis to the infirmary. Burroughs testified that, while he was going toward the infirmary, Bishop and Boughner tried to lock [Peraita] and Castillo in separate holding cells. However, he heard [Peraita] say that he and Castillo would not give up the knife unless they were locked up together. Burroughs testified that, after he and Castillo were locked in a holding cell together, [Peraita] threw the knife to the floor.

"Sergeant William James, the shift commander for the segregation area, saw [Peraita] and Castillo, who he described as 'covered from head to toe with blood,' as they were approaching the holding cell. (R. 991.) After he was secured in the holding cell, [Peraita] asked,' "Is he dead?"' (R. 991.)

"Dr. William John McIntyre treated Lewis in the emergency room at Atmore Community Hospital approximately one hour after the offense occurred. He testified that Lewis had six wounds, including a very large wound to his neck, and that he was close to death because he had lost so much blood. He further testified that medical personnel tried to revive Lewis, that they were not able to because the blood loss was irreversible, and that he pronounced Lewis dead.

"Dr. Leroy Riddick, a medical examiner employed by the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences, performed an autopsy on Lewis'[s] body. He testified that Lewis had a total of eighteen separate injuries, including six stab wounds. One stab wound to his neck cut his carotid artery. Another stab wound to the chest went through the chest cavity and caused a lung to collapse. He also had several superficial incised wounds. Dr. Riddick concluded that the cause of death was sharp force injuries from stab wounds and cuts.

"The defense called several inmates to testify on [Peraita]'s behalf. Michael Best testified that he knew [Peraita], Castillo, and Lewis and had seen them interact; that the three seemed to get along well at first, but that the situation deteriorated over time; that Lewis had admitted to him that he had made threats against [Peraita] and Castillo; and that he had discussed those threats with [Peraita] and Castillo. Finally, he testified that Lewis had a reputation for being sexually violent in

...