Pinto v. Alabama Coalition for Equity
Decision Date | 19 May 1995 |
Citation | 662 So.2d 894 |
Parties | 104 Ed. Law Rep. 1403 Joyce PINTO, et al. v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. Joyce PINTO, et al. v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. Robin SWIFT v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. Robin SWIFT v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. Walter ANDERTON, et al. v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. Walter ANDERTON, et al. v. ALABAMA COALITION FOR EQUITY, et al. 1931030, 1931031, 1931141, 1931142, 1931149 and 1931150. |
Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Thomas F. Parker IV and Samuel Adams, Montgomery, John Eidsmoe, Pike Road, for Pinto appellants.
Ted Pearson, Birmingham, for Anderton, Hall and Trucks appellants.
Richard N. Meadows, Denise B. Azar and Ashley H. Hamlett, Montgomery, for Alabama State Board of Education and State Superintendent of Education.
Thomas L. Stewart and Mary H. Thompson of Gorham, Stewart, Kendrick, Bryant & Battle, P.C., Birmingham, for Governor Jim Folsom, Jr.
Joyce Pinto, Robin Swift, and Walter Anderton appeal as class-action representatives from a judgment of the Montgomery County Circuit Court denying their motions to intervene in these actions. We reverse and remand as to Pinto and Anderton, and we dismiss the appeals by Swift.
The factual background of this case was broadly described in Opinion of the Justices No. 338, 624 So.2d 107 (Ala.1993). For the convenience of the reader, the factual statement is reproduced here (quoting the trial court's order as it was quoted in Opinion of the Justices No. 338 ):
624 So.2d at 110-12 ( ).
On March 31, 1993, the court entered in the "liability phase" a judgment, which included the following findings and declarations (as quoted in Opinion of the Justices No. 338 ):
624 So.2d at 165-66 (footnotes omitted).
On April 22, 1993, Governor Hunt was convicted of a felony; he was that day, by operation of law, removed from office, pursuant to Ala.Code 1975, § 36-9-2, and replaced by Lieutenant Governor Jim Folsom, Jr., pursuant to Ala. Const.1901, § 127. On May 28, 1993, the following parties moved to be realigned as defendants in their official capacities: (1) the speaker of the House of Representatives, James Clark; (2) the State superintendent of education, Wayne Teague; and (3) Alabama State Board of Education members John Tyson, Jr., Steadman Shealy, Jr., Dan Cleckler, Ethel Hall, Willie Paul, Betty Fine Collins, Victor Poole, and Tazewell Shepard. On June 8, 1993, Governor Folsom moved to be substituted formally as an official-capacity defendant in the place of former Governor Hunt.
On June 9, 1993, these...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
James v. Alabama Coalition For Equity, Inc.
...litigation known as the "Public School Equity Funding Case." See Ex parte James, 713 So.2d 869 (Ala.1997); Pinto v. Alabama Coalition for Equity, 662 So.2d 894 (Ala.1995); Opinion of the Justices No. 338, 624 So.2d 107 (Ala.1993). They are appeals and cross appeals from a judgment of the Mo......
-
Ex parte James
..."should be free to exercise their discretion," 713 So.2d at 894, with regard to their school-funding duties); Pinto v. Alabama Coalition for Equity, 662 So.2d 894, 900 (Ala.1995) (refusing to allow intervention to "reopen or relitigate the question of the constitutionality of the educationa......
-
Ex parte Melof
...Smith v. Schulte, 671 So.2d 1334, 1347-48 (Ala.1995) (Maddox, J., dissenting); Pinto v. Alabama Coalition for Equity, 662 So.2d 894, 901-10 (Ala.1995) (Houston, J., concurring in the result); Ex parte St. Vincent's Hosp., 652 So.2d 225, 230-31 (Ala.1994) (Houston, J., concurring specially);......
-
Ex parte James
...to review trial court proceedings in what has come to be known as the "Public School Equity Funding Case." See Pinto v. Alabama Coalition for Equity, 662 So.2d 894 (Ala.1995); and Opinion of the Justices No. 333, 624 So.2d 107 (Ala.1993). Those two opinions adequately set forth the facts un......