Randall v. Worthington
| Decision Date | 21 November 1904 |
| Citation | 141 Ala. 497,37 So. 594 |
| Parties | RANDALL v. WORTHINGTON. |
| Court | Alabama Supreme Court |
Appeal from City Court of Birmingham; William W. Wilkerson, Judge.
Action by J. R. H. Randall against J. L. Worthington. From a judgment granting a new trial, plaintiff appeals. Dismissed.
Von. L. Thompson, for appellant.
Walker, Tillman, Campbell & Porter, for appellee.
A judgment granting a new trial is matter of record in the trial court, and on appeal therefrom the judgment should appear either in the transcript of the record proper, or be set out in the bill of exceptions, in accordance with section 434 of the Code of 1896. Nowhere in the transcript submitted on this appeal is there such a judgment set out. The statement contained in the bill of exceptions that "the court granted said motion, and set aside the verdict of the jury and granted the defendant a new trial," is insufficient to present a judgment for review.
Therefore the appeal must be dismissed.
To continue reading
Request your trial
-
Irby v. Kaigler
... ... 619, 12 So. 918; Ewing v. Wofford, 122 Ala. 439, 25 ... So. 251; Craig v. Etheredge, 133 Ala. 284, 32 So ... 65; Randall v. Worthington, 141 Ala. 497, 37 So ... 594; Barton v. Charter Gas Engine Co., 154 Ala. 275, ... 45 So. 213 ... Although ... this ... ...
-
Ex parte Brandon
... ... Irby v. Kaigler, 6 Ala.App. 91, 60 So. 418; Sanford ... v. Life & Casualty Ins. Co. of Tennessee, 26 Ala.App ... 197, 156 So. 858; Randall v. Worthington, 141 Ala ... 497, 37 So. 594; Morgan v. Flexner & Lichten, 105 Ala ... 356, 16 So. 716 ... The ... order entered by ... ...
-
Sanford v. Life & Casualty Ins. Co. of Tennessee
... ... otherwise insufficient for that purpose. Clements v ... Hodgens, 210 Ala. 486, 98 So. 467. Randall v ... Worthington, 141 Ala. 497, 37 So. 594. So the question ... remains: Does an order that motion for a new trial be ... "sustained" show a ... ...
-
Clements v. Hodgens
... ... to this court. Section 2846, Code 1907, amended Gen. Acts ... 1915, p. 722; Randall v. Worthington, 141 Ala. 497, ... 37 So. 594; Dees v. Lindsey Mills Co. (Ala. Sup.) 97 ... So. 647. For the definition of a judgment of a court, ... ...