Robi v. Reed, 97-16909

• Court: United States Courts of Appeals. United States Court of Appeals (9th Circuit)
• Citation: 173 F.3d 736
• Docket Number: No. 97-16909,97-16909
• Parties: , 99 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 2431, 1999 Daily Journal D.A.R. 3183 Martha ROBI, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Herb REED, an individual, dba/Herb Reed and The Platters, an entity unknown; The Five Platters Inc.; John Valano, an individual; J.P. Productions, an entity unknown; Tony Cee Associates, an entity unknown; Cuzin Richard Entertainment Associates, an entity unknown; United Concert Productions, a New York Corporation, Defendants-Appellees.
• Decision Date: 02 April 1999

Page 736

173 F.3d 736 50 U.S.P.Q.2d 1315, 99 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 2431,
1999 Daily Journal D.A.R. 3183 Martha ROBI, Plaintiff-Appellant,
v. Herb REED, an individual, dba/Herb Reed and The Platters, an entity unknown; The Five Platters Inc.; John Valano, an individual; J.P. Productions, an entity unknown; Tony Cee Associates, an entity unknown; Cuzin Richard Entertainment Associates, an entity unknown; United Concert
Productions, a New York Corporation,
Defendants-Appellees. No. 97-16909. United States Court of Appeals,
Ninth Circuit. Argued and Submitted Sept. 18, 1998.
Filed April 2, 1999.

Page 737

Allen Hyman, Law Offices of Allen Hyman, Studio City, California, for the plaintiff-appellant.

T. Christopher Donnelly, Donnelly, Conroy & Gelhaar, Boston, Massachusetts, for the defendants-appellees.

Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Nevada; Lloyd D. George, District Judge, Presiding. D.C. No. CV-95-01029-LDG.

Before: CANBY and KLEINFELD, Circuit Judges, and KEEP, District Judge. ^*

KEEP, District Judge:

This case presents conflicting claims over the rights to the use of the trademark name "The Platters" by individuals associated with the group. In essence, this court must determine which party is "The Great Pretender," and which is not. Plaintiff-Appellant Martha Robi appeals the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of Herb Reed, John Valano, Reed's booking agent, and John P. Productions, Inc., Valano's booking company.

Page 738

The district court held that Paul Robi, as an individual, had no right to use the name "The Platters," which was the name of the singing group of which Robi and Reed were members. Hence, the court held that Robi's purported assignment of this right to Martha Robi was invalid. The court also concluded that Herb Reed has the right to use the service mark "The Platters" to the exclusion of Robi. We affirm the judgment of the district court. BACKGROUND

Defendant Herb Reed founded The Platters in 1953 he was also the manager and one of the group's original singers along with Joe Jefferson, Alex Hodge, and Cornell Gunther. In 1954, Jefferson and Gunther ceased to perform with the group and were replaced by David Lynch and Tony Williams. After this new group had recorded several songs, Zola Taylor joined the group. In August or September 1954, Paul Robi began performing with The Platters, having replaced Alex Hodge. Around 1957, after the group had achieved commercial success, Paul Robi met and later married plaintiff-appellant Martha Robi. Martha Robi has never performed with the group. Paul Robi severed his relationship with the group in 1965, when he was arrested and convicted of felony narcotics possession charges; he did not leave Reed's group for the purpose of starting a new group, nor did Robi return to the Platters group managed by Reed after his release from prison.

Since the late 1960s, there have been numerous disputes concerning the right to use the mark "The Platters," some of which involve The Five Platters, Inc. ("FPI"). In 1956, the members of The Platters group, including both Paul Robi and Herb Reed, assigned to FPI their interests in the name "The Platters" and executed employment contracts with FPI in exchange for equal shares of stock. In 1974, a California Superior Court held that FPI could not enjoin Paul Robi from performing under "The Platters" name, finding that the performers' assignment of their interest in the name to FPI was ineffective.

A later suit was brought by Paul Robi in federal court. In Robi v. Five Platters, Inc., 838 F.2d 318 (9th Cir.1988), this court upheld the district court's preliminary injunction which prevented FPI from further challenging Paul Robi's use of the name "The Platters." After losing at trial, FPI appealed. FPI challenged, inter alia, the district court's cancellation of FPI's registration of "The Platters" mark and the district court's order enjoining FPI from challenging Paul Robi's right to use the mark. This court affirmed the holdings of the district court. See Robi v. Five Platters, Inc., 918 F.2d 1439 (9th Cir.1990). Paul Robi died while that appeal was pending. By stipulation, the parties to that action substituted as plaintiff Martha Robi, Paul Robi's wife and assignee of his rights to "The Platters" name and goodwill. See id. at 1441 n. 1. In sum, our previous decisions did not address Paul Robi's rights to use the name "The Platters" as compared to Herb Reed's, nor did they address Martha Robi's rights to use that name as compared to Herb...