Rodd v. Heartt

Decision Date01 December 1872
Citation21 L.Ed. 627,17 Wall. 354,84 U.S. 354
PartiesRODD v. HEARTT
CourtU.S. Supreme Court

ON motion to dismiss an appeal from the Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana; the case being this:

A steamer having been sold under a proceeding in rem in the admiralty, left in the registry of the court $4337.51, claimed on the one hand by Rodd and several other persons, creditors of the owners, who by one mortgage on the vessel had undertaken to secure all these creditors in a body, and on the other hand claimed by Heartt and others, mariners, furnishers of supplies, and material-men. The claim of Rodd under the mortgage was $4825, and of his co-mortgagees over (in the aggregate) $8000. The claims of the opposing mariners, furnishers of supplies, and material-men were $10,151.

The case coming before the District Court that court ordered that the fund in dispute should be paid to Rodd and the others in satisfaction of the mortgage claims. This gave Rodd, who was the largest of the mortgage creditors, $1498.99 as his pro rata share.

From this decree of the District Court the mariners, furnishers of supplies, and material-men appealed; and on the appeal, the Circuit Court, on the 3d of June, 1872, ordered that the decree of the District Court 'be avoided and reversed;' and decreed that 'the claims of the mariners, furnishers of supplies, and material-men be recognized as superior to those of the mortgage creditors and paid in preference to the latter, and that a new distribution of the proceeds be prepared by the commissioner in accordance with the principles thus laid down.'- A new table of distribution having been prepared accordingly, and reported to the court, the following order was entered on the 6th of June, 1872:

'The commissioner having submitted a distribution based upon the decree heretofore made by the court, it is ordered and decreed that the balance of the proceeds of the steamer, now in the registry of this court, be distributed as follows:'

And then followed the names of the distributees and the pro rata sum awarded to each.

This decree being made, Rodd and his co-mortgagees, by one petition filed in the Circuit Court, on the 15th of June, 1872 (but one Sunday having intervened between that day and the preceding 3d of June), prayed an appeal; and on the same day, the district judge sitting in the Circuit Court, allowed it.

Mr. R. De Gray, for the motion, asked the dismissal of the appeal on three grounds:

First. That the appeal was from a decree of the Circuit Court, reversing a decree of the District Court, and was allowed by the district judge; who, though...

To continue reading

Request your trial
14 cases
  • Gibson v. Shufeldt
    • United States
    • U.S. Supreme Court
    • May 23, 1887
    ...to do with the division of the fund thus created among those having claims against it. To the same class may perhaps be assigned Rodd v. Heartt, 17 Wall. 354, where the appeal, which the court declined to dismiss, was by many creditors, secured by one mortgage for more than $5,000, from a d......
  • Troy Bank of Troy, Ind. v. Whitehead
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Western District of Kentucky
    • December 28, 1910
    ... ... various parties, each receiving less than the ... jurisdictional amount. Shields v. Thomas, 17 How ... 3, 4 (15 L.Ed. 93); Rodd v. Heartt, 17 Wall. 354 ... (21 L.Ed. 627); The Connemara, 103 U.S. 754 (26 L.Ed. 322); ... New Orleans Pacific Railway Co. v. Parker, 143 ... ...
  • Hartman v. Fishbeck
    • United States
    • U.S. District Court — Eastern District of Wisconsin
    • October 5, 1883
  • New Orleans Pac Ry Co v. Parker
    • United States
    • U.S. Supreme Court
    • February 1, 1892
    ...undivided interest in the claim, and it was perfectly immaterial to the appellant how it was to be shared among them.' The case of Rodd v. Heartt, 17 Wall. 354, is still more nearly analogous. In this case, which was in admiralty, a fund exceeding the jurisdictional amount paid into the reg......
  • Request a trial to view additional results

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT