Ryan James Realty, LLC v. Villages at Chester Condo. Ass'n
Decision Date | 27 January 2006 |
Docket Number | No. 2004–689.,2004–689. |
Citation | 153 N.H. 194,893 A.2d 661 |
Court | New Hampshire Supreme Court |
Parties | RYAN JAMES REALTY, LLC v. VILLAGES AT CHESTER CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION and another. |
Cronin & Bisson, P.C., of Manchester (John G. Cronin and John F. Bisson on the brief, and Mr. Cronin orally), for the plaintiff.
Mark E. Connelly, of Concord, by brief and orally, for defendant Villages at Chester Condominium Association.
Wadleigh, Starr & Peters, P.L.L.C., of Manchester (Dean B. Eggert on the memorandum of law), for defendant Town of Chester.
The plaintiff, Ryan James Realty, LLC (Ryan), appeals the order of the Superior Court (Morrill , J.) granting summary judgment to the defendants, Villages of Chester Condominium Association (Association) and the Town of Chester (Town). The court ruled that the unit owners of the Villages of Chester Condominium own the disputed land. We reverse and remand.
The record supports the following facts. On March 11, 1987, the Villages of Chester, Limited Partnership (Declarant) recorded a declaration of condominium (Declaration) in the Rockingham County Registry of Deeds. This Declaration established the Villages at Chester Condominium and stated its desire to build a one-hundred-unit condominium on 209.93 acres. The Declaration provided for initial development of ten two-unit buildings, along with infrastructure such as roads and sewerage, all within the "submitted land." Exhibit A of the Declaration, entitled "Description of Submitted Land for Chester," states the metes and bounds of the submitted land, summarizing the description by reference to a parcel labeled "Phase I" on a site plan map attached to the Declaration. The map shows that Phase I occupied approximately twenty-two and one-half acres. The Declaration reserved the right to expand development of the condominium on "expandable land." Exhibit B of the Declaration, entitled "Description of Expandable Land for Chester," describes by metes and bounds the 209.93 acres excluding the land identified in Exhibit A.
The Declaration states that any development beyond Phase I would require an amendment to the Declaration, and that the Declarant could record such an amendment no later than seven years from the date of the Declaration. On October 22, 1987, the Declarant recorded an amendment to initiate Phase II, which provided for construction of ten additional units and submission of approximately seven acres of the expandable land to the condominium. On May 18, 1988, the Declarant recorded an amendment to initiate Phase III, which provided for construction of ten additional units and submission of approximately seven and one-half acres from the expandable land to the condominium. Phases I, II, and III totaled approximately thirty-seven acres, leaving approximately 172.9 acres remaining in land designated as "expandable" on the site plan map.
First New Hampshire Mortgage Corporation held a mortgage on the property. After the Declarant submitted Phase III, First New Hampshire Mortgage foreclosed on its mortgage and deeded the remaining 172.9 acres to another developer. The property was conveyed multiple times, ending with a conveyance to Ryan in 1995.
In 2003, Ryan petitioned the superior court for a declaratory judgment regarding its right to further develop the 172.9 acres. The court first ordered the parties to submit motions for summary judgment on the issue of title. After considering the parties' motions, the court ruled that the Association, on behalf of the unit owners of the condominium, had title to the 172.9 acres. The court found that the Declarant had submitted all 209.93 acres to the condominium in the Declaration. The court stated that Ryan might have received title to the 172.9 acres if the Declarant had obtained approval from the Chester Zoning Board of Appeals to subdivide the property.
The sole question on appeal is who has title to the "disputed land," i.e., the 172.9 acres remaining of the parcel after exclusion of Phases I, II, and III. Ryan argues that the trial court erroneously found that the Declarant submitted all 209.93 acres to the condominium. Secondly, Ryan argues that the trial court erred by indicating that subdivision approval was required to separate the land submitted to the condominium from the disputed land.
The defendants agree with the trial court that the Declarant submitted the entire parcel in the Declaration. They also argue that, because the Declarant did not formally subdivide the parcel, the Declarant did not create an expandable condominium, and, therefore, submitted the entire parcel in the Declaration.
Since both parties moved for summary judgment and neither contends that there are any genuine issues of material fact, we review the trial court's application of law to the facts de novo . See Hughes v. N.H. Div. of Aeronautics, 152 N.H. 30, 35, 871 A.2d 18 (2005).
Entitled the "Condominium Act," RSA chapter 356–B (1995) (the Act) governs all condominiums and condominium projects. RSA 356–B:2 ; Neumann v. Village of Winnipesaukee Timeshare Owners' Assoc., 147 N.H. 111, 113, 784 A.2d 699 (2001). The Act provides that a condominium is created by recording condominium instruments in the local registry of deeds. RSA 356–B:7, :11 ; Town of Windham v. Lawrence Sav. Bank, 146 N.H. 517, 520, 776 A.2d 730 (2001). The condominium instruments include a declaration of condominium, which defines the rights as among the condominium owners, the condominium association, and the developer. Town of Windham, 146 N.H. at 520, 776 A.2d 730.
If the condominium is an "expandable condominium," the declaration must contain an explicit reservation of the option to add land to the condominium, a legal description of the "additional land," which is the land that may be added to the condominium, and numerous other provisions. RSA 356–B:16, III. "By declaring an expandable condominium, a developer may submit land to the condominium while reserving the right to expand the condominium by later adding more land." Town of Windham, 146 N.H. at 520, 776 A.2d 730. When a developer amends a condominium declaration to submit portions of the additional land to the condominium, the developer transfers ownership of those portions of land to the condominium. Id. at 522, 776 A.2d 730.
In the instant case, the trial court ruled that the Declarant submitted all 209.93 acres to the condominium. To support this assertion, the defendants cite the first page of the Declaration, which states:
The Villages at Chester Limited Partnership is the sole owner of the land submitted herein ... by virtue of a deed [which transferred the entire 209.93 acres].... The Declarant hereby submits the above land and buildings to the condominium form of ownership and use, in the manner provided by RSA Chapter 356–B.
The interpretation of a written document is a question of law, which we review de novo . Frederick v. Frederick, 141 N.H. 530, 531, 687 A.2d 711 (1996).
When interpreting a written agreement, we give the language used by the parties its reasonable meaning, considering the circumstances and the context in which the agreement was negotiated, and reading the document as a whole. Absent ambiguity, however, the parties' intent will be determined from the plain meaning of the language used in the contract.
Lawyers Title Ins. Corp. v. Groff, 148 N.H. 333, 336–37, 808 A.2d 44 (2002) (citations and quotations omitted); cf . RSA 356–B:13 ("a construction conformable with the statute shall in all cases control over any construction inconsistent therewith").
The language that the trial court and the defendants reference comes only from one page of the Declaration. This first page states that the Declarant "submits the above land," which refers to the "land submitted herein." Though this language does not explicitly refer to the entire 209.93–acre parcel, and refers only to land submitted "herein," the defendants argue that this language submitted the entire parcel to the condominium. We disagree.
What the trial court and the defendants failed to consider in their interpretation is that the "land submitted herein" is defined in Exhibit A of the Declaration. Entitled "Description of Submitted Land for Chester," Exhibit A describes by metes and bounds an area that Exhibit A summarizes as "the parcel shown as Phase I" on the site plan map. Exhibit A, therefore, defines the term "submitted land" as used throughout the Declaration as the land designated as "Phase I." In contrast, Exhibit B, entitled "Description of Expandable Land for Chester," describes by metes and bounds the entire 209.93–acre parcel, excluding the parcel described in Exhibit A....
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Glick v. Chocorua Forestlands Ltd. P'ship
...and the context in which the agreement was negotiated, and reading the document as a whole. Ryan James Realty v. Villages at Chester Condo. Assoc., 153 N.H. 194, 197, 893 A.2d 661 (2006). Absent ambiguity, however, we will determine the parties' intent from the plain meaning of the language......
-
Glick v. Chocorua Forestlands Ltd. P'Ship
...and the context in which the agreement was negotiated, and reading the document as a whole. Ryan James Realty v. Villages at Chester Condo. Assoc., 153 N.H. 194, 197, 893 A.2d 661 (2006). Absent ambiguity, however, we will determine the parties' intent from the plain meaning of the language......
-
Czumak v. N.H. Div. of Developmental Servs.
...and the context in which the agreement was negotiated, and reading the document as a whole. Ryan James Realty v. Villages at Chester Condo. Assoc., 153 N.H. 194, 197, 893 A.2d 661 (2006). Absent ambiguity, the parties' intent will be determined from the plain meaning of the language used in......
-
Bae Sys. Info. & Elecs. Sys. Integration, Inc. v. Spacekey Components, Inc.
...parties' intent will be determined from the plain meaning of the language used in the contract.” Ryan James Realty v. Villages at Chester Condo. Assoc., 153 N.H. 194, 197, 893 A.2d 661 (2006) (quotation omitted).Birch Broadcasting, 161 N.H. at 196, 13 A.3d 224 (parallel citations omitted). ......