Rymal v. Woodcock
Decision Date | 06 July 1995 |
Docket Number | Civ. A. No. 90-0237-LC. |
Citation | 896 F. Supp. 637 |
Parties | Theodore R. RYMAL, Jr., et al. v. Larry J. WOODCOCK, et al. |
Court | U.S. District Court — Western District of Louisiana |
Robert L. Dow, Lake Charles, LA, and Donald Coleman Brown, Woodley Williams Fenet Boundreau & Brown, Lake Charles, LA, for Theodore R. Rymal, Jr. and Poscon, Inc.
A.J. Gray, III, Anna R. Gray, Gray Law Firm, Lake Charles, LA, for Larry J. Woodcock, Larco Sales & Service, Inc. and Larco Environmental Services, Inc.
Donald Coleman Brown, Woodley Williams Fenet Boundreau & Brown, Lake Charles, LA, for Robert L. Dow.
Joseph A. Brame, Brame & McCain, Lake Charles, LA, for Scottsdale Insurance Co.
RULING
Before the court is defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment to determine whether Scottsdale Insurance Company has a duty to defend Larry J. Woodcock, Larco Sales and Service, Inc. and Larco Environmental Services, Inc. (hereafter Larco) with respect to patent infringement and state law claims at issue in this case. We hereby find that Scottsdale is obligated to assume Larco's defense of all the claims in this suit.
Applying these precepts to the policy at issue, we find that the endorsement language can reasonably be construed to provide coverage for some or all of the plaintiff's claims. The pleadings include a federal claim of patent infringement and state law claims of unfair trade practices and misappropriation of trade secrets. The applicable endorsement covers "Advertising Injury Liability" which is ambiguously defined as "injury arising out of an offense committed during the policy period occurring in the course of the named insured's advertising activities, if such injury arises out of libel, slander, defamation, violation of right of privacy, piracy, unfair competition, or infringement of copyright, title or slogan." (Emphasis added). Therefore, the question before the court is whether there is a possibility that patent infringement, unfair trade practices or misappropriation of trade secrets is included under the headings of piracy or unfair competition in advertising. We find that there is such a possibility that some or all of the claims fall within the terms of the endorsement.
Both the nature of our inquiry and the gross ambiguity of the contract language strengthen our conclusion. A court must decide whether an insurer is obligated to assume an insured's defense before having all of the relevant evidence at its disposal. Without the benefit of a crystal ball, a court must make...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Heil Co. v. Hartford Acc. and Indem. Co., 95-C-154.
...within the meaning of "advertising injury." Union Ins. Co. v. Land and Sky, Inc., 247 Neb. 696, 529 N.W.2d 773 (1995); Rymal v. Woodcock, 896 F.Supp. 637 (W.D.La. 1995); John Deere Ins. Co. v. Shamrock Ind., Inc., 696 F.Supp. 434 (D.Minn.1988), aff'd, 929 F.2d 413 (8th Cir.1991). In Union I......
-
Delta Pride Catfish, Inc. v. Home Ins. Co.
..."allows an insurer to construe the policy in its best interests no matter what the parties originally intended." Rymal v. Woodcock, 896 F.Supp. 637, 638 (W.D.La.1995). This Court should not endeavor to correct ambiguities within insurance policies; that job falls squarely upon the shoulders......
-
U.S. Test v. N.D.E. Enviromental Corp.
...be included in the coverage, then the policy must be interpreted to obligate the insurer to defend the insured. See Rymal v. Woodcock, 896 F. Supp. 637 (W.D. La. 1995). U.S. Test supports its argument by noting that Louisiana law construes insurance policies liberally so as to favor the ins......
- FIRST COM. CORP. v. Hibernia Nat. Bank, Civ. A. No. 91-2743.
-
Why neither side has won yet: recent trends in advertising injury coverage.
...(25.) See also GAF Sales & Service Inc. N. Hastings Mut. Ins. Co., 568 N.W.2d 165 (Mich. App. 1997). (26.) Rynial v. Woodcock, 896 F.Supp. 637, 638 (W.D. La. (27.) 539 N.W.2d 619 (Minn.App. 1995). (28.) Id. at 622. (29.) 674 A.2d 798, 803 (Vt. 1996). (30.) 84 F.3d 1105 (9th Cir. 1996). ......