Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette
| Court | Oregon Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | HARRIS, J. (after stating the facts as above). |
| Citation | Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette, 100 Or. 11, 196 P. 416 (Or. 1921) |
| Decision Date | 22 March 1921 |
| Parties | SALEM KING'S PRODUCTS CO. v. LA FOLLETTE. |
Department 1.
Appeal from Circuit Court, Marion County; George G. Bingham, Judge.
Action by the Salem King's Products Company against J. W. La Follette. From an order granting a preliminary injunction defendant appeals. Reversed.
This is an appeal from an order of the circuit court granting a preliminary injunction.
Salem King's Products Company, a corporation, began a suit to compel J. W. La Follette specifically to perform a contract for the delivery of loganberries raised by him. La Follette had delivered about half of his 1919 crop to the Equity Queen Canning Company, when the Salem King's Products Company applied for a preliminary injunction. After considering affidavits filed by the plaintiff in support of and by the defendant against the application, the circuit court granted a preliminary mandatory injunction commanding La Follette to deliver to the plaintiff all that then remained of his 1919 crop of berries. This order of injunction was made without requiring the plaintiff to file an undertaking. The defendant refused to obey the injunction, and because of such disobedience he was adjudged guilty of contempt and sentenced to pay a fine. La Follette appealed from the judgment rendered in the contempt proceeding, and he also appealed from the order granting the injunction.
It will not be necessary to restate here all the facts material to this appeal, for a complete account of all the essential facts will be found in the opinion rendered by us on the appeal from the judgment in the contempt proceeding entitled State ex rel. Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette and reported in 196 P. 412.
John Bayne and Roy F. Shields, both of Salem (Smith & Shields, of Salem, on the brief), for appellant.
Prescott W. Cookingham, of Portland (James G. Heltzel, of Salem, on the brief), for respondent.
HARRIS J. (after stating the facts as above).
In the opinion rendered by us in State ex rel. Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette, 196 P. 412, we held that the order allowing the preliminary mandatory injunction was absolutely void for the reason that no undertaking was required of or given by the plaintiff. In the instant appeal La Follette is contending that since the order allowing the preliminary injunction is void it is appealable.
The right of appeal exists only when some statute gives it; and therefore a party cannot maintain an appeal unless his cause comes within the embrace of a statute granting the right of appeal. Sears v. Dunbar, 50 Or. 36, 38, 91 P. 145; Sturgis v. Sturgis, 51 Or. 10, 13, 93 P. 696, 15 L R. A. (N. S.) 1034, 131 Am. St. Rep. 724; Clay v Clay, 56 Or. 538, 541, 108 P. 119, tland v. Nottingham, 58 Or. 1, 4, 113 P. 28; Blumauer-Frank Drug Co. v. H. F. R. of Ore., 59 Or. 58, 112 P. 1084; Macartney v. Shipherd, 60 Or. 133, 134, 117 P. 814, Ann. Cas. 1913D, 1257; Lewis v. Chamberlain, 61 Or. 150, 152, 121 P. 430; State ex rel. v. Simpson, 69 Or. 93, 99, 137 P. 750, 138 P. 467; Livesley v. Landon, 69 Or. 275, 281, 138 P. 853; Baskin v. Marion County, 70 Or. 363, 364, 141 P. 1014; Knight v. Beyers, 70 Or. 413, 419, 134 P. 787.
We must therefore look to our statutes to ascertain whether the order complained of by the defendant is appealable. An action terminates in a judgment. Section 179, Or. L. A suit ends in a decree. Section 409, Or. L. Every direction of the court or judge made or entered in writing and not included in a judgment or decree is denominated an order. Section 534, Or. L. All judgments and decrees are appealable, except judgments or decrees given by confession or for want of an answer; for by the express terms of section 549, Or. L., "any party to a judgment or decree other than a judgment or decree given by confession, or for want of an answer, may appeal therefrom." Some, but not all, orders are appealable; for we read in section 548, Or. L., as follows:
It will be observed that section 548, Or. L., defines the classes of orders which are appealable and further declares that such orders are deemed judgments or decrees. A judgment or decree may be characterized as a finality; and a reading of section 548, Or. L., makes it manifest that the classes of orders therein mentioned either possess or partake of the quality of a finality. This thought runs throughout our judicial precedents; and accordingly it has been held that an order is final for the purposes of an appeal when it determines the rights of the parties, and no further questions can arise before the court rendering it except such as are necessary to be determined in carrying it into effect. State v. Security Savings Co., 28 Or. 410, 417, 43 P. 162; Birkemeier v. Milwaukee, 76 Or. 143, 150, 147 P. 545. It is one which concludes the parties as regards the subject-matter in controversy in the tribunal pronouncing it. If the order in effect determines the suit or action, or if, in some circumstances, it gives a party all the relief he asks for, it may be appealable. Helm v. Gilroy, 20 Or. 517, 26 P. 851; Basche v. Pringle, 21 Or. 24, 26 P. 863; Marquam v. Ross, 47 Or. 374, 381, 78 P. 698, 83 P. 852, 86 P. 1; Giant Powder Co. v. Or. Western Ry. Co., 54 Or. 325, 101 P. 209, 103 P. 501; American Life Ins. Co. v. Ferguson, 66 Or. 417, 420, 134 P. 1029.
An intermediate order which affects a substantial right of a party, even though not appealable, may nevertheless be reviewed upon appeal; but such nonappealable order is brought to the appellate court by an appeal from the judgment or decree and not by an appeal from the order itself. Taylor v. Taylor, 61 Or. 257, 260, 121 P. 431, 964; Anderson v. Robinson, 63 Or. 228, 236, 126 P. 988, 127 P. 546. If therefore the injunction order made in the instant case is not an appealable order, then the only method by which it can be presented to this court is by an appeal from the decree rendered in the suit. Ordinarily an order granting or dissolving a preliminary injunction is not appealable for the reason that it is an intermediate order and is usually temporary and devoid of the quality of a finality. Helm v. Gilroy, 20 Or. 517, 520, 26 P. 851; Basche v. Pringle, 21 Or. 24, 26 P. 863; Fowle v. House, 26 Or. 587, 39 P. 5; Birkemeier v. Milwaukee, 76 Or. 143, 150, 147 P. 545. La Follette urges that the order for an injunction made in this case is appealable for the reason that it was made without jurisdiction and consequently is void; and that the order, being void, is a final order within the meaning of prior holdings.
In some jurisdictions void judgments or decrees are not appealable; but in this jurisdiction a void judgment or decree, even though entered after default, is appealable. Trullenger v. Todd, 5 Or. 37, 38, 40; Askren v. Squire, 29 Or. 228, 232, 45 P. 779; Whelan v. McMahan, 47 Or. 37, 40, 82 P. 19, 114 Am. St. Rep. 906; Oregon Lumber & Fuel Co. v. Hall, 76 Or. 138, 140, 148 P. 61; Service v. Sumpter Valley Ry. Co., 88 Or. 554, 591, 171 P. 202. This court has uniformly applied this same rule to void orders. Deering v. Quivey, 26 Or. 556, 558, 38 P. 710; Therkelsen v. Therkelsen, 35 Or. 75, 54 P. 885, 57 P. 373; Stites v. McGee 37 Or. 574, 577, 61 P. 1129; Sears v. Dunbar, 50 Or. 36, 38, 40, 41, 91 P. 145; Sturgis v. Sturgis, 51 Or. 10, 14, 93 P. 696, 15 L. R. A. (N. S.) 1034, 131 Am. St. Rep. 724; Ore. R. & N. Co. v. Eastlack, 54 Or. 196, 200, 102 P. 1011, 20 Ann. Cas. 692; Clay v. Clay, 56 Or. 538, 539, 108 P. 119, 109 P. 129; Zelig v. Blue Point Oyster Co., 61 Or. 535, 538, 113 P. 852, 122 P. 756; Holton v. Holton, 64 Or. 290, 294, 129 P. 532, 48 L. R. A. (N. S.) 779; Flynn v. Davidson, 80 Or. 502, 505, 155 P. 197, 157 P. 788; Matlock v. Matlock, 87 Or. 307, 310, 170 P. 528.
The doctrine that void orders are appealable is predicated on the idea that such orders partake of the quality of a finality as explained in Deering v. Quivey, 26 Or. 556, 558, 38 P. 710, and in Sears v. Dunbar, 50 Or. 36, 40, 91 P. 145. In Therkelsen v. Therkelsen, 35 Or. 75, 54 P. 885, 57 P. 373, the wife brought a suit against her husband to secure a separate maintenance, and upon her application the court made an order pendente lite directing the husband to pay a certain sum for the support of the wife and a further sum as suit money. A motion was made to dismiss the appeal on the theory that it was a nonappealable order, but this court ruled:
"The allowance in question being without the power or authority of the court to make, the order directing it is void, as an excess of jurisdiction, and is therefore final in its legal significance, and an appeal will lie from it."
Thus it is seen that the holding in...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Cessna v. CHU-R & T, INC.
...was purely a question of law). 12. See, e.g., Henry and Henry, 301 Or. 185, 190-91, 721 P.2d 430 (1986); Salem King's Products Co. v. LaFollette, 100 Or. 11, 19, 196 P. 416 (1921); Matlock v. Matlock, 87 Or. 307, 310, 170 P. 528 13. We express no opinion as to the availability of review by ......
- State ex rel. Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette
-
Lyon v. Mazeris
...Or. 325, 326, 101 P. 209, 103 P. 501; Columbia City Land Co. v. Ruhl, 70 Or. 246, 249, 134 P. 1035, 141 P. 208; Salem King's Products Co. v. LaFollette, 100 Or. 11, 196 P. 416; Winters v. Grimes, 124 Or. 214, 217, 264 P. 359; Timoney v. McIntire, 146 Or. 583, 586, 31 P. (2d) 165. Not in any......
-
State ex rel. Borland v. Yates
... ... v. Multnomah County, 98 Or. 418, 422, 192 P. 654, 194 P. 428; Salem King's Products Co. v. La Follette, 100 Or. 11, 13, 196 P. 416. The ... ...