Sammons v. Higbie's Estate
| Court | Minnesota Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | BROWN |
| Citation | Sammons v. Higbie's Estate, 103 Minn. 448, 115 N. W. 265 (Minn. 1908) |
| Decision Date | 28 February 1908 |
| Parties | SAMMONS v. HIGBIE'S ESTATE et al. |
OPINION TEXT STARTS HERE
Appeal from District Court, Steele County; Thomas S. Buckham, Judge.
Application by Harriet T. Sammons, as executrix of the will of the deceased wife of Delos Higbie, deceased, in the matter of his estate, for the widow's allowance granted by Gen. Laws 1903, p. 581, c. 334. The district court reversed the order of the probate court denying the application, and granted the prayer thereof; and from an order denying a new trial, the executrix of the will of Delos Higbie appeals. Affirmed.
Subdivisions 1, 2, § 1, c. 334, p. 582, Gen. Laws 1903 (now section 3653, Rev. Laws 1905), which provide that certain personal property of a deceased husband shall be ‘allowed’ to his widow, construed, and held to vest in the widow an unqualified right to the property immediately upon the husband's death.
The selection thereof by the widow is not essential to the investiture of the right. The right to the property vests and becomes absolute at the death of the husband, and the selection is necessary only as a designation of the particular property she elects to claim.
The abandonment of the husband by the wife, whether with or without cause, does not, in the absence of a decree annulling or dissolving the marriage, forfeit her absolute rights in or to his property.
If the widow dies before the property ‘allowed’ to her by the statute referred to has been set apart by order of the probate court, or before she has selected the same, the property passes and right of selection survives to her personal representative. L. W. Collins, W. A. Sperry, and W. H. Hallam, for appellant.
Harlan E. Leach, for respondent.
Application was duly made to the probate court of Steele county in the matter of the estate of Delos Higbie, deceased, by plaintiff, executrix of the last will and testament of his deceased wife, for the widow's allowance granted by chapter 334, p. 581, Laws 1903, and denied by that court. An appeal was taken to the district court, resulting in a reversal of the probate court and an order and judgment granting the prayer of the application. The executrix of the last will and testament of Higbie opposed the application, and appealed from an order of the district court denying a new trial.
The facts disclosed by the records are as follows: Delos Higbie and plaintiff's testate, Mrs. Higbie, were married to each other in the state of New York in the year 1864, and thereafter, in 1873, moved to and became residents of Owatonna, in this state. Higbie at all times thereafter until his death in January, 1905, continued an actual resident of this state. There was no issue from the marriage, and at the time of Higbie's death he was possessed of considerable real and personal property. Though his household furniture did not exceed $500 in value, his other personal property was largely in excess of that amount. Some time in 1883 Mrs. Higbie left her husband and moved to New Jersey, where she resided for a time, subsequently taking up her home among her friends in the state of New York, where she died on May 8, 1906, never returning to her husband in this state. So far as the record discloses, there was a complete estrangement between the parties, but the cause thereof, whether by reason of the misconduct of the husband or the voluntary act of the wife without cause, does not appear; but, in view of the conclusion we have reached on the questions presented, this is not important. They never resumed the relations of husband and wife after Mrs. Higbie left the state in 1883. By his will Higbie made no provision for his wife, but gave all his property to his niece, defendant in this action. Subsequent to his death in January, 1906, Mrs. Higbie duly applied to the probate court of Steele county to be appointed administratrix of his estate and for an allowance of temporary support pending the administration proceedings. This was opposed by defendant, sole legatee in the Higbie will, and the application was pending and undetermined in the probate court when Mrs. Higbie died in May, 1906. She made no application to have the wearing apparel of her deceased husband, or the household furniture or other personal property, set apart to her; nor did she in her lifetime make any selection thereof. Her application to the probate court to be appointed administratrix, so far as the property of deceased was concerned, was limited to a request for an allowance for her temporary support. After the death of Mrs. Higbie, plaintiff, her sister, was appointed executrix of her last will and testament by the proper court in the state of New York, and as such she duly made the application which is the subject-matter of this controversy, and which the district court, as already mentioned, granted.
Two question are presented by the assigments of error: (1) When husband and wife have established a residence in this state, can the wife leave her husband and their residence, remove to another state, acquire a residence there, maintain it until her husband dies, more than 22 years, never return to either husband or residence, and upon his death successfully assert a right as his widow to the statutory allowances? That is, is she the widow contemplated by the statutes? (2) If she is such widow during her lifetime and within the purview of the statute, and then dies without attempting to make her selection by filing a petition for the allowance or by any equivalent act, can her executrix assert this claim and make the selection contemplated and secure the allowances provided for by the statute?
The statute in force when the rights here involved accrued, and which controls the determination of the questions presented (chapter 334, p. 581, Laws 1903, now section 3653, Rev. Laws 1905), provides, so far as here material, as follows: Subdivision 4 provides that if, on the return of the inventory, it appears that the value of the estate does not exceed $150 over and above the allowance provided by subdivisions 1, 2, and 3, the whole estate shall be assigned to the widow and children. Subdivision 5 provides that, if the estate amounts to more than the allowances so provided for, ‘the excess thereof shall, after the payment of the funeral charges, and expenses of administration, be applied to the payment of the debts of the deceased.’ The residue, if any, subdivision 6 provides, shall be distributed as prescribed for the descent and disposition of real estate.
1. It is the contention of counsel for appellant that the abandonment by Mrs. Higbie of her husband and his home, continued from 1883 down to the time of his death, was willful and without cause, and a bar to any claim to the property granted her by the statute just quoted; that the allowances there provided for were intended by the Legislature as a bounty in honor of past marriage, to be bestowed upon those only who continued in the relation of wife in fact, and not merely in name, up to the time of the husband's death. It is insisted with earnestness that the statute should be so construed, and, so construing it, that the deserting wife in the case at bar forfeited all right to the allowances, whether they be construed as absolute property rights or as resting in the discretion of the probate court. A number of authorities are cited which seem to sustain their view of the question. Odiorne's Appeal, 54 Pa. 178, 93 Am. Dec. 683;Appeal of Nye, 126 Pa. 341, 17 Atl. 618,12 Am. St. Rep. 873; Kersey v. Bailey, 52 Me. 198; Hollenbeck v. Pixley, 3 Gray (Mass.) 521;Richard v. Lazard, 108 La. 540,32 South. 559. The statutes in the different states vary somewhat in their provisions on the subject (21 L. R. A. 244, note), and the cases just mentioned for the most part evidently involved only such allowances as under the particular statute construed rested in the discretion of the court, and were intended for the maintenance of the widow and children pending the administration of the estate-allowances such as subdivision 3 of our statute above quoted makes provision for. So far as allowances of that character are concerned, we have no serious doubt of the soundness of appellant's claim. Johnson's Estate v. Johnson's Estate, 41 Vt. 467; 18 Cyc. 392. The probate court would be fully justified in refusing an application for support under subdivision 3 by a widow who had abandoned her husband without cause, and lived separate and apart from him for many years, and did not sustain the relation of wife in fact at the time of his death. But the weight of authority upholds the view that dower rights and those allowances of personal property which...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
Krumenacker v. Andis
... ... D. While the will was in process of being probated and the estate was in the course of administration, the respondent, by attorney, filed a petition in the county ... Sammons v. Higbie's Estate, 103 Minn. 448, 115 N. W. 265;Mowser v. Mowser, 87 Mo. 437;Slack v. Slack, 123 ... ...
-
Shanklin v. Boyce
... ... concerning him, and appointed a guardian of his person and ... estate, without notice to him, without his having any ... knowledge of it. Plaintiff contends that this ... ...
-
Carey v. Brown
... ... Action by James M. Carey and others, as administrators of the estate of Edward Carey, deceased, against Robert D. Brown and another, as executors of the estate of Annie ... See Benjamin, Adm'r, v. Laroche, 39 Minn. 334, 40 N. W. 156; Sammons v. Higbie's Estate, 103 Minn. 448, 115 N. W. 265; Stromberg v. Stromberg, 119 Minn. 325, 138 N. W ... ...
-
Carey v. Brown
... ... Action ... by James M. Carey and others, as administrators of the estate ... of Edward Carey, deceased, against Robert D. Brown and ... another, as executors of the ... succeed thereto. See Benjamin, Adm'r, v ... Laroche, 39 Minn. 334, 40 N.W. 156; Sammons v ... Higbie's Estate, 103 Minn. 448, 115 N.W. 265; ... Stromberg v. Stromberg, 119 Minn ... ...