Shackleford v. Campbell
| Court | Arkansas Supreme Court |
| Writing for the Court | HART, J. |
| Citation | Shackleford v. Campbell, 161 S.W. 1019, 110 Ark. 355 (Ark. 1913) |
| Decision Date | 01 December 1913 |
| Parties | SHACKLEFORD v. CAMPBELL |
Appeal from Pulaski Chancery Court; Jno. E. Martineau, Chancellor affirmed.
STATEMENT BY THE COURT.
This is a proceeding by appellant, a taxpayer of Pulaski County against appellees to restrain them from proceeding further in the erection of an annex to the Pulaski County courthouse. The county court deemed it expedient to erect an annex to the present courthouse, and the quorum court made an appropriation for that purpose. Gordon N. Peay was appointed commissioner of public buildings, to superintend the erection of the same. George R. Mann was appointed architect, and, as such, prepared and submitted to the county court complete and detailed plans and specifications of the proposed annex, with the dimensions thereof and the materials of which it was to be composed, with an estimate of the probable cost thereof. The plans were approved by the county court, and the commissioner advertised for receiving proposals for erecting the building, to the lowest and best bidder. In July, 1912 the contract was. awarded to A. O. Campbell at the sum of $ 565,987, he being the lowest and best bidder; and a formal contract was executed to erect the building according to the plans and specifications.
The specifications called for a four-story, fire-proof courthouse building, to be erected on the corner of Spring and Markham Streets, in the city of Little Rock, Pulaski County Arkansas. The proposed building adjoins the site of the present courthouse. The first story was to be of Arkansas granite, and the remaining stories of Bedford stone. The interior was to be a steel frame construction, with brick masonry partition walls, and fireproof windows were to be constructed on the west side, next to the Quapaw Club. After the contract was executed for the erection of the building, and soon after the excavation for the foundations was commenced, certain changes in the construction of the building were suggested. It was ascertained that it was not practical to quarry Arkansas granite in sufficient quantities to erect the building within a reasonable time, and that a delay of more than one year would be caused if the walls of the first story should be constructed of that material. It was agreed that the first story should be constructed of Batesville stone, instead of Arkansas granite, and a deduction in the contract price of $ 2,374 should be allowed the county by reason of the change in the stone. After the contract was made, the county purchased the ground occupied by the Quapaw Club building, and tore down that building. It was then deemed unnecessary to construct the fire-proof windows, and they were changed so as to conform to the other windows in the building. It was also found out that great delay would be had in procuring the steel for the interior work, and this was changed. to reinforced concrete construction, and a deduction, on account of the change in the windows and the change to reinforced construction, was to be allowed the county in the sum of $ 7,180.
The original contract provided, in effect, that the county court should have the right to make any alterations, additions or omission of work or material or in designs and plans, during the progress of the erection of the building, that it should find necessary. It is conceded by appellant that the original contract was executed in conformity with the provision of article 19, section 16, of the Constitution, and with chapter 35 of Kirby's Digest, and that the same is valid in all respects. The county court, by appropriate orders, approved the changes as set out above, and the contract was modified so as to allow them to be made. It is contended by the appellant that these changes were made without authority of law, and that they render the whole contract void. Appellant also contends that the changes were procured by fraud and, on that account, the contract is void. The present suit was commenced on the 1st day of August, 1913, and at that time the change from Arkansas granite to Batesville stone, for the first story, was finished, and the greater part of the changes made in the interior, as provided for in the modifications of the contract, was also completed. Appellees file an answer in which they denied any fraud on their part in making the changes, and alleged that the reduction made on account of the changes is fair and adequate, and represents fairly the difference in the cost of construction. They also claim that under the contract they had a right to make the changes. Other evidence heard before the chancellor on the trial of the case will be stated in the opinion. The chancellor dismissed the complaint for want of equity, and the cause is here on appeal.
Decree affirmed.
Shackleford & Riegler, for appellant.
1. The changes made were not necessary, and were therefore without authority of law. 12 L. R. A. 502; 65 Ark. 550; 82 Ark. 592; 71 Ark. 199; 155 Mich. 11; 16 Ann. Cas. 346; 53 Kan. 358; 1 Pa. S.Ct. 9.
2. Material changes in the contract, or a new contract, could not be made by order of the county court. Constitution 1874 art. 19, § 16; 54 Ark. 645; 5 Ark. 651; 92 Ark. 254; 65 Ark. 552; 37 Mo.App. 466; 22 Ind. 388; 10 Ga. 235; 82 Ark. 592; 11 Col. App. 394; 114 Ga. 245; 11 Neb. 484; 19 O. St. 97; 54 Miss. 240; 48 Pa. 527.
Cockrill & Armistead and Marshall & Coffman, for appellees.
1. The orders of the county court directing the changes in the plans and specifications were authorized by the Constitution and statutes, and are valid. Constitution, 1874, art. 7, § 28; 102 Ark. 277; Kirby's Dig., §§ 1009 to 1023, inclusive; 73 Ark. 523; 57 F. 1030; 24 N.E. 366; 24 N. E. (Ind.) 115; 27 N. E. (Ind.) 612; 63 N. E. (Ind.) 982; 75 N. E. (Mass.) 954; 84 N.W. 430; 125 N.W. 866; 33 N.E. 243; 45 F. 217; 11 Cyc. 485; 32 O. 208.
Statutes usually give county courts the right to build courthouses whenever they think it expedient or necessary, and it is uniformly held that the county court has exclusive power to determine the necessity for the erection, which power can not be controlled in the absence of fraud or corruption, or facts showing it is so manifestly wrong or prejudicial as to create a conviction that it was the result of fraud and a plain disregard of official duty. 137 Ala. 155, 34 So. 17; 39 So. 167; 209 Ill. 142, 70 N.E. 610; 141 Ind. 522, 40 N.E. 1079.
Counsel review the evidence and conclude that the changes made were necessary and not material.
2. The specifications containing the reservation of the right to make necessary changes and alterations were filed in the county court October 16, 1911. The contract containing that provision was approved by the court's order dated July 26, 1912, in which order the contract was spread at length on the record. Appellant filed suit on August 1, 1913, after all the changes ordered by the county court had been practically completed. He is estopped by laches from asserting that the contract is void. 55 Ark. 148.
OPINIONHART, J., (after stating the facts).
Article 19, section 16, of our Constitution provides that the contracts for erecting or repairing public buildings or bridges in any county, or for materials therefor, shall be given to the lowest responsible bidder under such regulation as may be provided by law. Appellant contends that under this provision of the Constitution, and under chapter 35 of Kirby's Digest, the county court had no authority to order the changes made in the plans and specifications, and that the changes, as made, render the contract void. He relies upon the case of Fones Hardware Company v. Erb, 54 Ark. 645, 17 S.W. 7, to sustain his contention; but we do not think that case an authority for the position he has assumed. There, general plans were adopted for building a bridge across the Arkansas River in Pulaski County, and competitive plans and specifications were advertised for and received by the board of commissioners. Each bidder prepared his own plans and specifications and made his bid thereon, and the court said that it was plain that no two of the bids would be made upon the same basis, unless by accident, and therefore, under such a plan, there could be no competition among bidders. This was a palpable violation of the Constitution and statute regulating the erection of public buildings and bridges. Here, complete detailed plans and specifications were prepared by the architect and adopted by the county court. The advertisement for bids was made in accordance with the plans and specifications adopted; and it is perfectly evident that each bidder bid upon the same plans and specifications, and thus competitive bidding was secured.
It is conceded by appellant that the original contract was let in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution and statutes above referred to; but he contends that the modification of the contract was made without authority of law, and that this rendered the whole contract void. The original contract contained a provision that modifications of it might be made. The evidence shows that it is usual to insert in contracts for the erection of buildings of any magnitude provisions for modifications in the contract, so that necessary changes or alterations in the plans of the building may be made, and such clauses have been generally held to be valid when applied to contracts made between private individuals. In the absence of constitutional and statutory prohibition, there seems to be no good reason why such a clause may not be legally inserted in a contract for a public building. The power so to do is recognized in 11 Cyc 485, but the author adds that in no event can the county board or court make important general changes in the plans of the building,...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
- Grant v. Burrows
-
Gatzke v. Weiss
... ... No. 08-415 ... Supreme Court of Arkansas ... December 11, 2008 ... [289 S.W.3d 456] ... Hope, Fuqua & Campbell, P.A., by Ronald A. Hope, David M. Fuqua, and Patrick L. Spivey, Little Rock, for appellants ... Friday, Eldredge & Clark, LLP, by ... v. Clark Cty., 153 Ark. 175, 239 S.W. 740 (1922) (whether a county was obligated to pay on a bridge contract); Shackleford ... 289 S.W.3d 460 ... v. Campbell, 110 Ark. 355, 161 S.W. 1019 (1913) (whether a county court could amend a contract previously entered into ... ...
-
Greenlee County v. Webster
... ... also Kieburtz v. Seattle, 84 Wash. 196, 146 ... P. 400; McMaster v. State of New ... York, 108 N.Y. 542, 15 N.E. 417; ... Shackleford v. Campbell, 110 Ark. 355, Ann ... Cas. 1915D, 753 (annotated), 161 S.W. 1019; Cleveland ... etc. Ry. Co. v. Moore, 170 Ind. 328, 82 N.E ... ...