Shell Oil Co. v. ST. CHARLES SCHOOL BD.
Citation | 848 So.2d 129 |
Decision Date | 28 May 2003 |
Docket Number | No. 03-CA-116.,03-CA-116. |
Parties | SHELL OIL COMPANY v. ST. CHARLES PARISH SCHOOL BOARD, et al. |
Court | Court of Appeal of Louisiana — District of US |
David R. Kelly, David R. Cassidy, Breazeale, Sachse & Wilson, L.L.P., Baton Rouge, LA, for Plaintiff/Appellant.
Andrew A. Lemmon, Lemmon Law Firm, New Orleans, LA, and Roy M. Lilly, Jr., Minden, LA, for Defendants/Appellees.
Panel composed of Judges SOL GOTHARD, THOMAS F. DALEY and WALTER J. ROTHSCHILD.
The plaintiff, Shell Oil Co. ("Shell"), appeals the judgment of the trial court denying its motion for summary judgment and granting the motion for summary judgment filed by defendants, St. Charles Parish School Board and R.J. Lorio, Director of Tax Collection, St. Charles Parish School Board, Sales & Use Tax Department ("St.Charles"). For the following reasons, we affirm in part and reverse in part the decision of the trial court.
This suit arose out of an assessment made on Shell by St. Charles, subsequent to Shell's filing of an amended tax return in 2001. With this amended return, Shell remitted an additional $267,876.19 in tax payments. St. Charles assessed penalties of $68,592.67 (25% of tax) and interest of $81,622.40 (12% per annum), resulting in a total payment of $146,165.53. Shell paid $102,561.62 on December 13, 2001, but refused to pay the excess on the grounds that it represented excessive interest and penalties under La. R.S. 33:2746 and the Louisiana Supreme Court decision in Elevating Boats, Inc., v. St. Bernard Parish, XXXX-XXXX (La.9/5/01), 795 So.2d 1153. Shell paid the remaining amount of $43,603.91 under protest on January 29, 2002; and filed its petition for refund on February 22, 2002. St. Charles filed an answer and reconventional demand on March 25, 2002, requesting an additional 10% in attorney fees. The parties filed cross motions for summary judgment.
After a hearing in July of 2002, the trial court denied Shell's motion for summary judgment and granted St. Charles' motion, dismissing Shell's claims and transferring the funds deposited by Shell, together with interest earned on the deposit, to St. Charles. The trial court further granted judgment in favor of St. Charles for attorney's fees of ten percent (10%). In his reasons, the trial judge stated that:
St. Charles responds that Elevating Boats, Inc. is inapplicable to this case, as it merely held that La. R.S. 33:2746 superceded a parish ordinance, and that R.S. 33:2746 was not at issue in the present case. Furthermore, under La. R.S. 33:28411, local subdivisions may apply La. R.S. 47:1601, La. R.S. 47:1602, La. R.S. 47:1605, La. R.S. 47:1512, as St. Charles did in this case.
La. R.S. 33:2746 provides:
Upon local taxes not paid and delinquent thirty days after the date upon which the tax is due, there shall be an interest penalty of one and one-quarter percent per month on the amount of the tax due, which shall be collected by the tax recipient body, together with and in the same manner as the tax.
In Elevating Boats, Inc., the court considered a St. Bernard Parish Sales and Use Ordinance that provided for a 6% annual interest penalty, a one time delinquency penalty of 25%, and attorney's fees of 10%. The court noted that the La. R.S. 33:2746 "sets the maximum allowable burden for delinquent taxes." Thus, the assessment under the Parish Ordinance was excessive. The Court then remanded the matter to the district court for a determination of the exact amount due.
In Stowe-Woodard Co. v. Lincoln Parish School Board, 36,100 (La.App. 2nd Cir.6/14/02), 821 So.2d 694, writ denied, 2002-2339 (La.11/22/02), 829 So.2d 1049, the court found that La. R.S. 47:1512 allows a political entity to collect attorney's fees of 10% in addition to a maximum interest and penalty of 15%.
The Stowe-Woodard court noted that:
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Anthony Crane Rental, LP v. Fruge
... ... Veron, Jr., John C. Guillet, Scofield, Gerard, Veron, Singletary & Pohorelsky, Lake Charles, Counsel for Applicant ... David R. Cassidy, David R. Kelly, Breazeale, Sachse & ... James M. Wooderson, Lafayette, Counsel for amicus curiae Lafayette Parish School Board ... Lea Anne Batson, Baton Rouge, Counsel for amicus curiae City of Baton ... See also, Shell Oil Co. v. St. Charles Parish School Bd., 03-116, p. 5 (La.App. 5 Cir. 5/28/03), 848 So.2d 129, ... ...
- CARGO CARRIERS v. INDUSTRIAL MAINT. PROD.